Before there were Bo Jackson, Brian Jordan, and Deion Sanders, there was Rex Johnston. There have been 67 men who played Major League Baseball and also played in the National Football League. Johnston is the only one who played for just one team in each league while doing so in the same city. He played 12 games for the Pittsburgh Steelers in 1960 and 14 for the Pittsburgh Pirates in 1964. Even more uniquely, he was also a two-way player in the NFL after the free substitution rule took effect.
The next back is one of the most interesting players in Pittsburgh sports history despite only playing 26 total games across sports! Today we feature, Rex Johnston. #Steelers
— The Pittsburgh Steelers Alumni Collection (@304collectorcorner.bsky.social) 2025-04-06T13:43:18.497Z
“I Look at Your Stats”
Johnston was born in Colton, California, in 1937. He was a two-sport star at USC from 1956-58. In 30 games as a running back there, he rushed for 674 yards in 144 attempts, scoring one touchdown, and caught nine passes for another 85 yards. Unfortunately, his college baseball stats are lost to history.
The Pirates signed him for $40,000 out of college in 1959. He skipped his graduation ceremony and went to the Idaho Falls Russets of the Class C Pioneer League, where he remained the entire season, hitting .275/.378/.355, 2 HR, and 36 RBI in 70 games as a right-handed-hitting and -throwing outfielder. In 1960, his baseball travels took him to Class C Grand Forks, Class B Burlington, and Class A Savannah. His 1960 stats are incomplete; he hit .275 again across the three levels with five home runs and at least 49 RBI in 121 games.
In 1960, the Steelers offered Johnston a contract. He discussed the possibility of playing both sports with Pirates farm director Branch Rickey. When he was the Pirates general manager, Rickey had forbidden Dick Groat to play in the National Basketball Association. This time, as Johnston recalled to Brian O’Neill of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette in 2004, “I’ll never forget what he said: ‘Rex, I look at your stats every day. If you’ve got something else to do, you’d better do it.” I’m not sure what stats Rickey was looking at. At the time, Johnston was with the Grand Forks Chiefs, where he was hitting .300. Of course, Rickey was the same man who told Ralph Kiner, “We finished last with you, and we can finish last without you,” possibly the dumbest reason ever given for trading a seven-time home run champion, but one for which Rickey is mystifyingly glorified.
“Stumbles” or “Fumbles?”
When the Steelers signed Johnston (for “a thousand dollars and some shoes,” he told O’Neill) on September 7, 1960, Jimmy Miller of the Post-Gazette reported that he “generally was regarded as one of the top runners in the Pacific Coast Conference and was selected on the coaches’ PCC all-star team.” He also wrote that the six-foot-one, 195-pounder was “blessed with top speed” and led USC in scoring with 25 points in his senior year, which contradicts his official stats. No photos of Johnston in a Steeler uniform exist. He was finishing the baseball season on team photo day, but we know that he wore number 28. He joined the Steelers in time for the last exhibition game. That night, Chicago Bears defensive end Doug Atkins jumped over him to sack quarterback Bobby Layne. After that, Layne rarely called plays for Johnston.
For the 1960 Steelers, Johnston was primarily a kick and punt returner. In 12 games for the 5-6-1 Steelers, he returned 12 punts for 45 yards and 18 kickoffs for 393 yards. His 21.8 yards per kickoff return may not seem like much, but it was ninth in the NFL. Coaches eschewed “specialists” during that era and had “regular” players handle kicking and punting chores. Deep kicks weren’t as common as they are today, and a 21.8 return generally gave a team good field position.
Things didn’t go as well when Johnston lined up as a halfback. He gained 12 yards in four carries. This included a 17-yard run, so one can imagine how the other three attempts went. Pat Livingston of The Pittsburgh Press wrote that his teammates nicknamed him “Stumbles” because he “couldn’t run an off-tackle play without tripping over his own feet.” They could have called him “Fumbles.” He fumbled five times that season, despite handling the ball only 34 times.
A November 8 report by Livingston named Johnston among many players coach Buddy Parker had tried in the defensive secondary. The highlight of Johnston’s Steelers career was a 38-yard kickoff return against Washington at Forbes Field on November 27. It set up a field goal that extended the Steelers’ lead to 13-7. They went on to win, 22-10.
Back to Baseball
Johnston, who remained Pirates property, joined the Single-A Asheville Tourists of the South Atlantic League in 1961. In July, he announced that he was quitting football to concentrate solely on baseball – and why not? Layne didn’t like him anyway, and at the time, he was hitting a team-leading .324 with 10 home runs and gaining a reputation as a swift defensive outfielder. Pirates GM Joe L. Brown, back from a trip to observe the Asheville club, told Jordan, “He made a catch the other day which I thought was impossible. He went after a line drive, dived through the air for it, the ball hit his glove and bounced out, but he grabbed it with his bare hand before it hit the ground.” Johnston finished the year with Asheville hitting .283/.360/.457, 18 HR, and 66 RBI.
There, Johnston shared an apartment with pitchers Steve Blass and Tommie Sisk. At the time, Blass didn’t know that Johnston had played in the NFL. In 2017, Blass recalled to Post-Gazette columnist Gene Collier, “Rex wasn’t one to trumpet himself. A pretty modest guy. Just one of those guys you meet and you feel good about.”
Johnston got an invitation to spring training in 1962 with a legitimate shot to make the team. A March 9th photo in The Press shows him flying through the air, almost parallel to the ground, snagging a fly ball. On his back was the number 4, previously worn by Kiner and later retired in his honor. Nobody was going to unseat the Pirates’ starting outfield of Bob Skinner, Bill Virdon, and Roberto Clemente. Three rookies beside Johnston vied for the two reserve outfield spots. Among them were Larry Elliot and Howie Goss. Another was trying to make the jump from Single-A to the majors. His name was Willie Stargell. Maybe you’ve heard of him. Earl Weaver and Scott McGregor certainly remember him.
Alas, that same day, Johnston accidentally spiked himself in the leg during a sliding drill. A deep gash in his leg required 14 stitches to close. He still wanted to take batting practice that day and travel with the team for the next day’s game, but manager Danny Murtaugh turned him down. Johnston spent the 1962 season with the Triple-A Columbus Jets, slashing .273/.381/.399, 8 HR, and 35 RBI.
After the season, Johnston’s wife Mary obtained a divorce from him in Los Angeles. United Press International reported that she “told Judge Arthur Crum that her 104 pounds was [sic] no match for her husband’s 220 pounds.” The report didn’t elaborate as to why the difference in weight mattered. The guess here is that they weren’t scrimmaging in the backyard.
A Second Chance
Johnston became a switch-hitter during the 1963 season. Details about his status in 1963 are sketchy. Record-keeping had a few gaps in those days, as nobody foresaw today’s era of information-hungry sports geeks like your correspondent. However, all indications are that although Johnston spent the year with the Jets, hitting .267/.339/.411, 13 HR, and 49 RBI, he may not have been Pirates property. Perhaps Pittsburgh released him after the 1962 season. How else to explain that, after the season, the Pirates traded outfielder Ron Woods to obtain Johnston from Columbus?
Hope springs eternal. Johnston got another invitation to spring training camp in 1964. The Press ran a photo of him and his new wife Judy on March 1st. She wore a Pirates cap. They looked happy. Eight days later, The Press ran a photo of five candidates for the starting left field position. Lined up in a row, in one of those corny pictures seen in sports pages during those more innocent times, were Jerry Lynch, Johnston, Manny Mota, Stargell, and Bob Burda. The caption stated that Murtaugh was most impressed with Lynch and Stargell so far.
Meanwhile, on March 15th, Johnston blasted two home runs as the Pirates defeated the Kansas City Athletics, 15-7. He had a big three-hit game as Pittsburgh beat the New York Mets, 8-4, on March 31. He was hanging around, and he credited switching to switch-hitting when speaking to Lester J. Biederman of The Press. “I was agreeable [to switch-hitting] because I figured I didn’t have anything to lose. I just wasn’t hitting right-handed and felt going to the other side of the plate might give me an advantage. At least it would help me get to first base more quickly batting left-handed, and the move paid off. I doubt I would have been invited to the Pirates camp if I hadn’t shown I could bat from both sides,” he said. Columbus manager Larry Shepard, coach Clyde Sukeforth, and Hall-of-Famer Pie Traynor were effusive in their praise of Johnston. “Official Scouting Reports” from the March 1964 Baseball Digest, culled “directly from the confidential files of big league clubs, uncensored,” was less generous in its evaluation of Johnston: “Just average. Rough road to haul. Tries hard.”
A Pirate At Last
Johnston broke camp with the Pirates. Under the rules in effect during that period, teams began the regular season with 28 players and had to cut the roster down to 25 by May 15th. (Under the current negotiations for the new Collective Bargaining Agreement, the MLB Players Association has proposed something similar.) Wearing number 4, Johnston made his major league debut as a pinch-hitter in the 12th inning on April 15th against the Chicago Cubs, drawing an intentional walk from Don Elston in his lone plate appearance.
He appeared in 14 games for the Pirates, mostly as a late-inning defensive replacement. In 10 plate appearances, he had three walks and no hits. His only start came in Busch Stadium against the St. Louis Cardinals on May 2nd. He started in center field, was 0-for-4 with a walk, and shifted over to left field in the bottom of the ninth of a 5-4 Pirates victory. His buddy Sisk earned the win in relief. The newspaper accounts don’t mention Johnston, beyond being required to list him in the day’s box score. On May 15th, Johnston, Sisk, and Frank Bork were sent to Columbus to reach the 25-man limit. Johnston never played in the majors again.
“I Had a Business to Run”
Sisk’s next game was a start for Columbus against the Atlanta Crackers. He was two outs away from a no-hitter when Atlanta’s Tony Washington doubled. UPI reported, “Outfielder Rex Johnston fell over the fence in a vain effort to catch Washington’s drive.” He was still “trying hard.” But he hit poorly with Columbus, and in 1965, his contact was purchased by the Phoenix Giants. Johnston retired from baseball in 1966 after two years in the San Francisco Giants system.
In September 2017, two years before his death, he returned to Pittsburgh for the first time since he played there in 1960. He took in a Steelers game against the Minnesota Vikings on the 17th and threw out the first pitch at the Pirates game against the Milwaukee Brewers the next night. He explained his absence and his retirement to Collier: “My dad was having some bad health, and we needed someone to help him run his business. We had to make a decision. As to why I’ve never come back to Pittsburgh, I guess it was just that I had a business to run.”