World Series Preview: Nationals vs. Astros

The World Series is here! Tim Jackson and Dave Cherman break down the series ahead of Game 1.

We’ve reached the pinnacle of the 2019 season as the Nationals and Astros get ready to face off in the World Series. Washington, a surprise representative for the National League, is looking to cap off a fantasy run which was nearly unimaginable at various points earlier in the season. Meanwhile, Houston is looking to take one step closer to being a dynasty, something Alex Bregman has been talking about since last winter. The two teams match up well and seem to offer an entertaining series.


World Series Schedule


Game 1: Tuesday, Oct. 22, in Houston, 8:08 PM EDT.

Game 2: Wednesday, Oct. 23, in Houston, 8:07 PM EDT.

Game 3: Friday, Oct. 25, in Washington, 8:07 PM EDT.

Game 4: Saturday, Oct. 26, in Washington, 8:07 PM EDT.

Game 5 (if necessary): Sunday, Oct. 27, in Washington, 8:07 PM EDT.

Game 6 (if necessary): Tuesday, Oct. 29, in Houston, 8:07 PM EDT.

Game 7 (if necessary): Wednesday, Oct. 30, in Houston, 8:07 PM EDT.

All games will be aired on FOX. 


Regular-Season Results


The Nationals and the Astros did not play each other in the regular season, perhaps making advance scouting even more important than it otherwise would be. It’s how the Royals figured out and exploited José Bautista’s crow hop in Game 6 of the 2015 ALCS. It’s how the Red Sox helped Jonathan Papelbon pick off Matt Holliday in Game 2 of the 2007 World Series, despite Papelbon having never picked off anyone in the major leagues. And it’s certainly led to plenty of other moments through the annals of each postseason. 


Washington Nationals


This postseason for the Nationals has berthed a rather appropriate Twitter hashtag: #StayInTheFight. Before now, the team had never even made it past the first round of the playoffs. But this October has been patently different, with heroes at seemingly every turn. 

The team’s run started to pronounce itself when Juan Soto sliced a double with a funky bounce to Trent Grisham in the eighth inning of the play-in Wild Card game. The team had picked away at Josh Hader, the league’s third-most valuable reliever by fWAR in 2019 and its leader in K-BB rate at 40.8%. Then they squared off against the Dodgers and disposed of them in just five games. The Nats coerced Clayton Kershaw to say things such as, “Everything people say about [my struggles in] the postseason is true,” per Dylan Hernandez of the LA Times, and left Joe Kelly to shake his head in disbelief as Howie Kendrick blasted a game-winning grand slam in extra innings in the deciding game. Up next were the Cardinals, who were working a magic of their own. But Washington set the pace in Game 1, where Anibal Sanchez nearly no-hit them, and cruised to a sweep with having hardly been threatened in any game. 

Guys such as Kendrick and Sanchez have been provided opportunities for meaningful moments through each series as a direct result of the Nationals’ biggest names doing what they’re supposed to. No team’s starting pitchers were worth more than Washington’s, who posted a combined 21.4 fWAR in 2019. They also logged the second-most innings through the regular season with 938.2. For comparison, the Astros ranked fourth in each category after accruing 19.4 fWAR and 907.1 innings. In 10 postseason games so far, Max Scherzer, Stephen Strasburg, and Patrick Corbin have logged 55.1 innings and racked up 86 strikeouts. These three horses will inevitably have to continue being exactly who they’ve been all year to give the Nats a chance. 

In addition to providing chances for role players to shine, the starters have also helped nullify concerns about the team’s bullpen. After being a mess all year, they’ve only been relied on for 22 innings these playoffs. When Washington has gone to relievers, it’s primarily been Sean Doolittle, Daniel Hudson, and Taylor Rainey. Four guys on the NLCS roster didn’t even pitchJavy Guerra, Austin Voth, Roenis Elias, and Wander Suero. One way to reduce the effects of a weakness is to leave it leave it less exposed, and the Nationals have certainly achieved that so far. 

The offense got a boost from Victor Robles in Game 3 of the NLCS as he returned from a mild hamstring strain suffered against the Dodgers. He picked up right where he left off and has gone 5-for-16 in the playoffs with a .915 OPS while contributing in every way imaginable. As for the offense as a whole, they’ve only smacked eight home runs, or three more than Jose Altuve alone. But on the flipside, they also only have one batter who has struck at more than nine times, and remarkably, Juan Soto. The Astros, who had the lowest strikeout rate for hitters in the history of baseball through the regular season, have four: Yordan Alvarez, Carlos Correa, George Springer, and Robinson Chirinos. Correa and Springer have provided enormous moments with home runs, though, adding unique wrinkles in the fabric of this October narrative. 

The Astros may be the strongest opponent the Nationals face this postseason. However, Washington boasts more rotation depth. They’ve made a strength of their bullpen. Their hitting has been both consistent and timely. If they can continue to minimize disadvantages that Houston could exploit, we may be in for a true slobberknocker.

Tim Jackson


Houston Astros


The Astros’ run to the World Series was not without its drama, but Minute Maid Park has largely been their safe haven. The Tampa Bay Rays pushed Houston to a 2-2 series tie with back-to-back wins in Tampa in the ALCS, but when the Astros got back to Houston, the Rays folded. After falling behind 3-1 in the ALCS, the Yankees put pressure on the astros, winning Game 5 in New York. But when the Astros got back to Houston, the Yankees folded. Overall, the team is 5-1 in six games at Minute Maid this postseason versus 2-3 on the roada clear home-field advantage, which is no surprise given their 60-21 home record this season.

After their Game 6 win, the Astros announced their starters for the first three games: Gerrit Cole, Justin Verlander, and Zack Greinke. Who else? Cole gets the ball in Game 1, fresh off a five-walk performance with 27% CSW in Game 3 vs. the Yankees; Cole also allowed 20 foul balls, 18 on his elite four-seamer. He and Verlander both establish their game with a high fastball paired with elite breaking balls. The Nationals should be an easier opponent than the Yankees, as the Nats rank 18th in batting average and slugging percentage on four-seamers as opposed to the Yankees, who ranked first in both. That said, when we look at fastballs in the upper third of the zone and above it, the Nats jump up to 10th. On top of that, only six teams hit more foul balls on such pitches than the Nationals, making them a well-positioned team to beat those starters. Then again, there was no team with a lower batting average or slugging percentage than the Nationals on breaking pitches downthe other pitch these two aces use. It will be interesting how the Astros attack these Nationals hitters.

Coming into the playoffs, the big question mark for the Astros was the bullpen, and that concern was well-placed, as relievers gave up a 4.13 ERA over 24 innings to the Yankees in the ALCS. That sounds like a lot of innings, but outside of the nine-inning bullpen game, the Stros only averaged about three innings from their pen. This is a recipe for success for Houston who, like Washington, will succeed on the strength of the rotation. The real problem is: Who do the Astros feel confident about? Roberto Osuna gave up a game-tying two-run homer in his most recent appearance. Ryan Pressly gave up five hits, one walk, and two earned runs over 1.2 innings against the Yankees (Pressly hurt himself in Game 6 but says he’ll be ready for the World Series), Joe Smith gave up a run over 3.2 in four appearances but threw just 25 innings during the regular season, leaving Will Harris as the most reliable arm right now. How will AJ Hinch deploy this bullpen? Harris and Pressly have typically been the first arms out of the bullpen, but from there, who knows? Will Hinch replace someone with Wade Miley to use in high leverage spots against Soto and Adam Eaton? The Astros had no left-handed pitchers on the roster for the ALCS, after all.

Now to the biggest question mark right now, the question mark I never thought we’d have: the Astros lineup. Throughout the six-game set, the team hit 5-46 (.109) with runners in scoring position, Alvarez went 1-24 with 12 strikeouts, Bregman (who finished fifth in the AL in RBI) went 3-18 with one RBI, and Springer went 4-25. It doesn’t matter that Altuve and Michael Brantley hit over .300 if the team can’t drive in runs. They won big games on the strength of the long ballwalkoff home runs by Correa and game-defining three-run home runs by Springer, Correa, and Gurriel. They are unlikely to get the same long-ball opportunities against the Nationals pitching staff, so they’ll have to perform with runners on base to win.

Dave Cherman


Team Stats


A Regular Season Tale


The Astros have a tremendous edge in nearly every category here. Their world-beating offense is highlighted, as well as their ability to maximize the effectiveness of whiffs and walks in both sides of the game. But the other thing emphasized is just how much Washington’s pitching has grown through and since the regular season. A competitive series will hinge on those changes continuing to stick.


Things to Watch


  • What if Soto takes back the plate and stops whiffing? Containing him in addition to the likes of Anthony Rendon, Kendrick, and Robles could prove difficult. That may be especially true with how the Yankees made Cole and Verlander look human at times.
  • Do the Nationals have another unexpected hero sitting in the shadows of the dugout? Maybe Ryan Zimmerman reemerges to make an impact or Rainey plugs a hole in the dam if a starter gets chased early.
  • How quickly will Dave Martinez call on one of his starters to relieve, if necessary? Everyone is well-rested, and there basically is no tomorrow at this point. “All hands on deck” might be an understatement, and the Nats might not be able to afford to wait around if the Astros put up a crooked number early in a game.
  • Can the Nationals get to the Astros bullpen early? How quick will AJ Hinch be on the hook? He’s given Verlander and Cole a long leash and is unlikely to deviate from that strategy, but he can be quick on the draw in his bullpen.
  • Will Greinke show up as a playoff ace and silence the Nationals hitters, or will he continue to just be above average?
  • Can the Astros wake up with men on base and start getting the timely hits needed to get these Nats starters out of the game early? Can Alvarez, Bregman, and Springer reverse their fortune at the plate and spark the top of this Astros lineup?
  • Who will step up alongside Harris in the Astros bullpen?




Tim Jackson: Astros in seven games. There is a part of my sports being that feasts on chaos, and the Nationals winning the World Series would certainly represent that. They’ve had a magical run. I just can’t get over how great the Astros are, though, how well-oiled a machine they’ve been no matter who they’re facing. It may not be easy, but they seem unstoppable.

Dave Cherman: This is tough. I’m all on board the Nats bandwagon and think they have what it takes to neutralize the Astros completely. I’m going to play it safe and say the Astros in six games. But my heart is shouting Nats in seven.

Featured image by Justin Paradis (@FreshMeatComm on Twitter)

Tim Jackson

Tim Jackson is a writer and educator who loves pitching duels. Find him in the PL Discord, editing, managing, and podcasting with @BREAKINGPodPL here or writing at Baseball Prospectus.

3 responses to “World Series Preview: Nationals vs. Astros”

  1. Charlie says:

    I think you mean they took the Dodgers to a winner take all game 5. Not “just 5 games”

  2. theKraken says:

    On what planet is Josh Hader the third most valuable RP? Any equation that doesn’t place him at #1 has some issues! The only thing Hader did wrong was give up a ton of HR… but that has proven to be an unreliable indicator of skill and way more luck. See Degrom, Jake, 2018. It is the most egregious flaw in pitcher analysis.

    The Astros are without any doubt the strongest opponent the Nats have faced this postseason.
    I would argue that HOU hasn’t faced too much adversity. It has been profitable to sell it a adversity more than real adversity IMO. Sweeps are bad for business. HOU has given away games they didn’t need while saving the best pitcher in baseball for a decisive home game in each series. It might seem dramatic but here they are well rested and in the WS so it feels pretty on script to me. They have used those “if” games to eat up the other teams bullpens. Its more of a strategy than something negative that was imposed on them. Get a lead and suck the life from the opponent has been the script. What a great way to take advantage of a team that can’t wait to overuse their bullpen. Every team should be doing backflips at the thought of getting to face the other teams 6-10th best pitchers as much as possible. The consistently false narrative of the postseason has been the importance of the bullpens. It hasn’t gotten anyone here, but teams that have relied on it too heavily have lost because of it. It is crazy to me that it gets addressed in every preview article. Sure, they will be involved to some extent but it won’t be decisive. Kickers are involved in football games too. I actually think of RP as being fairly similar to K in football. They are a lot more important but similarities exist. The teams that don’t make an effort to field rotations add a serious wrinkle to that line of thought… it is worth considering that the real contenders are not teams that used openers much during the year of the opener. I’m not sure anyone actually looks at that kind of thing though as I see a lot of bad ideas continue to gain traction with what appears to be no significant oversight. More accurately, I think the people with the bad ideas support themselves with conveniently poor data while ridiculing those that don’t see it from their limited perspective which is likely absent of adequate experience.

    Why not use traditional stats in the table? The fact is that almost everyone is not going to understand what any of those stats actually mean. To those that think they do, I question how much of the larger context they understand. WAR is at best flawed and in all likelihood missing just about anything insightful. Simple OPS, BA and HR would probably tell you more. As for pitching you have WHIP and whatever else you want. The fact that FIP and SIERA are so divergent tell you what need to know about those, which is that they are both flawed. Its the details that are insightful not the composite approximations of value. I like to advocate for simple stats that people can research on tjhier own if they want to claim to be knowledgeable. I think WAR does the opposite of that as it abstract all the details into one approximation.

    So you want my pick in the series? Thanks for asking! Well, the smart money is something like HOU in 5 or 6. There is no good reason this series should go 7. If it does, it will be because things went pretty poorly for HOU. That said, this is a game played by humans so anything can happen. I would love for this to go to WAS in 7, but that is just because I am not rooting for HOU and I love the idea of a Harper-less WAS winning immediately. I can’t tell you how much I would love WAS in 4 but I don’t know how that is supposed to happen. The chance of a Cole loss at home in game 1 is not good. Verlander will be an overwhelming favorite in game 2 at home. It will be a very exciting story line if WAS can crack either of them. To be clear, I think WAS is a fun matchup – certainly the best the NL has to offer at this point in the season. They have the starting pitching to win any series which is a great starting point. The problem is that HOU does everything better on paper and over the entire course of their careers. Neither manager is committed to being progressive which should make for some decent baseball to watch. If WAS can show some life and make Cole look like a human then this series will be must see TV. If Cole does what he should do, then it might be a snooze of a series.

  3. theKraken says:

    So far we have a great series. I feel like people are missing it. For my money, game 4 is the big one. WAS is set up as well as they could be relative to HOU. If HOU wins then they have Cole, JV and home field advantage and momentum to win a 3 game series. WAS needs to capitalize on Urquidy tonight and hopefully use up that HOU pen if they are going to win this series. I haven’t seen a ton of Urquidy myself, but from what I have seen he is just a guy. Of course Corbin, whom I consider a low end #1 starter, has a tough task ahead of him but if WAS can win tonight then I like their chances to steal one of three remaining games. If they lose tonight then they will be as big of underdogs as they were to start – maybe worse. I thought it was foolish to not use their best pitcher in game 3, but if they can win tonight in the plus match-up then it was a good move – too creative for my taste but defensible. The question is how much role does momentum play? I really do think that Corbin could have beat Greinke last night but that is hindsight seeing how not sharp Greinke was. At least they didn’t waste Corbin too which is what some people were advocating for. The more I think about it, saving Corbin for a scrub day vs HOU may have been right but I didn’t like them giving away a game to a juggernaut like HOU. I would like to credit WAS for not using anything up in game 3 as that needed to be part of the commitment. I sure hope WAS wins tonight as I think the series is going to get really tilted towards HOU if they don’t. It would be fun to see if HOU can win three straight with all of their advantages – that would be absolutely great TV to watch.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Account / Login