The List 9/16: Sit or Start For Every Remaining Starting Pitcher Matchup

We have two more weeks left of “The List”, with today marking the shift to a massive Sit/Start table for all remaining Starting Pitcher Matchups.

Huge props to Max Freeze for his excellent Sit/Start articles through the year and allowing me to take the reigns for the final two weeks.

Before we begin, remember, these matchups are subject to change. We even had changes from last night to today for Monday’s games (I’m looking at you Gausman) and you can expect plenty of these to change moving forward.

Still, this should be a great resource to focus on specific starts and plan out your weeks to get ahead of your opponents.

The massive table ahead of you has been color-coded:

Green = Just start this guy
Blue = Worthwhile, though the conservative owners could hold off
Amber = Not the worst option for desperate plays – some of these could be better in the final week if they showcase their upside in the short term
Red = Please don’t. This is unlikely to go well.

Alright, let’s get to it. Here’s the huge Sit / Start Starting Pitcher table for the final two weeks of the regular season:

Sit / Maybe / Start From 9/16 – 9/29

Date	Game	Away Pitcher	Home Pitcher
Monday 9/16
9/16	MIA vs ARI	Lopez	Ray
9/16	CIN vs CHC	Gausman	Hamels
9/16	NYM vs COL	Matz	Senzatela
9/16	BAL vs DET	Means	Alexander
9/16	SDP vs MIL	Richards	Davies
9/16	CHW vs MIN	Lopez	Berrios
9/16	KCR vs OAK	Sparkman	Roark
9/16	WSH vs STL	Strasburg	Hudson
Tuesday 9/17
9/17	MIA vs ARI	Smith	Young
9/17	PHI vs ATL	Velasquez	Keuchel
9/17	TOR vs BAL	Thornton	Bundy
9/17	SFG vs BOS	Webb	Eovaldi
9/17	CIN vs CHC	Gray	Darvish
9/17	DET vs CLE	Boyd	Plutko
9/17	NYM vs COL	Stroman	Melville
9/17	TEX vs HOU	Lynn	Verlander
9/17	TBR vs LAD	Snell	Stripling
9/17	SDP vs MIL	Paddack	Gonzalez
9/17	CHW vs MIN	Giolito	Perez
9/17	LAA vs NYY	Suarez	Severino
9/17	KCR vs OAK	Lopez	Anderson
9/17	SEA vs PIT	Gonzales	Keller
9/17	WSH vs STL	Corbin	Mikolas
Wednesday 9/18
9/18	MIA vs ARI	Alcantara	Leake
9/18	PHI vs ATL	Eflin	Teheran
9/18	TOR vs BAL	Buchholz	Brooks
9/18	SFG vs BOS	Samardzija	Chacin
9/18	CIN vs CHC	Mahle	Lester
9/18	DET vs CLE	Turnbull	Civale
9/18	NYM vs COL	Syndergaard	Hoffman
9/18	TEX vs HOU	Allard	Cole
9/18	TBR vs LAD	McKay	Gonsolin
9/18	SDP vs MIL	Lamet	Houser
9/18	CHW vs MIN	Covey	Odorizzi
9/18	LAA vs NYY	Peters	Sabathia
9/18	KCR vs OAK	Duffy	Bailey
9/18	SEA vs PIT	Dunn	Musgrove
9/18	WSH vs STL	Scherzer	Wainwright
Thursday 9/19
9/19	PHI vs ATL	Nola	Soroka
9/19	TOR vs BAL	Kay	TBD
9/19	SFG vs BOS	Bumgarner	Rodriguez
9/19	STL vs CHC	Flaherty	Hendricks
9/19	DET vs CLE	Zimmermann	Clevinger
9/19	SDP vs MIL	Lucchesi	Lyles
9/19	KCR vs MIN	Montgomery	Gibson
9/19	LAA vs NYY	Heaney	Happ
9/19	SEA vs PIT	Kikuchi	Brault
Friday 9/20
9/20	SFG vs ATL	Beede	Foltynewicz
9/20	SEA vs BAL	Hernandez	Wojciechowski
9/20	STL vs CHC	Wacha	Quintana
9/20	NYM vs CIN	deGrom	Castillo
9/20	PHI vs CLE	Smyly	Plesac
9/20	CHW vs DET	Cease	Norris
9/20	LAA vs HOU	Barria	Greinke
9/20	COL vs LAD	Lambert	Kershaw
9/20	WSH vs MIA	Voth	Dugger
9/20	PIT vs MIL	Marvel	Anderson
9/20	KCR vs MIN	Junis	Smeltzer
9/20	TOR vs NYY	Waguespack	Tanaka
9/20	TEX vs OAK	Minor	Bassitt
9/20	ARI vs SDP	Kelly	Lauer
9/20	BOS vs TBR	Porcello	Morton
Saturday 9/21
9/21	SFG vs ATL	Cueto	Fried
9/21	SEA vs BAL	Sheffield	Means
9/21	STL vs CHC	Hudson	Hamels
9/21	NYM vs CIN	Wheeler	DeSclafani
9/21	PHI vs CLE	Vargas	Bieber
9/21	CHW vs DET	Nova	Jackson
9/21	LAA vs HOU	Sandoval	Miley
9/21	COL vs LAD	Gonzalez	Ryu
9/21	WSH vs MIA	Sanchez	Hernandez
9/21	PIT vs MIL	Williams	Davies
9/21	KCR vs MIN	Sparkman	Berrios
9/21	TOR vs NYY	TBD	Paxton
9/21	TEX vs OAK	Burke	Fiers
9/21	ARI vs SDP	Gallen	Quantrill
9/21	BOS vs TBR	TBD	Glasnow
Sunday 9/22
9/22	SFG vs ATL	Webb	Keuchel
9/22	SEA vs BAL	Gonzales	Bundy
9/22	STL vs CHC	Mikolas	Darvish
9/22	NYM vs CIN	Matz	Bauer
9/22	PHI vs CLE	Velasquez	Plutko
9/22	CHW vs DET	Lopez	Boyd
9/22	LAA vs HOU	Suarez	Verlander
9/22	COL vs LAD	Senzatela	Buehler
9/22	WSH vs MIA	Strasburg	Lopez
9/22	PIT vs MIL	Keller	Gonzalez
9/22	KCR vs MIN	Lopez	Perez
9/22	TOR vs NYY	Thornton	Severino
9/22	TEX vs OAK	Lynn	Manaea
9/22	ARI vs SDP	Ray	Richards
9/22	BOS vs TBR	Eovaldi	Yarbrough
Monday 9/23
9/23	STL vs ARI	Wainwright	Young
9/23	MIA vs NYM	Smith	Stroman
9/23	BOS vs TBR	Chacin	Snell
9/23	BAL vs TOR	Brooks	Buchholz
9/23	PHI vs WSH	Eflin	Corbin
Tuesday 9/24
9/24	STL vs ARI	Flaherty	Leake
9/24	CLE vs CHW	Civale	Giolito
9/24	MIL vs CIN	Houser	Gray
9/24	MIN vs DET	Odorizzi	Turnbull
9/24	ATL vs KCR	Teheran	Duffy
9/24	OAK vs LAA	Roark	Peters
9/24	MIA vs NYM	Alcantara	Syndergaard
9/24	CHC vs PIT	Lester	Musgrove
9/24	LAD vs SDP	Stripling	Paddack
9/24	HOU vs SEA	Cole	Milone
9/24	COL vs SFG	Melville	Samardzija
9/24	NYY vs TBR	Sabathia	McKay
9/24	BOS vs TEX	Rodriguez	Allard
9/24	BAL vs TOR	TBD	Kay
9/24	PHI vs WSH	Nola	Scherzer
9/24	PHI vs WSH	Smyly	Voth
Wednesday 9/25
9/25	STL vs ARI	Wacha	Kelly
9/25	CLE vs CHW	Clevinger	Covey
9/25	MIL vs CIN	Lyles	Mahle
9/25	MIN vs DET	Gibson	Zimmermann
9/25	ATL vs KCR	Soroka	Montgomery
9/25	OAK vs LAA	Anderson	Heaney
9/25	MIA vs NYM	Dugger	deGrom
9/25	CHC vs PIT	Hendricks	Brault
9/25	LAD vs SDP	Gonsolin	Lamet
9/25	HOU vs SEA	Greinke	Kikuchi
9/25	COL vs SFG	Hoffman	Bumgarner
9/25	NYY vs TBR	Happ	Morton
9/25	BOS vs TEX	Porcello	Minor
9/25	BAL vs TOR	Wojciechowski	Waguespack
9/25	PHI vs WSH	Vargas	Sanchez
Thursday 9/26
9/26	CLE vs CHW	Plesac	Nova
9/26	MIL vs CIN	Anderson	Castillo
9/26	MIN vs DET	Smeltzer	Norris
9/26	HOU vs LAA	Miley	Barria
9/26	MIA vs NYM	Hernandez	Wheeler
9/26	CHC vs PIT	Quintana	Marvel
9/26	LAD vs SDP	Kershaw	Lucchesi
9/26	OAK vs SEA	Bailey	Hernandez
9/26	COL vs SFG	Lambert	Beede
9/26	BOS vs TEX	TBD	Burke
9/26	PHI vs WSH	Velasquez	Strasburg
Friday 9/27
9/27	SDP vs ARI	Lauer	Gallen
9/27	BAL vs BOS	Means	Eovaldi
9/27	DET vs CHW	Jackson	Lopez
9/27	DET vs CHW	TBD	TBD
9/27	MIL vs COL	Davies	Gonzalez
9/27	MIN vs KCR	Berrios	Junis
9/27	HOU vs LAA	Verlander	Sandoval
9/27	ATL vs NYM	Foltynewicz	Matz
9/27	MIA vs PHI	Lopez	Eflin
9/27	CIN vs PIT	DeSclafani	Williams
9/27	OAK vs SEA	Bassitt	Sheffield
9/27	LAD vs SFG	Ryu	Cueto
9/27	CHC vs STL	Hamels	Hudson
9/27	NYY vs TEX	Tanaka	Burke
9/27	TBR vs TOR	Glasnow	TBD
9/27	CLE vs WSH	Bieber	Corbin
Saturday 9/28
9/28	SDP vs ARI	Quantrill	Ray
9/28	BAL vs BOS	Bundy	Chacin
9/28	DET vs CHW	Boyd	Giolito
9/28	MIL vs COL	Gonzalez	Senzatela
9/28	MIN vs KCR	Perez	Sparkman
9/28	HOU vs LAA	Cole	Suarez
9/28	ATL vs NYM	Fried	Stroman
9/28	MIA vs PHI	Smith	Nola
9/28	CIN vs PIT	Bauer	Keller
9/28	OAK vs SEA	Fiers	Gonzales
9/28	LAD vs SFG	Buehler	Webb
9/28	CHC vs STL	Darvish	Mikolas
9/28	NYY vs TEX	Paxton	Lynn
9/28	TBR vs TOR	Yarbrough	Thornton
9/28	CLE vs WSH	Plutko	Scherzer
Sunday 9/29
9/29	SDP vs ARI	Richards	Young
9/29	BAL vs BOS	Brooks	Rodriguez
9/29	DET vs CHW	Turnbull	Covey
9/29	MIL vs COL	Houser	Melville
9/29	MIN vs KCR	Odorizzi	Lopez
9/29	HOU vs LAA	Greinke	Peters
9/29	ATL vs NYM	Keuchel	Syndergaard
9/29	MIA vs PHI	Alcantara	Smyly
9/29	CIN vs PIT	Gray	Musgrove
9/29	OAK vs SEA	Manaea	Milone
9/29	LAD vs SFG	Stripling	Samardzija
9/29	CHC vs STL	Lester	Wainwright
9/29	NYY vs TEX	Severino	Allard
9/29	TBR vs TOR	Snell	Buchholz
9/29	CLE vs WSH	Civale	Voth

15 responses to “The List 9/16: Sit or Start For Every Remaining Starting Pitcher Matchup”

Sam says:

September 16, 2019 at 2:15 PM

Do you really expect guys like Cole, Verlander, and Scherzer to make 3 more starts? Especially with Nats facing a WC game and likely having WC1 locked up…

- Chris says:
  
  September 16, 2019 at 4:05 PM
  
  Agreed, I find it hard Cole would start Tuesday and then Saturday, unless you think its like a 2 inning appearance because of short rest.
  
- Nick Pollack says:
  
  September 16, 2019 at 4:32 PM
  
  You’re right, I think a day was skipped there.
  
  It’s still the same matchups for Verlander/Cole, but they would get pushed back, or skipped altogether to get them set up for Wednesday/Thursday.
  
Sean says:

September 16, 2019 at 2:33 PM

I’m seeing Mets are at Colorado this week, not versus. Does that impact their status?

- Nick Pollack says:
  
  September 16, 2019 at 3:05 PM
  
  I am too! It’s listed as such here.
  
  - Sean says:
    
    September 16, 2019 at 3:09 PM
    
    Oh my mistake, I just saw where you had written “NYM vs COL” and not “@ COL” and completely missed the home/away columns. Thanks!
    
Jay says:

September 16, 2019 at 3:09 PM

Can you explain why Lamet gets the green light in Milwaukee? I get the strikeout upside but he seems to get pulled pretty quickly if he has any trouble.

- J says:
  
  September 16, 2019 at 3:48 PM
  
  One could argue that in fantasy playoff matchups that can be a good thing. They won’t let him sit out there to kill your ratios if he doesn’t have it that day. That Brewers lineup is pretty pedestrian without Yelich too. Despite being on a hot streak, the team has an 83 wRC+ in the small sample since Yelich’s injury. Grandal, Moustakas, and Grisham are hot, but I don’t buy into Grisham and the rest of the offense has been abysmal.
  
Frankie says:

September 16, 2019 at 4:13 PM

This list is amazing. Thank you.

Lion says:

September 16, 2019 at 4:13 PM

So you think bassit and perez x2 starts over desclafani start? If you had to pick 3 out of 4?

Makes me nervous after bassit got knocked around and disco been pretty good over last 5 starts. But I trust the expert if thats what you say.

Justin says:

September 16, 2019 at 4:40 PM

The old format sorted by teams and pitcher was much better.

- J says:
  
  September 16, 2019 at 4:59 PM
  
  Strong disagree. This is super useful for fantasy playoffs.
  
  - Justin says:
    
    September 17, 2019 at 10:23 AM
    
    Head to head weekly leagues for baseball are madness. There’s too much variance in the sport week to week.
    
Weekly Roto Boy says:

September 17, 2019 at 12:04 PM

Thank you for including next week’s games. One of the benefits of Max’s articles was I could use them for deciding which pitchers to FAAB Sunday night. I couldn’t do that this week

Ken Schneider says:

September 18, 2019 at 6:58 PM

Is Wainwright being underestimated? He was just fantastic against Scherzer and he seems to be holding his own against better than expected pitchers.

AL East

AL Central

AL West

NL East

NL Central

NL West

The List 9/16: Sit or Start For Every Remaining Starting Pitcher Matchup

Nick Pollack

15 responses to “The List 9/16: Sit or Start For Every Remaining Starting Pitcher Matchup”

Leave a Reply Cancel reply