Sit/Start Week 25: Reviewing All Starting Pitcher Matchups From 9/24 – 9/30

Here's a giant table of every starting pitcher matchup for Week 25, telling you which pitchers should get in your lineup or stick on your bench.

Every Sunday here at Pitcher List, I review all expected starting pitcher matchups for the week ahead. There are three labels: StartMaybe, and Sit. Outings marked with a Maybe are circumstantial and dependent on your needs in a standard 5×5 Wins 12-teamer, while the other two are self-explanatory. Feel free to question my designations in the comments and we’ll dive into it together.

Here’s the massive table containing every Week 25 start from 9/24 – 9/30:

Note: These matchups are subject to change.

Date Game Away Pitcher Sit / Start Home Pitcher Sit / Start
9/24 LAD vs ARI Clayton Kershaw Start Robbie Ray Start
9/24 BAL vs BOS Dylan Bundy Sit Nathan Eovaldi Start
9/24 PIT vs CHC Jameson Taillon Start Cole Hamels Start
9/24 CLE vs CHW Corey Kluber Start Dylan Covey Sit
9/24 PHI vs COL Zach Eflin Sit Tyler Anderson Maybe
9/24 TEX vs LAA Adrian Sampson Sit Felix Pena Start
9/24 OAK vs SEA Daniel Mengden Sit James Paxton Start
9/24 SDP vs SFG Bryan Mitchell Sit Derek Holland Start
9/24 MIL vs STL Chase Anderson Sit Jack Flaherty Start
9/24 NYY vs TBR Luis Severino Start Diego Castillo Sit
9/24 HOU vs TOR Dallas Keuchel Start Marco Estrada Sit
9/24 MIA vs WSH Sandy Alcantara Start Stephen Strasburg Start
9/25 LAD vs ARI Walker Buehler Start Matt Koch Sit
9/25 BAL vs BOS Bullpen Sit David Price Start
9/25 PIT vs CHC Chris Archer Maybe Mike Montgomery Sit
9/25 CLE vs CHW Trevor Bauer Start James Shields Sit
9/25 KCR vs CIN Eric Skoglund Sit Matt Harvey Maybe
9/25 PHI vs COL Vince Velasquez Sit Jon Gray Start
9/25 TEX vs LAA Yovani Gallardo Sit Matt Shoemaker Maybe
9/25 DET vs MIN Spencer Turnbull Sit Kohl Stewart Sit
9/25 ATL vs NYM Touki Toussaint Start Noah Syndergaard Start
9/25 OAK vs SEA Brett Anderson Sit Mike Leake Sit
9/25 SDP vs SFG Robbie Erlin Sit Chris Stratton Maybe
9/25 MIL vs STL Gio Gonzalez Maybe Austin Gomber Maybe
9/25 NYY vs TBR Masahiro Tanaka Start Bullpen Sit
9/25 HOU vs TOR Josh James Start Sam Gaviglio Sit
9/25 MIA vs WSH Jeff Brigham Sit Max Scherzer Start
9/26 LAD vs ARI Ross Stripling Start Zack Greinke Start
9/26 BAL vs BOS Yefry Ramirez Sit Chris Sale Start
9/26 PIT vs CHC Ivan Nova Sit Jose Quintana Start
9/26 CLE vs CHW Josh Tomlin Sit ??? Sit
9/26 KCR vs CIN Heath Fillmyer Sit Cody Reed Maybe
9/26 PHI vs COL Nick Pivetta Sit German Marquez Start
9/26 TEX vs LAA Yohander Mendez Sit Andrew Heaney Start
9/26 DET vs MIN Matthew Boyd Start Jake Odorizzi Maybe
9/26 ATL vs NYM Sean Newcomb Sit Jacob Degrom Start
9/26 OAK vs SEA Edwin Jackson Maybe Felix Hernandez Sit
9/26 SDP vs SFG Eric Lauer Sit Madison Bumgarner Start
9/26 MIL vs STL Jhoulys Chacin Maybe John Gant Sit
9/26 NYY vs TBR CC Sabathia Maybe Bullpen Sit
9/26 HOU vs TOR Gerrit Cole Start Sean-Reid Foley Sit
9/26 MIA vs WSH Wei-Yin Chen Maybe Tanner Roark Maybe
9/27 HOU vs BAL Justin Verlander Start David Hess Sit
9/27 PIT vs CHC Trevor Williams Maybe Jon Lester Start
9/27 PHI vs COL Jake Arrieta Sit Antonio Senzatela Sit
9/27 CLE vs KCR Mike Clevinger Start Jorge Lopez Sit
9/27 DET vs MIN Francisco Liriano Sit Stephen Gonsalves Sit
9/27 ATL vs NYM Julio Teheran Maybe Jason Vargas Sit
9/27 TEX vs SEA Mike Minor Start Marco Gonzales Maybe
9/27 NYY vs TBR Lance Lynn Sit Tyler Glasnow Maybe
9/28 HOU vs BAL Framber Valdez Start Bullpen Sit
9/28 NYY vs BOS J.A. Happ Start Rick Porcello Maybe
9/28 STL vs CHC Adam Wainwright Sit Kyle Hendricks Start
9/28 PIT vs CIN Nick Kingham? Sit Luis Castillo Start
9/28 WSH vs COL Joe Ross Sit Kyle Freeland Start
9/28 CLE vs KCR Adam Plutko Sit Ian Kennedy Sit
9/28 OAK vs LAA Mike Fiers Maybe Jaime Barria Sit
9/28 DET vs MIL Jordan Zimmermann Sit Zach Davies Maybe
9/28 CHW vs MIN Reynaldo Lopez Start Jose Berrios Start
9/28 CHW vs MIN Lucas Giolito Maybe Chase-De Jong Sit
9/28 MIA vs NYM Jose Urena Start Corey Oswalt Sit
9/28 ATL vs PHI Kevin Gausman Start Aaron Nola Start
9/28 ARI vs SDP Patrick Corbin Start Jacob Nix Sit
9/28 TEX vs SEA Martin Perez Sit Wade LeBlanc Maybe
9/28 LAD vs SFG Rich Hill Start Dereck Rodriguez Maybe
9/28 TOR vs TBR Thomas Pannone Sit Bullpen Sit
9/29 HOU vs BAL Charlie Morton Start Dylan Bundy Sit
9/29 NYY vs BOS Luis Severino Maybe Eduardo Rodriguez Maybe
9/29 STL vs CHC Miles Mikolas Start Cole Hamels Start
9/29 PIT vs CIN Jameson Taillon Start Anthony Desclafani Sit
9/29 WSH vs COL Erick Fedde Sit Tyler Anderson Sit
9/29 CLE vs KCR Corey Kluber Start Jakob Junis Sit
9/29 OAK vs LAA Trevor Cahill Sit Tyler Skaggs Sit
9/29 DET vs MIL Daniel Norris Sit Wade Miley Start
9/29 CHW vs MIN Carlos Rodon Start Kyle Gibson Start
9/29 MIA vs NYM Trevor Richards Maybe Steven Matz Start
9/29 ATL vs PHI Mike Foltynewicz Start Zach Eflin Sit
9/29 ARI vs SDP Zack Godley Maybe Joey Lucchesi Start
9/29 TEX vs SEA Adrian Sampson Sit James Paxton Start
9/29 LAD vs SFG Hyun-Jin Ryu Start Andrew Suarez Sit
9/29 TOR vs TBR Ryan Borucki Sit Blake Snell Start
9/30 HOU vs BAL Dallas Keuchel Start Bullpen Sit
9/30 NYY vs BOS Masahiro Tanaka? Maybe Nathan Eovaldi Maybe
9/30 STL vs CHC Jack Flaherty Start Mike Montgomery Sit
9/30 PIT vs CIN Chris Archer Maybe Matt Harvey Maybe
9/30 WSH vs COL Stephen Strasburg Start Jon Gray Maybe
9/30 CLE vs KCR Trevor Bauer Start Brad Keller Sit
9/30 OAK vs LAA Brett Anderson Sit Felix Pena Sit
9/30 DET vs MIL Spencer Turnbull Sit Chase Anderson Sit
9/30 CHW vs MIN Dylan Covey Sit Kohl Stewart Sit
9/30 MIA vs NYM Sandy Alcantara Start Noah Syndergaard Start
9/30 ATL vs PHI Anibal Sanchez Start Vince Velasquez Sit
9/30 ARI vs SDP Robbie Ray Start Bryan Mitchell Sit
9/30 TEX vs SEA Yovani Gallardo Sit Mike Leake Maybe
9/30 LAD vs SFG Clayton Kershaw Start Derek Holland Maybe
9/30 TOR vs TBR Marco Estrada Sit Bullpen Sit

Nick Pollack

Founder of Pitcher List. Creator of CSW, The List, and SP Roundup. Worked with MSG, FanGraphs, CBS Sports, and Washington Post. Former college pitcher, travel coach, pitching coach, and Brandeis alum. Wants every pitcher to be dope.

9 responses to “Sit/Start Week 25: Reviewing All Starting Pitcher Matchups From 9/24 – 9/30”

  1. Peter says:


    I need to choose 6 of the following 8 options for this week.

    – Clevinger (KC)
    – Carrasco. (?)
    – Grienke (LAD)
    – Marquez (PHI)
    – Buehler (ARI)
    – Castillo (PIT)
    – F.Pena (TEX +)
    – Eovaldi (BAL +)

    + For Pena and Eovaldi, I can start them today and pick someone off of waivers tonight and get a second start. (i.e. Toussaint, Josh James, Montgomery, Alcantara) (some of these would have a chance of getting me a third start … but that’s difficult to count on)

    What do you think? Drop Carrasco? Is that crazy?

    • Nick Pollack says:

      I’d drop Pena and maybe Greinke.

      I first wanted to say Carrasco, but him coming in after Bauer = great chance at a Win, and he could easily get 5+ innings.

      Pretty close between the two of them, though.

  2. Rick says:

    Can you help me pick 4 of these 6 options (QS league)?
    1. Holland v. SD
    2. Sale v. NYY
    3. Bumgarner v. SD
    4. Greinke v. LAD
    5. Clevinger v. KC
    6. Toussant v. NYM

    You think Cleveland might shorten Clevinger’s start in prep for playoffs?

    • Nick Pollack says:

      Wow. Love all of these.

      Drop Holland and Toussaint. If you’re worried about the QS from Sale (he probably won’t get one as he won’t last six frames), then keep Toussaint.

      • Rick says:

        Thanks. Head spinning. I was pretty sure you’d prefer Holland over Bumgarner with both going against SD. I’m worried about that Dodger’s offense too. Tough calls.

  3. Michael says:

    Why is Alcantara a double ‘START’? Did your opinion change about something? In your Two-Start Pitchers for Week 25 you had his starts under the ‘Questionable’ tier.

    • Nick Pollack says:

      Good question. His first start against the Nationals could easily be a “Maybe”, but I essentially wanted to express that if you’re going for it, I ultimately think you’re okay going with Sandy in that first start and definitely against the Mets.

      In the Two-Start article, I’m often a little more conservative, if that makes sense. I guess I could just label that Nats start a “Maybe” and make things clearer.

  4. tiger says:

    how would you rank these guys for this week in a pts league? thanks.

  5. Erli Zhou says:

    Can you rank the below starts in a standard points league(W/L matters):
    Touki Toussaint @ NYM
    Josh James @ TOR
    Matt Boyd @ MIN
    Kyle Gibson vs CHW
    Jose Urena @ NYM
    Trevor Richards @ NYM

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Account / Login