Closing Time 8/22: Ranking the Top 30 Closers Every Tuesday

Ranking baseball's closers for the 2023 season.

Andrés Muñoz has been really good since returning from the IL back in early June, but really good isn’t what we were expecting from him entering the season.

Since the All-Star break, Muñoz has just 25.9% K and 14.6% SwStr rates to go along with a 1.42 WHIP over 18.1 IP. Those numbers are fine, but this is a guy who had a 0.89 WHIP plus 38.7% K and 21.4% SwStr rates for the entire 2022 season. This could be the result of diminished velocity (down almost 2 MPH from last year) but he’s also throwing more of a two-seamer/sinker combo this season, leading to a huge uptick in groundballs (63.9% GB up from 52.6% last year).

He may not be pitching at the elite level he was at last season, but he is still the favorite for saves. However, Matt Brash (and even Gabe Speier) will still factor into save chances in what is turning out to be more of a committee approach than just Muñoz taking over the closer role entirely.




  • Kyle Finnegan continues to rise up the list and now has ten saves since the All-Star break while allowing just three earned runs (all on home runs). Finnegan’s 27.9% K-BB rate since the break is good for 7th best amongst active closers, while his 2.74 xFIP is good for 5th best over that span. That being said, he is very four-seam dependent, throwing the pitch 74% of the time, and it’s definitely part of the reason he has one of the worst hard contact rates in baseball (92.3 MPH average EV, 31.5% HC, and 46.2% HardHit rates), and lacks in the swing and miss department (11.2% SwStr, 25% Whiff rates). He’s safe for now though and at least worth rostering until the wheels fall off.
  • David Robertson had another rough outing for the Marlins this past weekend, allowing three earned runs on four hits against the Dodgers while working the 8th inning of that game. Robertson has now allowed seven earned runs over seven innings this month, while also having a disappointing 6/5 K/BB ratio. I don’t think it would be a shock to see Tanner Scott get some save chances moving forward, or perhaps the team even turns back to A.J. Puk, whose luck seems to be turning around finally.


  • Will Smith may be fading from the Rangers’ closer picture and if it wasn’t for Aroldis Chapman’s blown save last night, there’s a chance I would have had Chapman on the list today. Chapman’s blown save did result in Smith picking up a loss later in the game as he allowed two earned runs in extras, so perhaps Chapman still gains an edge on Smith following last night’s game. Regardless, I think if you are in a spot to roster just one of these two, you have to go with Chapman at this point. Smith has a 10.80 ERA (5.24 xFIP) and 1.80 WHIP over his past 10 outings (plus a blah 10% K-BB rate), so if the team was going to pivot to Chapman full time at some point, now would seem to be the time.
  • Justin Lawrence has been pretty ineffective in August for the Rockies and only has five saves since the All-Star break while Trevor May has shown some positive signs recently, and has no competition for saves in Oakland. Lawrence on the other hand could wind up losing his role to maybe someone like Tyler Kinley (I know he has a 9.53 ERA and 2.12 WHIP right now, but an 8/2 K/BB ratio over 5.2 IP is a positive) who is signed through next season.



And if you want more daily reliever updates, please check out our Reliever Ranks series

Watch List


Rank Pitcher Change
1Félix BautistaT1-
2Devin Williams
3Craig Kimbrel-
4Ryan Pressly-
5Camilo Doval-
6Josh Hader-
7Paul Sewald-
8Jhoan Duran-
9Raisel Iglesias-
10Jordan Romano-
11Emmanuel Clase-
12Evan Phillips+1
13Adbert Alzolay+2
14Pete Fairbanks-
15David Bednar+1
16Alexis Díaz+1
17Kenley Jansen+1
18Clay Holmes+2
19Andrés Muñoz-7
20Kyle Finnegan+4
21Gregory Santos+1
22David Robertson-3
23Carlos Estévez
24Will Smith-3
25Jason Foley-
26Carlos Hernández-
27Adam Ottavino-
28JoJo Romero-
29Trevor May+1
30Justin Lawrence-1

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Account / Login