Closing Time 4/11: Ranking the Top 30 Closers Every Tuesday

Ranking baseball's closers for the 2023 season.

Evan Phillips has emerged as the Dodgers’ primary closer and all it took were a couple of shaky Brusdar Graterol appearances. The Dodgers have seemed determined to keep Phillips out of the ninth-inning role but their hand has been forced, which is great for those who drafted Phillips. Despite only one strikeout so far (he’s faced a lot of lefties to begin the season), he has yet to allow a run in four outings. I get the sense Phillips will be used more like a “Rays” closer, in that he won’t see all of the save chances, but this development certainly makes him a most-rostered reliever in all but the shallowest of formats.




  • Even despite last night’s blown save, A.J. Minter should still be close to rostered in all leagues as the news on Raisel Iglesias injury has not been as optimistic as we had hoped for. He has yet to resume throwing off a mound, but he has at least begun throwing on flat ground, so all that being said, Minter should be the closer here for the next month or possibly longer.
  • Scott Barlow has pitched well this season (three-inning sample size of course) despite his fastball being down 1.5 MPH, and while I’m not overly concerned with that right now, I am concerned with how well Aroldis Chapman has been throwing. I doubt the Royals would just change things up as is, but it may just take 1-2 blown saves to get Chapman into the role now.


  • Alex Lange has seen some weird usage to begin the year so far, and while I still believe he’s the best reliever in this bullpen, the early season results have not been great. Velocity is down almost 2 MPH, while his fastball is up 1 MPH and not getting the Whiffs we are used to. This could be a mechanical thing so I’d still sit tight and wait for things to turn around for Lange.
  • Andrew Chafin now has two saves on the season for the Diamondbacks, striking out the side in order yesterday to finish off the Brewers. What’s more interesting is that he faced two righties in the inning (Joey Wiemer and Willy Adames) while just facing one lefty in Christian Yelich. Chafin looks like the favorite for saves in this pen now and makes for a worthy speculative add in deeper leagues.


Rank Pitcher Change
1Emmanuel ClaseT1-
2Devin Williams-
3Josh Hader-
4Félix Bautista+1
5Jordan Romano-1
6Ryan Helsley-
7Ryan Pressly-
8Kenley Jansen-
9Jhoan Duran
10Pete Fairbanks-
11Paul Sewald-
12Evan Phillips+UR
13David Bednar
14Clay Holmes+1
15Alexis Díaz-2
16Camilo Doval-2
17David Robertson
18Michael Fulmer+2
19A.J. Puk-2
20A.J. Minter+4
21Scott Barlow
22Alex Lange-4
23José Leclerc-2
24Reynaldo López-2
25Carlos Estévez-2
26Craig Kimbrel
27Andrew Chafin+UR
28Pierce Johnson+2
29Kyle Finnegan-2
30Dany Jiménez-2


Watch List


And if you want more daily reliever updates, please check out our Reliever Ranks series

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

2 responses to “Closing Time 4/11: Ranking the Top 30 Closers Every Tuesday”

  1. Noah Dengler says:

    you listed chafin as #27 but he’s also on your watchlist as #4, just thought you should know

  2. J H Bauer says:

    I agree that Alvarez is the man in Philly. Boxburger looks to be getting it done in Chicago. Any news on Iglaisias or Munoz?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Account / Login