The List 6/12: Ranking The Top 100 Starting Pitchers Every Monday

Every Monday during the season, I will be releasing “The List” where I rank the current value of the Top 100 pitchers in fantasy baseball for the rest of the...

Every Monday during the season, I will be releasing “The List” where I rank the current value of the Top 100 pitchers in fantasy baseball for the rest of the season. Use these rankings to help understand what to expect from pitchers for 2017 and as a tool to gauge trade value in your fantasy leagues.

Let’s see how the SP landscape has changed:

[wpdatatable id=6]


  • I’m seeing four distinct tiers this week, often separated by injured players. Outside of the power trio of Kershaw, Scherzer, and Sale, there’s one at #22/#23 with Madison Bumgarner and Noah SyndergaardThen there is a distinct drop at Ervin Santana where it begins to become a free-for-all of upside vs. banking on rebounds. That slows down around Gerrit Cole and Kyle Hendricks at #52 with a number of middling options that are slightly more depending than what’s on your wire. A mini-group of injured arms returning soon (Jon Gray, Tyson Ross, Carlos Rodon) is the last gap that separates the rosterable and the waiver wire options. At this point, I’m looking short-term where I’m adding now and asking questions later, with the rest of the Top 100 sifting through possible streaming options that I wouldn’t bank on being consistent producers or have plenty of question in the amount of starts they get ROS.
  • Plenty of shuffling in the Top 20. James Paxton is slowing down giving him a few steps back, Dallas Keuchel is expected to miss 2-3 starts, Carlos Carrasco isn’t looking like himself, while Luis Severino and Carlos Martinez deserved bumps (Severino at #8!). Lance McCullers would have reached higher but missing the next start (maybe more?) forces me to dock him a point or two.
  • Chase Anderson’s velocity jump is extraordinary, averaging over 94mph suddenly across his last four starts. His ceiling is capped with his walk rate, but his current hot streak is well earned.
  • With more and more disappointments in starters (Justin Verlander, Kyle Hendricks, Gerrit Cole, Jose Quintana, etc.) more surprising names are popping up into ranks I had zero expectations they would see. Jimmy Nelson jumps into the Top 40, Jeff Hoffman climbs all the way to #42 (even with his uncertainty!), and pitchers that weren’t on people’s radar last week are suddenly Top 70 worthy (Jacob Faria, Sean Newcomb).
  • Speaking of which, Buck Farmer joins Faria and Newcomb as young arms getting playing time in the rotation. I see Faria as having the most polished repertoire of the bunch, with Newcomb having the most legitimate strikeout ability in his Curveball (a lack of third pitch concerns me). Farmer has flashed the K upside with his Changeup, but he’s still a bit of an unknown at the time and I question if he has the same ceiling as the other two.
  • Other new additions this week are Robert Gsellman, Jesse Hahn, Jaime Garcia, and Joe Ross who have all pitched well enough as of late to become a desperate choice for streams. Mike Montgomery also joins the ranks as a short term option with Kyle Hendricks on the DL.
  • Leaving The List this week are Nate Karns, Francisco Liriano, Jharel Cotton, Kenta Maeda, Chris Tillman, Kevin Gausman, Matt Andriese,  and David PaulinoWe don’t know when Andriese, Karns, and Maeda will get time on the hill again, Paulino’s time is limited and he is far from dependable enough at the moment, while Cotton, Gausman, Tillman, and Liriano aren’t pitching well enough to keep them in the Top 100.

Nick Pollack

Founder of Pitcher List. Creator of CSW, The List, and SP Roundup. Worked with MSG, FanGraphs, CBS Sports, and Washington Post. Former college pitcher, travel coach, pitching coach, and Brandeis alum. Wants every pitcher to be dope.

11 responses to “The List 6/12: Ranking The Top 100 Starting Pitchers Every Monday”

  1. Chucky says:

    Pick up Biagini for any of Godley, Guerra, Vargas or Wacha? Dynasty no contracts

  2. Scott says:

    Mccullers on dl. Hoffman, biagini, mccarthy, sabathia best short term add? Fyi, the add may be longer term too since i am losing patience with rich hill. I need quality starts amd a guy who cant go 6 doesnt help me.

  3. Manley Ramirez says:

    Surprised to see you being so aggressive on Hoffman, considering your usual reserve towards Rockies pitchers (was peak Gray ever even ranked this high?) and we haven’t really seen him in Coors yet.

  4. Sticki says:

    I’ve had enough of Porcello. I read a great article today about holding him but come on, rocked by the Phillies??

  5. tiwaniuk says:

    Hey Nick, thanks as always for the work you do here! I have a couple questions for you…

    1. I get Verlander not being ranked anywhere close to where he was to start the season, but #44? According to these rankings I should be dropping him for the likes of Nola, Gray, Nelson, Hoffman, Pomeranz, or Biagini (who are all available on my WW). However, I just don’t see myself doing that. What would you suggest we do with Verlander in a league that doesn’t really do trades?

    2. Again, according to these rankings, both Tyson Ross and Carlos Rodon are better DL stashes than Hamels (who I currently have on my DL). Would you make the swap for either of them?

    • Dave says:

      I’d be quicker to deal Verlander than drop him. I’m sure you can get someone better than those guys, but don’t forget that he struggled in the first half last year and then became an absolute machine down the stretch.

      • Nick Pollack says:

        I’m totally with you on Verlander being able to recover and I’ve written a ton about what Verlander did last year to make that rebound starting on May 8th…

        …which was a full month earlier than where we are now. It’s getting harder and harder to sit on our hands and wait for Verlander to make an adjustment.

  6. Benivan Stanciano says:

    Cotton, Faria or Chatty today?

  7. bobbo says:

    Hey Nick, I know Cueto has been dropping in your rankings but his peripherals don’t seem too bad. Any chance at a resurgence in the 2nd half?

    Would you give up A Reed + S Casilla for Cueto + Robertson? (10 team 6×6 roto with holds as the 6th cat)

    I have Jansen, Bush, and Neris as my other closers and A Miller as my holds man and could pick up a speculative Kahnle (who is somehow unowned) in case CWS gets frisky.

    (SP are Scherzer, Kluber, Berrios, Taillon, Bundy, and Jimmy Nelson with Rodon on DL)

  8. Dave says:

    Can I ask why Porcello is still so high? Sure, his BABIP is a little high, particularly for a fly ball pitcher, but his FIP, xFIP, and SIERA do not exact inspire confidence. He’s allowing more fly balls than ever, and 42.5% hard hit rate. My only guess is that, as you say, it’s a crap shoot after Lester, and that 34-52ish aren’t that far apart.

    I say this because I’m considering dropping Porcello (or Nelson) for Monty.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Account / Login