Going Deep: What’s Up With Andrew Benintendi?

Ben Palmer takes a look at why Andrew Benintendi has been struggling so much this season.

Photo by Doug Murray/Icon Sportswire

Andrew Benintendi has been one of my favorite prospects for a while now, and I was so psyched to see him turn in the type of year I knew he was capable of, going 20/20 with a .271/.352/.424 slashline and a solid 0.71 BB/K.

When people were drafting him in around the fourth or fifth round this year, I thought that was perfectly reasonable. I mean, the guy went 20/20 with a good average in his rookie year all supported by his peripherals, so we should at least expect that, right?

Well, so far this year, Benintendi has been a bit of a disappointment compared to the expectations levied his way in the preseason. So far, he’s slashing .244/.333/.395 on the year with just one home run and five stolen bases. He’s on pace for about 25 stolen bases, so that isn’t really an issue, but the average and power are, and it’s fair to wonder if this is just some bad luck, or if Benintendi is having some serious problems.

Diving deeper into Benintendi’s stats on the year leads you down an interesting path. When I see a hitter slumping this poorly, my first instinct is to look at plate discipline and batted ball stats. A look at Benintendi’s plate discipline shows he’s just as good as last year, with a walk rate of 12.3%, a strikeout rate of 17.4%, a chase rate of 28.3% (last year was 29%) and a whiff rate of 7.4% (last year was 7.6%).

Where you see the issue is in his batted ball stats. Specifically, his quality of contact stats:

Benintendi’s hard-hit rate has taken a nosedive, going from 34.3% last year to 20.6% this year. He’s also seen a massive drop in his HR/FB rate (obviously, considering he has just one home run), from 11.2% last year to 2.9% this year.

At first glance, that’s very concerning seeing his hard-hit rate drop so significantly, but the rest of his batted ball stats don’t support the narrative that he’s declining in skill. Take a look at his batted ball percentages this year compared to last year:

2017 21.5% 40.1% 38.4% 10.1% 11.2% 5.3%
2018 21.6% 42.3% 36.1% 8.6% 2.9% 4.9%

So aside from a very slight increase in his groundball rate and a slight decrease in his fly ball rate (along with the aforementioned drop in HR/FB rate), he’s hitting the ball just about the same. In fact, normally when I see a drop in hard-hit rate with a relatively static fly ball rate, I’d expect to see more infield fly balls, but that didn’t happen either.

So what is going on with Andrew Benintendi? Well as you can see from the batted ball graph from earlier, he not only saw a drop in his hard-hit rate, but a jump in his medium-hit rate, from 49.1% last year to 61.9% this year, while his soft-hit rate has remained fairly stable, increasing only slightly from 16.6% last year to 17.5% this year.

That’s good news, because if Benintendi’s hard-hit rate had dropped that significantly and we saw a subsequent increase in his soft-hit rate, I would be very concerned (especially if his groundball rate increased with it). But that’s not the case. In fact, what’s been happening with Benintendi is that he’s hitting a bunch of fly balls that are dying in the outfield.

On the left, you can see all the outs Benintendi has made this year. On the right are all the fly balls he’s hit that have hung in the air without turning into home runs (so, essentially, mostly catchable fly balls). It’s pretty clear that Benintendi is hitting a bunch of these fly balls that are dying in the outfield, which is why his hard-hit rate has declined so much and why his medium-hit rate has increased so much.

It’s also worth noting that Benintendi has started pulling the ball a lot more this year, increasing his pull rate from 34.3% last year to 44.3% this year, which typically is good news for power.

Considering the fact that Benintendi’s batted-ball profile has changed very little, aside from the hard-hit rate decrease and medium-hit rate increase, I’m not overly concerned about his production going forward. Some of those fly balls are going to turn into home runs, hitters like Benintendi don’t typically have medium-hit rates as high as he does.

In fact, last year’s leader in medium-hit rate was Dee Gordon with 59.2%, followed by Billy Hamilton at 59.0%. That’s not the kind of hitter Benintendi is, which leads me to believe that his medium-hit rate is unsustainable, and given that it doesn’t seem like he’s hurt, nor has his plate discipline gotten any worse, I’d expect his average and power to go back to normal soon enough, making him an interesting buy-low candidate.

Ben Palmer

Senior columnist at Pitcher List. Lifelong Orioles fan, also a Ravens/Wizards/Terps fan. I also listen to way too much music, watch way too many movies, and collect way too many records.

8 responses to “Going Deep: What’s Up With Andrew Benintendi?”

  1. Bob says:

    Thanks for doing this. He’s my fourth round pick and so far he’s been one of the biggest bust in the top 40. Here’s to hoping he can turn it around! This guy was ranked in front of Yoan Moncanda in the red sox prospect rankings. He’s supposed to be a .300 hitter, and basically was during his short time in the minors. Do you see him being that from here on out? A .280 hitter with 15-20 (which he is not even on pace for) home runs even with 20-25 steals is not worth an ADP of even the top 60 in today’s game. Especially given he only has outfield eligibility.

    • Ben Palmer says:

      I don’t know that he’ll hit .300 the rest of the way, but I think 20-25 steals will happen, and I think he’ll probably hit in the .270s ROS. I wouldn’t be shocked if he gets to 20 home runs, but given his slow start, I think 15 is more likely.

  2. Jacoby says:

    Would you rather own Benintendi or Yelich ROS?

    • Ben Palmer says:

      That’s extremely close for me. I think I might lean Benintendi just because I think he’ll get 20-25 steals whereas I think Yelich will have closer to 15. I think Yelich will have a slightly better batting average and the two will have similar power, so the steals put it over the top for me.

  3. Rainmaker says:

    Appreciate the analysis — thorough and balanced. I don’t expect the power to change materially, but I do think he’ll bat closer to .300 ROS. Looking at his career stats and his above average speed, he should be an above average BABIP guy which means he’s maybe 25-30 pts off in BABIP today, but its important to note that his xStats don’t really show him as “unlucky” per se. Given his carer ISO, I’d expect HRs will also drive his slash up a tick (in addition to the BABIP), but I’m not sure he’s really built to hit more than 20HR. His true skill ISO seems to peg around .175 (at least today, I’m sure he’ll continue to mature physically) which correlates to 18-22HR per year

    • Ben Palmer says:

      Yea, I mean even at his peak, I don’t expect him to hit more than 20-25 home runs, and I think he’s more a 20 home run guy than anything. It’s the balance of the speed/power/average that makes him so appealing, and I do think he’ll get some of that back.

  4. Swfcdan says:

    Dylan Bundy….oops sorry for ruining your day forget I said that name! As an owner in a keeper who bought after his great start and got his last 3 starts….yikes! Is he cuttable in 12 teamers at this point? He’s either hurt or off mechanically, either way hoping for a disgraceful list trip to stash him away and get him fixed.

    Liked your deep dive on Ozuna too (think it was you?). Still not showing any power yet, would you flip him for Polanco given the choice now? I had the choice of either when trading Manaea, so maybe he’ll be happy with his return to show me some pity!

    • Ben Palmer says:

      For Bundy – I wouldn’t drop him personally. He’s still got good strikeout upside and his elevated HR/FB rate will come down. He’s got a SIERA of 3.68, I think that sounds about right.

      For Ozuna – I didn’t write that, but I’m glad you liked the article! I wouldn’t have a problem flipping him for Polanco at all. I believe in a Polanco bounceback

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Account / Login