Sit/Start Week 23: Reviewing All Starting Pitcher Matchups From 9/10 – 9/16

Here's a giant table of every starting pitcher matchup for Week 23, telling you which pitchers should get in your lineup or stick on your bench.

Every Sunday here at Pitcher List, I review all expected starting pitcher matchups for the week ahead. There are three labels: StartMaybe, and Sit. Outings marked with a Maybe are circumstantial and dependent on your needs in a standard 5×5 Wins 12-teamer, while the other two are self-explanatory. Feel free to question my designations in the comments and we’ll dive into it together.

Here’s the massive table containing every Week 23 start from 9/10 – 9/16:

Note: These matchups are subject to change.

Date Game Away Pitcher Sit / Start Home Pitcher Sit / Start
9/10 MIL vs CHC Wade Miley Sit Jon Lester Start
9/10 LAD vs CIN Alex Wood Start Cody Reed Sit
9/10 ARI vs COL Zack Godley Maybe German Marquez Start
9/10 HOU vs DET Justin Verlander Start Francisco Liriano Sit
9/10 CHW vs KCR Lucas Giolito Start Jakob Junis Start
9/10 TEX vs LAA Mike Minor Start Jaime Barria Maybe
9/10 NYY vs MIN J.A. Happ Start Kyle Gibson Sit
9/10 MIA vs NYM Jeff Brigham Sit Jacob Degrom Start
9/10 WSH vs PHI Erick Fedde Sit Jake Arrieta Start
9/10 ATL vs SFG Sean Newcomb Sit Dereck Rodriguez Start
9/10 PIT vs STL Trevor Williams Maybe Adam Wainwright Sit
9/10 CLE vs TBR Corey Kluber Start Diego Castillo Sit
9/11 OAK vs BAL Mike Fiers Start Alex Cobb Sit
9/11 TOR vs BOS Ryan Borucki Sit Chris Sale Start
9/11 MIL vs CHC Jhoulys Chacin Sit Jose Quintana Start
9/11 LAD vs CIN Hyun-Jin Ryu Start Luis Castillo Start
9/11 ARI vs COL Zack Greinke Start Antonio Senzatela Sit
9/11 HOU vs DET Framber Valdez Sit Jordan Zimmermann Sit
9/11 CHW vs KCR ??? Sit ??? Sit
9/11 TEX vs LAA Adrian Sampson Sit Bullpen? Sit
9/11 NYY vs MIN Sonny Gray Sit Kohl Stewart Sit
9/11 MIA vs NYM Jose Urena Maybe Jason Vargas Sit
9/11 WSH vs PHI Tanner Roark Maybe Nick Pivetta Maybe
9/11 SDP vs SEA Bryan Mitchell Sit Marco Gonzales Sit
9/11 ATL vs SFG Mike Foltynewicz Start Andrew Suarez Sit
9/11 PIT vs STL Joe Musgrove Maybe Miles Mikolas Start
9/11 CLE vs TBR Shane Bieber Maybe Tyler Glasnow Maybe
9/12 OAK vs BAL Bullpen? Sit Andrew Cashner Sit
9/12 TOR vs BOS Aaron Sanchez Sit David Price Start
9/12 MIL vs CHC Chase Anderson Sit Kyle Hendricks Start
9/12 LAD vs CIN Ross Stripling Maybe Anthony Desclafani Sit
9/12 ARI vs COL Patrick Corbin Start Jon Gray Maybe
9/12 HOU vs DET Gerrit Cole Start Daniel Norris Sit
9/12 CHW vs KCR Carlos Rodon Start Brad Keller Sit
9/12 TEX vs LAA Yovani Gallardo Sit Felix Pena Maybe
9/12 NYY vs MIN Luis Severino Start Jake Odorizzi Sit
9/12 MIA vs NYM Trevor Richards Start Zack Wheeler Start
9/12 WSH vs PHI Stephen Strasburg Start Aaron Nola Start
9/12 SDP vs SEA Joey Lucchesi Start Wade Leblanc Start
9/12 ATL vs SFG Anibal Sanchez Start Derek Holland Start
9/12 PIT vs STL Jameson Taillon Start Austin Gomber Maybe
9/12 CLE vs TBR Carlos Carrasco Start Blake Snell Start
9/13 OAK vs BAL Chris Bassitt? Sit Dylan Bundy Sit
9/13 TOR vs BOS Sam Gaviglio Sit Eduardo Rodriguez Start
9/13 ARI vs COL Clay Buchholz Maybe Kyle Freeland Start
9/13 MIN vs KCR Stephen Gonsalves Sit Heath Fillmyer Sit
9/13 SEA vs LAA James Paxton Start Matt Shoemaker Sit
9/13 MIA vs NYM Sandy Alcantara Maybe Steven Matz Start
9/13 LAD vs STL Clayton Kershaw Start Jack Flaherty Start
9/13 CHC vs WSH Cole Hamels Start Joe Ross Sit
9/14 WSH vs ATL Max Scherzer Start Kevin Gausman Maybe
9/14 CHW vs BAL James Shields Sit David Hess Sit
9/14 NYM vs BOS Noah Syndergaard Start Brian Johnson Sit
9/14 CIN vs CHC Matt Harvey Sit Mike Montgomery Sit
9/14 DET vs CLE Matthew Boyd Sit Adam Plutko Sit
9/14 ARI vs HOU Robbie Ray Start Charlie Morton Start
9/14 MIN vs KCR Jose Berrios Start Jorge Lopez Sit
9/14 SEA vs LAA Mike Leake Maybe Andrew Heaney Maybe
9/14 PIT vs MIL Chris Archer Maybe Gio Gonzalez Maybe
9/14 TOR vs NYY Marco Estrada Sit Masahiro Tanaka Start
9/14 MIA vs PHI Wei-Yin Chen Maybe Zach Eflin Maybe
9/14 TEX vs SDP Yohander Mendez Sit Eric Lauer Sit
9/14 COL vs SFG Tyler Anderson Maybe Chris Stratton Sit
9/14 LAD vs STL Walker Buehler Start John Gant Maybe
9/14 OAK vs TBR Edwin Jackson Sit Bullpen Sit
9/15 WSH vs ATL Erick Fedde Sit Julio Teheran Maybe
9/15 CHW vs BAL Reynaldo Lopez Maybe Josh Rogers? Sit
9/15 NYM vs BOS Jacob Degrom Start Rick Porcello Start
9/15 CIN vs CHC Tyler Mahle Sit Jose Quintana Start
9/15 DET vs CLE Michael Fulmer Maybe Mike Clevinger Start
9/15 ARI vs HOU Zack Godley Maybe Dallas Keuchel Start
9/15 MIN vs KCR Zack Littell Sit Ian Kennedy Sit
9/15 SEA vs LAA Felix Hernandez Sit Jaime Barria Maybe
9/15 PIT vs MIL Ivan Nova Maybe Zach Davies Maybe
9/15 TOR vs NYY Sean-Reid Foley Sit Lance Lynn Maybe
9/15 MIA vs PHI Jeff Brigham Sit Vince Velasquez Maybe
9/15 TEX vs SDP Ariel Jurado Sit Brett Kennedy Sit
9/15 COL vs SFG German Marquez Start Madison Bumgarner Start
9/15 LAD vs STL Rich Hill Start Adam Wainwright Sit
9/15 OAK vs TBR Trevor Cahill Sit Bullpen Sit
9/16 WSH vs ATL Tanner Roark Maybe Sean Newcomb? Sit
9/16 CHW vs BAL Lucas Giolito Start Alex Cobb Sit
9/16 NYM vs BOS Jason Vargas Sit Chris Sale Start
9/16 CIN vs CHC Cody Reed Sit Kyle Hendricks Start
9/16 DET vs CLE Francisco Liriano Sit Corey Kluber Start
9/16 ARI vs HOU Zack Greinke Start Justin Verlander Start
9/16 MIN vs KCR Kyle Gibson Start Jakob Junis Maybe
9/16 SEA vs LAA Marco Gonzales Sit Bullpen? Sit
9/16 PIT vs MIL Trevor Williams Maybe Wade Miley Maybe
9/16 TOR vs NYY Thomas Pannone Sit CC Sabathia Start
9/16 MIA vs PHI Jose Urena Maybe Jake Arrieta Start
9/16 TEX vs SDP Mike Minor Start Robbie Erlin Sit
9/16 COL vs SFG Antonio Senzatela Sit Dereck Rodriguez Start
9/16 LAD vs STL Alex Wood Start Miles Mikolas Start
9/16 OAK vs TBR Mike Fiers Maybe Diego Castillo Sit

Nick Pollack

Founder of Pitcher List. Creator of CSW, The List, and SP Roundup. Worked with MSG, FanGraphs, CBS Sports, and Washington Post. Former college pitcher, travel coach, pitching coach, and Brandeis alum. Wants every pitcher to be dope.

10 responses to “Sit/Start Week 23: Reviewing All Starting Pitcher Matchups From 9/10 – 9/16”

  1. BJ says:

    Nick, great stuff as always. Would appreciate your help locking in my final pitching spots in a H2H points league going into Week 1 playoffs. Need 2 of these 3 “Maybe”s:
    Gant vs. LAD
    Tyler Anderson @ SF
    Jose Urena @ NYM, @ PHI
    Right now I’m leaning Urena and Gant, Anderson has been too inconsistent even though SF vs. Stratton sounds cushy. Urena is the worst of the three, but I have no other two start pitchers going. I don’t have to start him @ Philly though. Any thoughts? Thanks in advance.

    • Nick Pollack says:

      Urena since it’s two starts.

      I’m not a big fan of Gant, honestly, and think you’re better off with Tyler as the Giants are terribly weak.

  2. Phil says:

    Nick, love this. Can’t tell you how helpful it is.

    In a H2H categories league, would you be any more willing to roll the dice with some of the maybes or even sits like Godley, Gibson, or Pivetta if your opponent was rolling out “weaker” sits like Newcomb, Fedde, or Suarez?


  3. Ed says:

    With Matz pushed to face Boston, is he a sit now? Start Pivetta over Matz?

  4. John Connors says:

    Would you rather start Veldez against Detroit or Pena against Texas. Where innings pitched and going for the W really Matter.

  5. Pitcher List Fan says:

    Rotoworld is showing Chen starting vs the Mets on Thursday. Worth starting if he does end up going against the mets?

  6. Al says:

    what about cc or vince velasquez today?

  7. David says:

    I’ve been looking for your 9/17 – 9/23 Sit or Start list? Was 9/10 – 9/16 your last one? My Yahoo fantasy league is still going on for possibly this week….and next if I make the Championship. Either way thanks for your great work all season!

    • Nick Pollack says:

      Sorry for the delay! I’m writing the two-week Sit/Start right now to replace The List. It’ll be up within the hour!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Account / Login