Top 100 Relievers for Save+Hold Leagues: 4/2

Rick Graham updates his top 100 relief pitchers for SV+HD leagues.

It was a busy opening day for the league, with (almost) every team playing yesterday, and gave us a good look at how some bullpens will operate out of the gate. The biggest news of the day was likely the placement of  Trevor Rosenthal on the IL with a shoulder issue that seemingly came out of left field. There’s currently no timetable for his return but as soon as we find out I’ll update the new IL table at the bottom of the page. For the time being, Jake Diekman will fill in as the Athletics closer, but it doesn’t affect his ranking all that much.

We also found out who would be the Cardinals (and Padres) closer to begin the season, with the Cards going with Alex Reyes, which was a bit of a surprise to me. Reyes has a 2.44 career ERA at the MLB level over 73.2 IP, but that also comes with a 1.34 WHIP due to a career 14.7% BB rate. Reyes does have an impressive 4 pitch mix, it just comes down to how well can he command it. The overall skill set, closing out games for a potential playoff team, and also potentially working multiple innings each outing with the team hoping to get him 100 IP this year still have me very much in on Reyes right now with the concerning walk rate the only thing holding me back.




  • Will Smith picked up where he left off this spring, racking up 3 K’s while allowing no baserunners and most importantly, working the 9th inning following Chris Martin. Smith’s 3 K’s came with a 64% CSW as he produced four whiffs on all four swings against him.
  • After dealing with some forearm issues last month, Drew Pomeranz was electric in his regular-season debut today and looks to be 100%. His fastball sat at 95 MPH and produced a 59% CSW while he only threw 4 curveballs in his 21 pitch outing. Despite not closing, he should remain one of the top 2-3 setup options in baseball this year.
  • Emmanuel Clase didn’t pitch yesterday, which is perhaps a good thing considering James Karinchak worked the 8th inning down 3 runs. This is the one team where we still have no idea how the closer position will shake out, but there seems to be growing hype around Clase getting the first crack at the job, which if that’s the case, you don’t want to miss out.


  • Although Emilio Pagan was gathering all the momentum to open as the Padres closer, it will be Mark Melancon who gets the first crack at the role after all. He converted the save in typical Melancon fashion yesterday (no K’s) and while the lack of K’s is frustrating, closing out games for that Padres team makes him a near must roster player.
  • Adam Ottavino gets a slight boost for a couple of reasons here. He had a great spring, is in a contract year and no Ryan Brasier should mean he gets a heavy workload pitching in high leverage situations.
  • I was probably a little too harsh with my low Rafael Montero ranking to begin the season, and despite the blown save last night, I feel like he deserves a slight bump being the only reliever of real value in Seattle at the moment. He had a shaky spring, and probably won’t be much help in the ERA or K department but saves are saves, right?


  • Jose Alvarado is awfully fun to watch when he is commanding his pitches, but the shaky command is still holding me back from placing him any higher on the list at this point. It’s great that he has a setup role locked down and is healthy and sitting at 100 MPH though.
  • All the bottom tier closers are getting a slight boost this week, with perhaps none benefiting more than Ian Kennedy who opens the season as the Rangers closer. Coming off a good spring, maybe we are sleeping on Kennedy a little here as he is just one year removed from being a respectable closer with a 30 save season to his name.
  • Due to a shaky spring (it was really one bad outing), the Diamondbacks backed off their commitment to Joakim Soria as their closer, and have yet to name anyway. He should still be viewed as the favorite for the job, especially considering Kevin Ginkel and Stefan Crichton worked the 5th and 6th innings of yesterday’s game.



Rank Pitcher Change
1Edwin DíazT1-
2Liam Hendriks-
3Josh Hader+1
4Aroldis Chapman-1
5Devin Williams+1
6Raisel Iglesias-1
7Ryan Pressly
8James Karinchak-
9Will Smith+4
10Drew Pomeranz+10
11Jordan Romano-
13Diego Castillo+1
14Jake Diekman+2
15Giovanny Gallegos-5
16Tyler Duffey
17Trevor May-2
18Chad Green-1
19Pete Fairbanks-
20Tanner Rainey+3
21Héctor Neris+3
22Taylor Rogers+4
23Kenley Jansen-2
24Brad Hand-2
25Alex Reyes+42
26Aaron Bummer
27Blake Treinen+1
28Scott Barlow+1
29Chris Martin+2
30Lucas Sims+2
31Emmanuel Clase+33
33Alex Colomé+1
34Rafael Dolis+1
35Codi Heuer+14
36Jake McGee+1
37Enoli Paredes+3
38Archie Bradley-
39Richard Rodríguez+4
40Mark Melancon+46
41Tanner Scott
42Josh Staumont-1
43Victor González-1
44Craig Kimbrel-
45Matt Barnes-
46Adam Ottavino+7
47Anthony Bass-
49Gregory Soto+1
50Daniel Bard+2
51Emilio Pagán-26
53Rafael Montero+7
54Nick Wittgren-8
55Garrett Crochet+2
56Wander Suero-5
57Jordan Hicks-27
58Miguel Castro-2
59José Alvarado+21
60Stefan Crichton-5
61Yimi García-7
62Ian Kennedy+25
63Joakim Soria+7
64Tejay Antone+1
66Andrew Miller
67Robert Stephenson+1
68Cody Stashak+4
69A.J. Minter+2
70Mychal Givens+9
72Hansel Robles+UR
73Andrew Chafin+8
74Phil Maton-15
75Connor Brogdon+7
76Brent Suter-2
77Hirokazu Sawamura+UR
79Tony Gonsolin+4
80Michael Kopech+4
81David Price+UR
82Jesse Hahn+10
83Lou Trivino+10
84Jason Adam+1
85Daniel Hudson+6
86Darren O’Day+9
87Sergio Romo+UR
88Matt Wisler-12
89Keone Kela+7
90Kevin Ginkel-1
91Tyler Matzek+UR
92David Bednar+UR
93Julian Merryweather+UR
94Corey Knebel+UR
95Sean Doolittle+UR
96Reyes Moronta-8
97Darwinzon Hernández+UR
99Josh Sborz+UR
100J.P. Feyereisen+UR


Injured List


Photo by Scott Kane/Icon Sportswire | Adapted by Justin Paradis (@JustParaDesigns on Twitter)

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Account / Login