At-Bat of the Week: Freddy Peralta vs Yasiel Puig

In this first edition of a weekly series, Dan McNamara breaks down an epic battle between Yasiel Puig and Freddy Peralta for our At-Bat of the Week!

The word “dominant” does not do justice to the outing that Freddy Peralta put together on this particular day. In typical Freddy fashion, he threw 67 fastballs and only 13 curveballs through his first seven innings, but also totaled an impressive 16 whiffs (12 on his heater) while exhibiting tremendous control and exploring the entire strike zone with his fastball throughout the day. The Cincinnati Reds almost literally couldn’t touch Peralta. Other than an Eugenio Suarez single back in the second inning, the Reds had not gotten a hit; with Peralta’s elite control to this point, he also hadn’t walked a batter. The problem? His team had only spotted him a single run and he had been protecting that lead since the second inning.

The eighth inning began with an easy three-pitch strikeout of Scott Schebler, including two more whiffs on that inexplicably nasty four-seamer. Then Derek Dietrich stepped up and battled Peralta for seven tough pitches (seven more fastballs) and eventually laced a ball into left field which, fortunately for Peralta, was destined for Ryan Braun’s glove. The ball was struck with an exit velocity of 97.2 mph and had an XBA of .360, so perhaps Peralta got away with one, but nonetheless he now had two outs, no one on base, and only 91 pitches on the day. With Curt Casali stepping to the dish, Peralta wanted to put this inning to bed and get back to the dugout as soon as possible to argue with Craig Counsel about going for the CGSO… but Casali had other plans, and he jumped on another first-pitch fastball and ripped it into left field for a base hit.

Smelling blood for the first time all game, David Bell sent out stolen-base-threat Jose Peraza to pinch-run for Casali and called Yasiel Puig from the bench to pinch-hit for Jose Iglesias. Peralta, who had been cruising all game, had just given up back-to-back hard hits on two consecutive pitches late in his outing. With Josh Hader having pitched the last two days and there being no real activity in the Milwaukee Brewers pen, Craig Counsel left him out there to defend the lead he had defended all day, now with a speedster at first base and the go-ahead run standing at home plate.

Brewers lead 1-0, man on first, two outs, Peralta vs Puig… here’s your at-bat of the week.


Pitch #1 0-0




Peralta starts Puig with a pretty soft 91 mph four-seamer low and off the plate that Puig takes for a ball. It’s hard to tell from Manny Pina’s reaction just how bad of a miss that was, but the plan was certainly to go away and test Puig’s patience early in the count. With Peralta on the mound, you’d expect any hitter to sit fastball and look for one to drive. They probably wanted to put this one a little closer to the dish to get Puig to jump on something he’d have a hard time barreling, but no harm no foul.


Pitch #2 1-0




There it was. That was about the pitch Peralta and Pina wanted to start him with; they probably wanted it elevated a touch more. Puig takes a pretty good cut at this ball, but it’s away enough to get him to open up too soon and foul it.

Puig is certainly disciplined at the plate, as evidenced by his 19.9%/9.1% K and BB rates for his career and he loves pitches on the outer half of the dish. In 2018, the vast majority of his swings came on balls that were middle or middle-away, and his best contact came on pitches in those zones. Peralta and Pina clearly had a plan to induce swings during this battle.



Pitch #3 1-1




Peralta makes a mistake here. After slowing Puig down by going away with two relatively soft fastballs, he tries to fire a 94.0 mph laser in the upper third, but he misses middle-middle and is lucky that Puig gets underneath it. From his reaction, Puig knows he should’ve crushed that one.


Pitch #4 1-2




94.7 mph… Peralta’s fastest pitch of the at-bat thus far. Again, him and Pina really want to get Puig to fish on the outside corner, but Peralta barely misses his spot and Puig is up to the task and watches it go wide for a ball.


Pitch #5 2-2




95.5 mph… Peralta dials it up a touch more and paints the outside corner this time. Puig is just about on the pitch, but appears to be a little late once again. He gives his bat a nice lick after this swing, probably an indicator that he’s zeroing in on the outside corner. This was a much better swing than the one he put on the second pitch of the at-bat and if Peralta had elevated this pitch more it would have been really tough for Puig to make contact. Peralta’s reaction is one of confidence, knowing he made a pretty good pitch and that Puig is having a hard time dealing with the uptick in velocity since the first couple of pitches.

It was here that Pina decided it was time for a mound visit — a long one. There was a full 71-second break between pitch #5 and pitch #6 of the at-bat, so Pina clearly had a plan.


Pitch #6 2-2




DANG! 96.1mph… Peralta’s fastest pitch of the game. Puig had a strong tendency to strikeout on elevated pitches in 2018 and with him being late on not only the previous pitch, but also the third pitch of the at-bat, Pina and Peralta knew they could get one by him.



Peralta consistently changed Puig’s eye-level and spent most of the at-bat on the outside corner during this battle, so he and Pina knew that if they came further inside, Puig had no hope of getting the barrel to the ball. Unfortunately, he missed his spot again, as Pina wanted this pitch up and Peralta delivered it middle-middle. Puig was able to get just enough and foul it straight back.

Before pitch #7 was thrown, Puig took a second to himself. He called timeout. Perhaps it was to get Peralta to think a little bit, or maybe it was just to recalibrate himself. Either way, this happened next…


Pitch #7 2-2




Well, they went back outside and Puig was on this one. We’ve seen Puig smoke pitches like this in the past and he was an inch away from putting this one in the right field seats. It certainly wasn’t a bad pitch from Peralta, as he was once again able to elevate it just enough to keep Puig from squaring it up, but this was the best swing of the at-bat for Puig, and (I believe) Pina knew it.

Peralta is feeling himself at this point. His velocity is good, his command is solid, and he knows that Puig, for the most part, can’t catch up to his fastball. This was what happened between pitches #7 and #8…




You can see that as Peralta shakes off Pina multiple times, Pina flashes a sign (sort of like a “cash” or “money” finger rub). After being shaken off again, Pina looks down before looking out at Peralta. Peralta is emphatic in his frustration (I think he wants to finish Puig with a trademark heater), but it certainly appears as though Pina has an idea and, at the very least, wants to be on the same page as Peralta.

Pina eventually takes the walk out to the mound to discuss this crucial moment with his young pitcher. That’s two mound visits over two pitches with pitch #8 coming. What happened during that discussion? Well…


Pitch #8 2-2




Got him! Say what you want about the execution of the pitch itself (he may have bounced it pretty short), but I give a lot of credit to Pina here. Over the course of the at-bat, a few things stuck out:

  1. Puig could not catch up to pitches on the inner half, but Peralta could not command his fastball quite as well the further inside they went.
  2. Peralta had great command on the outside corner, but Puig clearly had a great feel for the outer half of the plate and just took his best swing on the previous pitch.
  3. It was a 2-2 count and they still had a pitch to waste if they wanted to.
  4. Puig had been sped up pretty much from pitch #1 to pitch #7.

I believe it was Pina who wanted the curveball here. He knew that if Peralta started it on the outer half, Puig would immediately swing fastball, and he was right. This was Peralta’s 19th pitch of the inning and his only non-fastball. Huge spot, huge pitch, huge out, and the Brewers would later close the door in the ninth inning to secure an early divisional win.

If you see an at-bat during the week and believe that it deserves to be highlighted as the “At-Bat of the Week”, please tweet me @dannyhottakes.

Featured Image by Justin Paradis (@freshmeatcomm on Twitter)

Dan McNamara

As a lifelong athlete and Personal Trainer by trade, everything in Dan's day-to-day life is centered around proper human movement and athletic efficiency. He takes his physical expertise and combines it with a love for statistical problem-solving to deliver the best possible stories to you about a variety of topics. He believes that stats and scouting should always be willing to shake hands, and he will always stand strong behind what his eyes and the numbers are telling him. His twitter feed is filled exclusively with baseball and dogs, and if asked who his hero is, he'd probably say "himself in five years".

7 responses to “At-Bat of the Week: Freddy Peralta vs Yasiel Puig”

  1. J.C. Mosier says:

    I’m a Reds fan, and that was some very nice analysis.

    • Dan McNamara says:

      Glad you enjoyed it! This is what makes baseball so awesome. Two men enter, one man leaves. No game clock, no play clock, just two guys trying to best one another. Reach out if you ever see an AB you’d like me to cover!

  2. Gus says:

    I will agree that puig probably couldn’t handle inside heat cause that where the hole in his swing is but he was not late on those middle away fastballs just under em cause I’m sure Peralta had that 4 seamer that looks like it rises ( spin rate). Could of easily been 3 home run swings

    • Dan McNamara says:

      Thanks for the take, Gus. Yea I only thought he was late on one of them. There were 3 swings at FAs away. The first one he just flies open too soon; rusty swing, as he did come off the bench. The second one, I think you’re half right :) I assumed he was late because of the uptick in velo, but looking closer, he may have actually been EARLY. The ball ricochets back to the catcher’s right, so it looks like Puig got the barrel to the spot, but a millisecond too soon. If he lets that get deeper, it may not be on the barrel, but pretty dang close. The third one, as I mentioned above, was one Puig really wanted back. He was right on that thing and Peralta did well to keep it elevated to get him to swing under.

  3. theKraken says:

    Pitch 1: I am pretty sure the plan is always to hit the glove, I don’t think there is much mystery there. If pitchers were not trying to hit the catcher’s glove, how would framing work? Good framers beat the ball to the spot, they don’t reach for it. I would bet you he was trying to get ahead, not induce a chase. Look at where the C glove starts to go after the initial target.
    Pitch 2 – that appeared to be exactly where he wanted it. I don’t think he was trying to elevate. He didn’t want to get behind 2-0. He attempts to throw that exact pitch several times in the AB.
    Pitch 3 – He was lucky to get that one back, but lucky is as big a factor as any.
    Pitch 6 – Worse location than pitch 5, that was middle-middle. I don’t think he was late on it necessarily, but it was certainly a terrible pitch.
    Pitch 8 – Pitches like that are weird. It was never a strike for a fraction of a second, but if a guy swings at it you look brilliant. I think he missed his location by several feet – you can see the C kind of jump to the inside and it was off the plate and feet short. In reality, Puig was probably just in swing mode and got caught cheating. Nice idea to throw the first CB of the inning there. I have never bought into the speeding up his bat idea. Changing speeds is a good idea, but the pitcher doesn’t make the hitter do anything IMO.
    We like to tell a narrative about a brilliant game of strategy, but I believe that it is more about mistakes and who ends up on the wrong end of the significant one. As I used to say when I coached, games are more often lost than won. Nobody “knew” anything throughout the AB – it could have ended in a go-ahead HR multiple times… alas history is written by the winners. In any case, this was a fun read.

    • Pitcher List is #1 says:

      Couldn’t agree more about pitches one and two. Looking at the glove makes it obvious where the pitch was supposed to go, I don’t know how Dan missed it.

  4. Nick Gerli says:

    Great stuff, Dan. This was really entertaining. Looking forward to the next one.

    It’s kind of hard to believe Puig swang at that last pitch. Maybe he was just so thrown off. But that was a terribly executed curveball.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Account / Login