+

FYPD Targets for Rebuilding Teams

Get to planting and drafting.

There is an old line about trees that gets passed around whenever someone wants to sound wise about patience: the best time to plant one was 20 years ago, and the second-best time is today. Nobody who says it ever mentions the part in between, where you water a stick in the ground for years, and your neighbors wonder what exactly you are doing out there. Maybe it needs some Miracle-Gro? Who knows, certainly not me.

That is what rebuilding in dynasty baseball feels like. You trade away the veterans, you stare at a roster full of names your leaguemates barely have a profile on, and you wait. So when first-year player draft season arrives, a rebuilding manager should not be shopping from the same list as everyone else. The contender in your league wants the college bat who could be in the majors by next September. You want the player who will still be getting better in 2031, when your window is finally wide open, and theirs could be closing.

That changes the math. Youth, ceiling, and organization become the priorities, while proximity to the big league roster stops being a dominant factor. Pitchers slide, because a teenage arm has a lot of innings and a lot of elbow ligament to get through before he helps you. A prep bat with an ETA four years away is not a flaw here. It is the whole point.

Before the rankings, a bit of housekeeping. This year’s posting class out of Japan and Korea is a strong one, though not a big one. Teruaki Sato, the Hanshin Tigers slugger who won the Central League Triple Crown with a .306 average, 39 home runs, and 106 RBI, leads the pack. Kaima Taira, Hiromi Itoh, and KBO slugger Roh Si-hwan are on the market, too. All four should be FYPD eligible in most leagues once they sign, and all four belong near the top of a contender’s board. Sato will be 28 next season, though, and for a team building toward 2029 or 2030, he is better used as a trade chip than a cornerstone. International amateurs will join the pool once the signing period opens in January and we know where everyone lands. For this exercise, I skipped the posting quartet because they do not offer the biggest bang for the rebuilding buck, and immediate role matters too much for these four.

For everyone else, here are my 10 players for the manager looking to plant that tree today.

SS Grady Emerson, Tampa Bay Rays

2026 (Low-A): 51 AB | .176/.283/.216 | .039 ISO | 21.7% K% | 13.3% BB% | 0 HR | 3 RBI | 2 SB

Do not let the pro debut scare you off. Emerson is the easiest call on this list, and it is not close.

The Rays took him second overall and paid him $9.75 million, the largest bonus ever given to a high school player. He earned it with a senior season at Fort Worth Christian that looks like a math error, slashing .532/.648/1.013 with 31 stolen bases. He is an 18-year-old lefty-swinging shortstop with a projectable 6’3″ frame, a smooth swing, plus speed, and arguably the best hit tool in the class. Scouts consider him a lock to stay at shortstop, which matters more than people think, since the bat only has to be good rather than great to make him an everyday player.

Tampa Bay sent him straight to Low-A Charleston, an aggressive assignment for a teenager, and he looked like an 18-year-old facing pros for the first time. A .176 average over 13 games is not terrible, especially with a 13.3% walk rate from a kid who was in high school in May. The development goal is lift. He needs to pull and elevate more to get to the 25-homer power his frame suggests.

The 5×5 outlook is a shortstop who helps in all five categories, with a realistic ETA of 2029, though Emerson himself has said he wants to be in Tampa by 20. I would not bet against him or that aggressive timeline. In OBP leagues, his approach gives him even more of a cushion.

SS Jacob Lombard, Miami Marlins

2026 (Low-A): 82 AB | .220/.343/.390 | .171 ISO | 39.4% K% | 13.1% BB% | 4 HR | 17 RBI | 11 SB

If Emerson is the safest bet among the teenagers, Lombard is the high-ceiling, low-floor consolation prize with the loudest tools of the bunch.

The Marlins took the Gulliver Prep shortstop 14th overall and kept him home in South Florida. Baseball runs in the family, since his father, George, played in the majors and his brother, George Jr., was a first-round pick of the Yankees. Jacob, 19, has potentially plus-plus power and speed, a 6-foot-3 frame, and the infield feel and arm to stay at shortstop. In his 22-game debut at Low-A Jupiter, he hit four homers and stole 11 bases in 13 tries. It was an early debut that landed on the positive end of the spectrum compared to Emerson’s.

But the power and speed came packaged with the pre-draft concerns, now being realized. Lombard struck out in 39.4% of his plate appearances, and contact against premium velocity was the knock on him before the draft, too. Baseball America noted this is a compounding issue, as both the bat-to-ball skills and the swing decisions point to a 40-grade hit tool. That is a real risk, but it is exactly the type of risk a rebuilding team can afford to take. He has years to sort it out, the Marlins have no reason to rush him, and the payoff if he does is a five-category star at a premium position.

The best-case scenario is a late 2029 arrival, looking for a full-time role in 2030. In points leagues that punish strikeouts, he slides a bit, but in 5×5 roto, the power-and-speed combination is too rare to pass up.

OF Trevor Condon, St. Louis Cardinals

2026 (Low-A): 28 AB | .321/.387/.536 | .214 ISO | 19.4% K% | 9.7% BB% | 1 HR | 5 RBI | 2 SB

As fun as Lombard and Emerson are to watch, Condon has an electric style of play that jumps off the tape, with the wheels to match.

He carries a 70-grade run tool, one of the best in the class, and backs it up with what may be the best mix of hitting ability and speed in this high school crop. He hit .504 as a senior at Etowah High School, won Georgia’s Gatorade Player of the Year award, led his team to a state title, and then signed with the Cardinals for $5.16 million as the 13th overall pick.

The swing is unconventional, with a look that reminds some evaluators of Corbin Carroll, and the power is the unanswered question in a 5-foot-11, 178-pound frame. But the 18-year-old went to Low-A Palm Beach and hit .321 with a homer and three doubles in seven games, a promising sign that the hit tool is ready to travel. It is a tiny sample, of course, but it is the right kind of tiny sample.

The dream is a leadoff center fielder who hits for average and swipes 30-plus bags, with enough pop to make pitchers pay for challenging him, especially if the outfield limitations tested in the AFL carry over to the big leagues. That profile ages beautifully on a rebuilding roster, and his 2029 ETA lines up with a team that is a couple of years away. He fits every format, though his value climbs highest in roto leagues that reward stolen bases.

C Vahn Lackey, Minnesota Twins

2026 (Low-A): 54 AB | .204/.389/.370 | .167 ISO | 22.2% K% | 19.4% BB% | 1 HR | 9 RBI | 5 SB

2026 (High-A): 38 AB | .316/.500/.500 | .184 ISO | 15.4% K% | 26.9% BB% | 2 HR | 7 RBI | 8 SB

I went back and forth on where to slot Lackey on a rebuilding list. He is a 21-year-old college bat who could reach the majors well before the teenagers ranked above him, which runs against the theme. But he is a rare talent who provides immense value behind the plate.

The Twins gave him $9.5 million as the third overall pick, the largest bonus ever for a catcher, after he hit .397/.519/.772 with 20 home runs at Georgia Tech. He even stole 15 bases in college, which is not something you see often from a backstop. I know receiving and throwing out baserunners do not show up in many dynasty leagues, but Lackey’s polished skills make him an extremely safe bet to stick behind the plate for the foreseeable future.

His debut only reinforced the profile. Lackey walked 28 times against 24 strikeouts across Low-A Fort Myers and High-A Cedar Rapids, stole 13 bases in 25 games, and got better after the promotion, posting a .500 OBP in 10 games with the Kernels. The power question is real, and catchers are notorious for slowing down once the grind of the position catches up with them. Still, a catcher who controls the zone this well and runs like this is a long-term asset, and he could be entering his prime right as your rebuild arrives. If your roster is stuck in the gray area between contending and rebuilding, Lackey is the way to go.

In OBP and points leagues, he is a strong candidate to go first overall on this list, because that walk rate will absolutely play. His present tools are so good that I wonder how much room there is for him to improve. But if he slides down to you in the draft, do not hesitate to take the Georgia Tech product.

SS Roch Cholowsky, Chicago White Sox

2026 (High-A): 36 AB | .167/.326/.333 | .167 ISO | 19.6% K% | 15.2% BB% | 1 HR | 10 RBI | 3 SB

The first overall pick lands fifth here, and that has more to do with the theme than with Cholowsky himself.

The UCLA shortstop was a two-time Big Ten Player of the Year, hit 23 home runs as a sophomore and 21 more as a junior, and signed with the White Sox for a record $10.35 million. He is about as polished as amateur hitters get, with plus power, an above-average hit tool, a strong on-base profile, and the defense to stay at shortstop. If you are building for 2027 or 2028 contention, he is the top name on your board.

For a rebuilding team, he is still a very good pick, just a less urgent one. His debut lasted only nine games at High-A Winston-Salem before the White Sox shut him down with right wrist soreness, so the .167 average deserves no weight at all. The bigger knock is that no single tool is elite, and his speed will not do much for your stats on the bases.

That makes him a counting-stat shortstop who could debut in 2028 and give a rebuilding team a decade of production. Just know that you are buying the steadiest asset in the class, not the highest ceiling.

OF/1B Jared Grindlinger, Los Angeles Angels

2026 (ACL): No stats reported.

Slugger Jared Grindlinger did not turn 17 until April. That alone earns him consideration from a rebuilding team, and it only fuels his projection further.

The Angels took the Huntington Beach two-way star 12th overall, signed him for $5.88 million, and plan to develop him as a hitter first, even though his low-90s fastball touches 96 mph, and some scouts preferred him on the mound. I agree with the call. I would rather see that arm strength in the outfield than watch him toil in the minors as a pitcher or an extremely rare two-way player.

At the plate, Grindlinger’s calling card is his feel to hit, with elite bat-to-ball data on the showcase circuit. The power is not eye-popping right now, but it does not take much imagination to see him growing into more. He has a 6’3″ frame with plenty of room to fill out, though right now he hits too many balls on the ground, and his likely home in a corner outfield spot or at first base raises the bar for his bat. Drafting Grindlinger is a bet that his very polished contact skills hold steady or improve while the power makes its biggest gains in the years ahead. His longer levers make for a long swing path, but I see at least two adjustments that could increase his hand speed and improve his load, keeping that contact skill intact as he physically grows.

With a 2030-plus ETA, he is the longest of the long plays in the 2026 draft class. But I like his skills for batting average and putting the ball in play, and the ceiling for power is very high, even if the stolen-base potential is limited.

SS Elliot Lascelles, San Diego Padres

2026 (Low-A): 56 AB | .321/.406/.429 | .107 ISO | 15.6% K% | 10.9% BB% | 0 HR | 5 RBI | 6 SB

If there is one name on this list I think could rocket up prospect boards in 2027, it is Lascelles.

The Padres went over slot to sign the 18-year-old for $2.8 million in the second round, the largest bonus for a Canadian draftee this year. The Upper Canada College shortstop was the top Canadian position player in the class, a hitter scouts loved for his approach, bat-to-ball skills, and all-fields swing. He hit .389 for Canada’s junior national team against mostly professional pitching and .394 in the MLB Draft League before the draft, so he was hardly intimidated by older competition.

San Diego challenged him with an assignment to Low-A Lake Elsinore, and he did not skip a beat. He hit .321 with a .406 OBP over 15 games, made contact on 94% of his in-zone swings, and went 6-for-6 on stolen base attempts, one of them a steal of home.

The power is light right now, and his long-term position could be second base rather than shortstop. But his 6’1″ frame has room to add strength, and an 18-year-old who already makes this much contact is the kind of player who climbs lists quickly. Buy now, before he does. He gets a bump in OBP and points leagues, where his approach and low strikeout rate play up.

SS Tyler Bell, Colorado Rockies

2026 (Pro): Did not play (shoulder surgery).

Tyler Bell, a switch-hitting shortstop, turned down the Rays as the 66th overall pick in 2024 to go to Kentucky, became the first Wildcat on the U.S. collegiate national team since 2018, and went 10th overall to Colorado this summer for a $6 million bonus. He has power from both sides of the plate, good swing decisions, and a near-elite glove at shortstop. I do not know how the Rockies plan to climb out of the basement, but Bell could be the guy who helps anchor the infield as they scratch their way up the NL West standings one day.

So why is a 21-year-old college bat on a rebuilding list? Because of the shoulder. Bell tore the labrum in his non-throwing shoulder early in the 2026 season, played through it, and will need surgery that is expected to delay his pro debut by several months. That pushes his timeline back, and it may push his price down with it, which is exactly the kind of discount a patient manager should take.

Contact against breaking balls is the main question once he is healthy. If he answers it, a switch-hitting shortstop who calls Coors Field home is a fantasy asset for a very long time.

3B Bo Lowrance, Los Angeles Dodgers
2026 (ACL): No stats reported.

The Dodgers had the smallest bonus pool in baseball this summer, and they still spent nearly three-quarters of it on one player. That is a strong stamp of approval for Lowrance.

The South Carolina prep infielder went 40th overall, signed for about $3 million, roughly half a million over slot, and passed on a commitment to Virginia to do it. At 6’5″ with a smooth left-handed swing, the 19-year-old has the size and athleticism that make power projection feel like more than a hopeful guess, and he ranked 21st on MLB Pipeline’s pre-draft list.

Like most teenagers his size, Lowrance has a long way to go. He will likely move from shortstop to third base; the hit tool is still developing, and the power that makes him interesting has not shown up against professionals yet. His ETA is 2030 at the earliest.

But I am happy to bet on the Dodgers’ development machine and a frame like this, especially at a price that should land well outside the first round of most FYPDs. If it clicks, you have a middle-of-the-order third baseman that your peers will regret passing on for years.

LHP Gio Rojas, Texas Rangers

2026 (Pro): No stats reported.

I promised pitchers would slide on this list, and nine hitters later, I meant it. But if you are going to take one arm with the long game in mind, take the best high school pitcher in the class.

Rojas is a 6’4″, 19-year-old lefty from Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida, and his senior season was absurd: a 0.58 ERA with 124 strikeouts in 72 innings, capped by 6.2 scoreless innings and 12 strikeouts in the state championship game. The Rangers took him 16th overall and signed him for $4.6 million.

The stuff backs up the numbers. Rojas sits at 92 to 95 mph and touches 98, with a wipeout slider that already misses bats at a high level, and his frame suggests more velocity could be on the way. The changeup is the pitch that will decide whether he is a frontline starter or a two-pitch reliever, and that development takes time. So does every teenage arm, which is the risk you accept when you take one.

His ETA is 2029 at the absolute earliest. For a rebuilding team, he is the one pitcher in this class whose ceiling justifies the wait, and his strikeout upside makes him even more appealing in points leagues that reward punchouts.

Honorable mention

3B/SS Connor Comeau, Texas Rangers: The Austin-area shortstop signed for $2.5 million in the second round, well over slot, and has one of the most advanced prep bats in the class, with power expected to come early. He just missed the cut, but he would be my first add if one of the names above goes before your pick.