Hello and welcome to year 3 of me grading these rebound picks! During last offseason/Spring Training, I looked at one player on each MLB team I found capable of having a bounce-back season in 2026. These articles can be found at the links below:
AL East | AL Central | AL West
NL East | NL Central | NL West
This article will look at all 15 American League players I considered to be rebound candidates entering 2026. I will be assessing their results compared to previous seasons, and assigning a “grade” (F to A+) accordingly.
Compared to years past, I went from three players per division to one per team. This decision contributed to a far wider range of results, with injuries, lack of playing time, and trades all affecting players differently. Still, I thoroughly enjoyed looking through each 40-man roster and plan to stick with a higher volume/variance approach for these rebound picks in the future.
AL East
Blue Jays – Jeff Hoffman
Grade: B
Jeff Hoffman had a remarkably solid 2026 season, pitching to a 3.55 ERA/2.48 FIP in 66.0 IP split between the Blue Jays and Twins. This was helped by a career-high 34.9% strikeout rate, adding depth and swing-and-miss to a now primary-offering slider.
Another contributing factor was luck; Hoffman’s 20.0 HR/FB% in 2025 was his worst as a reliever and led to 15 homers against. That number dropped to 4 in an equivalent 2026 sample.
However, a .356 BABIP was his highest as a reliever, and a -1.06 WPA suggests Hoffman’s results weren’t as good as they seemed. Still, gains in swing-and-miss and hard contact are more sustainable and could lead to solid results for the Twins in 2027, the final year of a previously signed 3-year, $33 million deal with the Jays.
Orioles – Shane Baz
Grade: B
In his first season with the Orioles, Shane Baz pitched to a respectable 4.11 ERA/3.62 FIP in 31 starts/179.2 innings. Despite leading MLB in losses, the veteran righty now has back-to-back seasons of making 31 starts, overcoming early-career injury concerns while anchoring an underwhelming O’s rotation.
Still, some of Baz’s metrics left more to be desired. An 11.8 K-BB% is underwhelming, and a career-best 7.1 HR-FB% helped limit damage. A lot of his arsenal concerns remained, as well, with lefties taking advantage of his mediocre changeup in particular.
Baz enters 2027 in the second year of a 5-year, $68 million extension with the Orioles. He currently projects as their SP2, and will look to further develop his arsenal and remain a high-upside talent in Baltimore.
Rays – Cedric Mullins
Grade: D
Rays fourth-outfielder Cedric Mullins had another rough season in 2026, posting a career-worst 76 wRC+ despite a solid 15 home runs/21 stolen bases. The former Orioles mainstay signed a one-year deal with the Rays to add experience to a young outfield, and struggled to bounce back offensively.
However, Mullins came around on the other side of the ball. With former Rays outfielder Kevin Kiermaier taking a bigger role in the organization, Mullins posted a career-high 7.4 Fangraphs defensive runs in 2026, quickly reversing a downward trend in his outfield ratings.
Mullins is now a free agent after he and the Rays declined a $10-million mutual option for 2027.
Red Sox – Justin Slaten
Grade: C
After losing most of 2025 to injury, Justin Slaten had a better 2026 before eventually facing an elbow injury and missing the remainder of the season. The 29-year-old reliever posted a career-best 22.6 K-BB% and 2.82 xFIP in 31.1 innings, despite a 4.60 ERA. Slaten will need to get healthy again to re-establish the elite upside he flashed with Boston in 2024.
Yankees – Ryan McMahon
Grade: F
Ryan McMahon continued to struggle at sea level in 2026, remaining a replacement-level option for the Yankees. In 124 games, the veteran third baseman hit 11 home runs with a 78 wRC+, his lowest since a COVID-shortened 2020.
Difficulties making enough contact and consistently pulling hard contact made McMahon a poor matchup for Yankee Stadium, and a decline in walks, sprint speed, and defensive ratings all contributed to his eventual loss of playing time.
In 2027, McMahon will enter the final year of a 6-year, $70 million extension, and will likely remain an option at third base. McMahon will look to re-establish his value as a strong defensive third baseman and hopefully figure his swing out in a competitive Yankees infield mix.
AL Central
Guardians – Bo Naylor
Grade: D
Bo Naylor had quite the eventful 2026 season, struggling in the Guardians system between the Majors and AAA before an August 1st trade sent him to the eventual World Champion Brewers, where a solid finish to the season left Naylor in a good spot for 2027. As the projected backup to William Contreras, Naylor is just 26 and remains a strong defender with long-ball upside.
Royals – Cole Ragans and Tigers – Parker Meadows
Grades: n/a
Both Cole Ragans and Parker Meadows had their 2026 season cut short by season-ending injuries, with Ragans down in early May with UCL damage and Meadows down in April after a severe outfield collision. Meadows is expected to be ready for the 2027 season (whenever that will be), and Ragans should be recovered by April/May 2027.
Twins – Bailey Ober
Grade: C-
Bailey Ober had another weird 2026 season, with his fastball velocity continuing to decline (88.3, down from 90.3) and results remaining ambiguous. In 24 starts/25 games, Ober pitched to a 4.47 ERA/4.61 FIP and a career-low 10.5 K-BB%, but improved on a results basis from an awful 2025.
Limiting hard contact and throwing strikes were essential to Ober’s success, with a solid slider/sweeper pairing doing the bulk of work for an otherwise underwhelming pitch mix. Despite his elite extension, averaging 88 on a four-seam with an otherwise average pitch mix is a really tough barrier to overcome.
White Sox – Erick Fedde
Grade: C
2026 was an interesting season for Erick Fedde, who pitched to a strong 3.83 ERA in 141.0 innings in his return to the South Side. However, a 5.01 FIP/4.81 xFIP, elevated by a whopping 23 homers allowed, hurt his peripherals. Still, reuniting with White Sox director of pitching Brian Bannister saw a bump in velocity and a return of the elite sweeper that proved crucial to Fedde’s success.
Now a free agent, Fedde remains a solid innings-eater option and has shown reasonable upside in his White Sox career thus far.
AL West
Angels – Logan O’Hoppe
Grade: F
Logan O’Hoppe had another rough season in the Majors in 2026, appearing in 85 games between the Angels and Rangers before finishing his season in AAA. The former top prospect has continued to struggle defensively without the elite power upside he’s flashed in the past.
Shipped to the Rangers before the Trade Deadline, O’Hoppe played fairly well in AAA with a much-reduced 17.5% strikeout rate. Keeping that number down while showing any upside defensively will be key for O’Hoppe sticking behind the plate long-term. Now the projected backup to Danny Jansen, O’Hoppe has shown offensive promise in the past and could continue seeing playing time in the future.
Astros – Cristian Javier
Grade: D
After struggling with injuries for the past two seasons, Cristian Javier had another up-and-down season in 2026 while missing time throughout. In 12 starts/17 appearances, Javier’s 5.14 ERA/4.72 were among his career worst marks, as a shockingly low 24.2% ground ball rate contributed to lots of extra-base hits.
Javier’s four-seam has been a step worse than in 2022 for a while, where he broke out with a 2.54 ERA/3.16. Developing an arsenal around it has proven difficult, and the now-29-year-old will look to stay healthy and ideally induce a few more ground balls in the future.
Athletics – Lawrence Butler
Grade: C
Lawrence Butler had a rough start in 2026, with just a 62 wRC+ in the 1st half before finishing strong with a 130 wRC+ in the 2nd. The young outfielder also took a step back defensively and was a negative contributor on the bases in 2026, contrary to his previous two seasons.
Despite generating negative fWAR on the season, Butler’s career-best 11.3% walk rate and best xwOBA (.326) since a 130 wRC+ breakout in 2024 (.341) were encouraging signs. Getting off to a more consistent start and proving to be a safe option in the outfield will be key to Butler re-establishing his value for the Athletics.
Mariners – Bryce Miller
Grade: B-
Bryce Miller had a similarly inconsistent 2026, showing flashes of dominance with elite velocity in some starts while struggling to miss bats in others. Another starter plagued by injuries, Miller ended 2026 with a 4.17 ERA/4.41 FIP (although 3.70 xERA/3.94 xFIP!) in 21 starts/22 games.
Overall, a 16.7 K-BB% is encouraging and in line with his breakout 2024 season. Miller’s elite pitch mix also continued generating chases and limiting hard-hit contact. Still, Miller’s success will come down to his fastball’s effectiveness and his own availability on the field.
Rangers – Jordan Montgomery
Grade: C
Jordan Montgomery finally made his return to the Majors in 2026, appearing in 13 games out of the bullpen upon activation from the 60-day injured list in August. In these appearances, Montgomery pitched to a 4.15 ERA/3.87 ERA in 26.0 innings, with a solid 13.5 K-BB% and 3.46 SIERA agreeing with his plus results.
However, Montgomery’s fastball velocity topped out in the low 90s, and the rest of his arsenal dropped a few ticks from the past. Montgomery still managed to limit hard contact and keep the ball on the ground, however, and is currently a free agent with solid upside.