+

Projection Based Prospect Rankings: Second Base

Taking a granular look at the second base prospect pool.

The off-season is a perfect time to dive into article ideas that the regular season simply lacks the time for. Each year, I attempt to refine my prospect ranking process. My goal is always to keep followers up to date on the latest trends and prospects that they need to roster in dynasty leagues. For those who consistently follow along, thank you.

Admittedly, the current process is not perfect. That is where this article comes into play. Bias undoubtedly plays a part in my current prospect rankings. What is one good way to remove bias? Data and numbers. So, I am taking the top 20 at each position (with some help from Matt Heckman) and comparing their end-of-season prospect-list ranking to where they would rank in terms of projections to identify any prospects that are currently misrepresented in terms of rankings.

The Math

Each of the top 20 prospects at each position was taken and put into a spreadsheet. From there, each prospect was given a ceiling and floor projection. These projections are not data-driven, but personal scouting beliefs. The categories factoring into the model were home runs, stolen bases, batting average, strikeouts, and walks. From there, a “confidence level” was assigned to each prospect. This confidence level indicates the confidence I have in a prospect reaching their ceiling. For example, if a prospect has an 80% confidence level, then their expected projection is calculated as 80% of their ceiling and 20% of their floor.

From there, I worked with AI to build a scoring model that accounts for both positional value and a prospect’s ceiling, weighting the ceiling a bit more heavily. Positional value was factored in by utilizing FanGraphs Auction Calculator from the 2026 season. The model looks at the “elite producers” for home runs, stolen bases, and batting average at each position, the “average producers,” and the “replacement level” producers with the assumption of a standard 12-team fantasy league. To create a position benchmark blend, the model pulls 80% of the “elite producers”, 10% of the “average producers,” and 10% of the “replacement level” producers. From there, the model spits out a score for each prospect in each category based on their expected projection. The model takes 90% of a prospect’s expected projection, but also 10% of the prospect’s ceiling projection to account for upside.

The final result is a score assigned to each prospect. The goal is that throughout a prospect’s development curve, their ceiling or floor could be easily adjusted to better reflect their long-term projection. Their confidence level can also be adjusted as they develop. This article will dive into a little bit of each prospect’s projection and then compare the rankings in terms of score versus the end-of-season prospect list.

Initial Thoughts

As I began assessing the second base position, a few things were already apparent. The player pool, which will ultimately include some additional talents sliding over from SS, is fairly top-heavy. The first five players in my personal rankings are all inside the Top 100 overall, followed by a pretty sizeable gap down to the Max Anderson–Michael Arroyo-Wilder Dalis types who rank just inside the Top 130, then another gap to Jett Williams. Speaking of shortstops (and third basemen), some players appear here and in Matt’s shortstop and third base projections. As a result, their scores/projections differ. For example, I have a bit more confidence in Jefferson Rojas and Luis Peña, which leads to higher overall scores for each player.

The Prospects

Jefferson Rojas-NYM

 

Expected Projection: .258/24.6 HR/20.2 SB/21.6 K%/8.6 BB%

 

Score: 75.2

 

After an underwhelming 2025, Rojas answered a lot of questions in 2026 with a 27-homer season, mostly at Double-A. Adding in-game power gave him a huge boost in offensive value after he barely cracked the double-digit threshold the previous season. Rojas did so with a bit more aggression, swinging 5% more often and chasing more, albeit with a 4% dip in his contact rate. That said, he impacted the ball much harder and launched the ball in the air to his pull side with much more consistency. In a small Triple-A sample to close out the year, his quality-of-contact numbers were very impressive, at least temporarily validating his newfound power. With Rojas’ blend of hit, power, and speed, I gave him a confidence rating of 60%, and the model validated him as the #1 second baseman at the position.

 

Luis Peña-MIL

 

Expected Projection: .273/9.3 HR/25.8 SB/21.6 K%/9.8 BB%

 

Score: 54.5

 

A tough finish to 2025 followed by an injury-plagued 2026 slowed Pena’s momentum toward becoming a Top 10 overall prospect. Now 20, the diminutive infielder is still young and possesses some advanced, fantasy-friendly skills. He has double-plus speed, above-average bat-to-ball skills, and at least league-average raw power. The in-game pop has yet to develop, though, as Pena has failed to reach double-digit homers at any level, which makes him difficult to project. At the same time, he’s very skilled at finding the barrel and still growing into his frame, which leads me to believe some power is coming. My confidence rating of 55% is based solely on the hit tool and speed and would be higher if I knew the long-term power outlook. Hopefully Pena’s 2027 will provide a clearer representation of what we can expect, although it may be difficult coming off a broken leg suffered in September.

 

Mitch Voit-NYM

 

Expected Projection: .259/ 17.2 HR/ 19.8 SB/ 24.0 K%/ 9.3 BB%

 

Score: 53.6

 

Voit’s emergence in 2026 was a bit of a surprise for me personally, as I didn’t rank him very high coming out of the University of Michigan last summer. The 21-year-old delivered a monster debut, slashing .273/.371/.431 with 13 homers and 45 steals while reaching Double-A. Voit did a little bit of everything at the dish, including drawing walks at a 10% clip while maintaining a sub-20% K rate. Formerly a two-way player, Voit is a tremendous pure athlete with quick, twitchy movements and double-plus speed. His hit tool was easily plus this summer as well, leaving his power projection as the lone unknown. Based on bat speed, pull air rate, and the limited batted-ball data we have, I feel confident in projecting Voit as a future 20-homer bat. All told, I really like what Voit offers, and he should be a perennial Top 12 asset at the position.

 

Demetrio Crisantes-ARI

 

Expected Projection: .282/ 11.6 HR/ 4.3 SB/ 15.7 K%/ 8.3 BB%

 

Score: 41.9

 

After missing most of 2025, Crisantes stayed on the field for most of this season, playing in 92 games across three levels. He finished with a very Crisantes-esque line, batting .292 with ten homers and a .377 OBP. Crisantes may have the best hit tool at this position, barely swinging and missing, making elite swing decisions, and showing no clear deficiencies against any pitch type. He also has fringy power and speed, which ultimately limits his upside. Assuming he can continue to hit for a high average, his fantasy value will depend on how much in-game pop he can develop. My 65% confidence rating reflects my assessment of the hit tool and my skepticism about the supporting skills. His score reflects what I see as a high-floor, low-ceiling profile.

 

Roldy Brito-COL

 

Expected Projection: .266/11.9 HR/26.9 SB/21.3 K%/6.5 BB%

 

Score: 54.1

 

I’m not at all surprised by how well Brito scored in this exercise. Last season, at 19, he hit .305 with 10 homers and 41 steals across two levels of A-ball, while posting a sub-20% strikeout rate. The bat-to-ball skills appear to be very solid, with excellent contact rates despite an aggressive approach. Brito has little problem maximizing his power from both sides of the plate and projects as a 15-18-homer bat at his peak. He’s also a terrific athlete, showing plus run times and defensive versatility as he’s played both 2B and CF in the Minors. My confidence level is just under 50% because of his age and lack of track record, but the model loves his five-category contribution, which has helped raise his score.

 

Max Anderson-DET

 

Expected Projection: .266/10.0 HR/4.0 SB/17.5 K%/9.0 BB%

 

Score: 28.7

 

Anderson’s score was considerably lower than I anticipated, given his ability to get on base at a high clip, with an above-average hit tool and average power. In 2026, he hit .302 with an 11% walk rate, adding 17 homers and 6 steals at Triple-A. Anderson is fairly aggressive at the plate, swinging over 50% of the time with a fair amount of chase and a very high Z-swing %. He supported his aggression with above-average contact rates and high grades for his swing decisions. He’s not a zero in power, producing a 90th percentile EV of around 103mph, but he does not consistently pull the ball in the air, which could be problematic at Comerica Park. Anderson should be an option as the Tigers’ primary 2B in 2027, or at the very least, a utility infielder.

 

Michael Arroyo-SEA

 

Expected Projection: .259/8.4 HR/10.9 SB/19.4 K%/7.5 BB%

 

Score: 25.4

 

Arroyo has always been a very difficult player for me to rank. on one hand, he’s shown a strong hit tool with really good contact rates, both overall and in-zone; he runs well, and he can draw walks. At the same time, his power output is misleading and inconsistent. His best seasons were in very favorable hitting environments like Modesto (A) and Everett (A+), while he was well below average at Double-A Arkansas in 2025, but then repeated the level with better success this past season. Another relevant piece of his profile, though not fantasy-related, is a lack of defensive acumen. Arroyo is a mediocre defender trapped at a position behind a Gold Glove winner in Cole Young, who also offers significantly more offensive thump. With no clear carrying tool or path to playing time, Arroyo gets dinged in my confidence level, which caused his score to plummet.

 

Wilder Dalis-COL

 

Expected Projection: .257/14.2 HR/9.8 SB/24.2 K%/8.2 BB%

 

Score: 32.0

 

Dalis has done nothing but hit since debuting in the DSL as a 16-year-old in 2023. Now 19, he’s become an intriguing young prospect, continuing to show growth in both power and speed. Dalis put together a breakout 2026 season, mashing 19 homers with 27 steals, mostly at Low-A. His contact rates have steadily improved year over year, especially as his approach has become more consistent and less aggressive. With his improved approach have come better swing decisions and substantially more impact on the baseball. According to Baseball America, he increased his 90th percentile EV by over two mph this season, now sitting comfortably above the MLB average at 104.6mph. The main driver behind Dalis’ low score is a confidence rating of 45, largely due to his age and lack of track record with his improved skills.

 

Jett Williams-MIL

 

Expected Projection: .262/9.5 HR/17.9 SB/23.1 K%/9.0 BB%

 

Score: 36.9

 

Aside from a momentary lapse in judgment back in 2024, Williams is a guy I’ve been highly skeptical of throughout his career. The versatile Brewers’ prospect is an enigma as a fantasy asset, often falling short of what could be and leaving owners wanting more. Williams had a disappointing season in 2026, batting .233 with 9 homers and 21 steals at Triple-A, a far cry from his 17-homer, 34-steal performance the year prior. Under the hood, he’s doing a lot of good things, including improving his contact rate, which sat around 81% in 2026, up 5% year-over-year. Williams is trending the wrong way with his batted-ball data, which now sits a few ticks below the MLB average. He is still pulling the ball in the air at a high clip, but the launch angles and quality-of-contact metrics just aren’t there. Williams has also struggled to find a defensive home, likely meaning he’ll remain on the outside looking in within a very deep Milwaukee organization.

 

JD Dix-ARI

 

Expected Projection: .254/9.2 HR/12.3 SB/18.7 K%/6.9 BB%

 

Score: 27.1

 

In year two as a pro, the Wisconsin native showed a dynamic fantasy skill set, producing his first double-digit home run and steal output in his age-20 season. Dix showed a solid hit tool with much more in-game power than in his debut, though he doesn’t pull the ball in the air enough and lacks the prerequisite raw power to hit it out to the opposite field. A plus runner, Dix should continue to be impactful on the bases, likely with a 15-20 steal ceiling depending on his OBP. Having yet to play above High-A, the earliest we could project his arrival would be mid-to-late 2028.

 

Daniel Dickinson-MIL

 

Expected Projection: .254/10.9 HR/19.2 SB/22.6 K%/6.9 BB%

 

Score: 35.3

 

The Brewers have a loaded system, and one player quietly popping off is 22-year-old Daniel Dickinson. The former LSU Tiger is a ballplayer, possessing a well-rounded profile on both sides of the ball. Despite being regarded as a hit-over-power, Dickinson had three double-digit HR seasons at LSU and then hit 11 at High-A in his pro debut in 2026. There’s sneaky pop here along with terrific hand-eye coordination, giving him a relatively high offensive floor. Dickinson is also a very cerebral player and has used that to his advantage on the bases. He’s never produced elite run times yet swiped 61 bases in 120 games this season. That said, it’s hard to project him for anything more than 15-25 at his peak because the foot speed just isn’t there.

 

Luke Dickerson-WSH

 

Expected Projection: .241/13.1 HR/11.9 SB/27.7 K%/9.9 BB%

 

Score: 22.2

 

Dickerson is a Jersey kid who was a multi-sport athlete in high school (hockey) and came into the pro game with raw but impressive tools. One thing that’s helped build (and diminish) his baseball identity is his passivity at the plate. Dickerson doesn’t swing much (37% in ’26) and never chases, instead taking a ton of pitches and posting very high walk rates, including 20.1% in 2026. At the same time, he takes called strikes at a 16-to-18% clip, which, along with poor overall contact rates, has consistently produced strikeout rates in the mid-20s to low 30s. Because he doesn’t engage much with the ball, he’s hard to project. When he does swing, he tends to hit fly balls to the pull side, which could bode well for future power. He also runs well, making him a potentially impactful baserunner.

 

Luke Hill-CLE

 

Expected Projection: .258/11.6 HR/7.1 SB/24.4 K%/7.5 BB%

 

Score: 21.8

 

As I started this process, Hill was grading out much worse than I expected, but after seeing him in the AFL, I felt a bit more confident in the player. The 22-year-old played collegiately at Ole Miss, repeatedly showing an outstanding hit tool and posting a high batting average with huge OBP numbers. He carried that into his post-draft debut and his first full season in 2026. As expected, he’s seen some regression in his contact rates at the pro level, but still maintains a mid-teens walk rate and a K rate hovering around 20%. Hill has also produced more power as a pro, hitting 13 homers in the regular season and then two more in the AFL, where he has a .951 OPS. I gave Hill a 52% confidence rating based on the current profile, but if he continues to show in-game power and slowly regains the contact rates, I wouldn’t be surprised to see him as a borderline Top 150 prospect.

 

Míguel Hernandez– STL

 

Expected Projection: .239/18.8 HR/2.4 SB/27.0 K%/8.8 BB%

 

Score: 21.1

 

Projecting an 18-year-old with 110 career MiLB games and only 25 at Low-A isn’t easy, but here we go. Hernandez made a name for himself this summer, batting .282 with 11 homers, 18 steals, and a 20.1% walk rate across two levels. He showed good plate skills, drawing a high volume of walks, rarely chasing, and making good contact. Hernandez also hit the ball hard early on, averaging over 95mph with his EV in rookie ball and a hard-hit rate over 71%. He didn’t reach those levels in A-ball, but he sustained good contact rates and high walk rates while limiting his Ks. At 6 feet, 150 pounds, you have to think Hernandez will fill out his frame, adding muscle and, ideally, more power. That also could impact his speed, which is around league average at present. My best guess for Hernandez is a 15+ homer bat with a decent batting average and an occasional stolen base.

 

Émilien Pitre-NYM

 

Expected Projection: .269/2.1 HR/17.9 SB/12.9 K%/8.1 BB%

 

Score: 33.3

 

Pitre has arguably the safest profile in the lower half of this positional group, largely due to his advanced bat-to-ball skills and his plus speed. Beyond that, there’s not a ton to love in the profile for fantasy purposes. In 2026, he slashed .306/.420/.427 with 33 XBH (6 HR), 35 steals, and more walks (80) than strikeouts (58), with most of his production coming at Double-A. Pitre has elite contact rates for a prospect, pushing 90% in-zone with single-digit swinging-strike rates. He also runs well, which can help his BABIP, which he’ll need with a 50% groundball rate. There’s not much raw power, so any over-the-fence production would come from his ability to find the barrel consistently. Pitre has improved enough defensively to project as a utility infielder if he makes the Majors.

 

Henry Godbout-BOS

 

Expected Projection: .259/15.1 HR/4 SB/17.0 K%/9.5 BB%

 

Score: 38.5

 

Godbout projects similarly to Dickinson, only without the speed. The former UVA infielder had an abbreviated debut season in 2026, playing in just 61 games across three levels, but hit .291 with 15 homers, 11 doubles, and 9 steals. His rapid path up the organization is a testament to his experience and pedigree as a collegiate hitter, but also reflects how well he performed. At every stop, Godbout hit for a high average, put up good power metrics, and got on base at a high rate. His strikeouts did tick up in a small Double-A sample, but his contact rates were above average, and he still had a single-digit SwStr%. Projecting his power is tricky because we don’t have much batted-ball data. What we do know is that he had a 35% groundball rate this season, along with a 52.7% pull rate and 27.2% and 25.9% pull-air rates at High-A and Double-A, respectively. Assuming health, we should have a better idea of what Godbout is capable of after a full 2027 season.

 

Roc Riggio-COL

 

Expected Projection: .237/16.6 HR/6.0 SB/26.4 K%/6.3 BB%

 

Score: 18.1

 

Riggio is a fun player with impressive skills for his size, but he also has a few red flags. He was traded to the Rockies organization late in 2025 and, in his first full season with them, hit .265 with 22 homers and 21 steals, mostly at Double-A. At 5’9 “, 180, Riggio gives off some Caleb Durbin starter-kit vibes, with the ability to pull the ball in the air with good EVs and maximize his physical stature. At the same time, he’s not as athletic or as quick on the bases, so he won’t be very impactful there and has limited defensive value. Still, his profile could work just fine in hitter-friendly Coors Field, assuming he can make enough contact. Riggio has struggled to find consistency in his hit tool, especially against anything that isn’t a fastball. Because of the fringy hit tool and speed, he projects as a power-dependent MI with a mediocre batting average.

 

Johan De Los Santos-PIT

 

Expected Projection: .270/1.9 HR/28.1 SB/20.2 K%/10.8 BB%

 

Score: 28.9

 

Projecting De Los Santos is very similar to Hernandez: you’re taking a shot in the dark on a limited sample and hoping something hits. In two seasons as a pro, he’s hit .353 and then .270, with more walks than strikeouts, elite speed output, and no power. So, that’s how we’ll project. The contact skills look solid early on, including an 84.1% overall contact rate at Low-A. His in-zone miss rate is well above average right now, but pitching will get better, and he’s been aggressive early in his career. He has high swing rates and chases a lot. With that in mind, we have to conservatively project more strikeouts as pitching improves, especially if he continues free-swinging. For now, it’s impossible to project more power based on current data and physical characteristics. That leaves De Los Santos with a batting-average-and-speed-dependent score.

 

Jadher Areinamo-TBR

 

Expected Projection: .248/8.7 HR/3.4 SB/21.1 K%/6.0 BB%

 

Score: 4.5

 

The lowest score in the group belongs to Areinamo, although I wouldn’t say he’s the least projectable. The 22-year-old spent almost all of 2026 at Double-A Montgomery, slashing .240/.282/.407 with 13 homers and nine steals in 82 games. A bit of a free-swinger, Areinamo made good contact with respectable strikeout rates, though he didn’t walk much. He finds the barrel enough to get some in-game power, though it will have to come to the pull side, as his contact quality metrics are poor. If Areinamo could be a touch more patient at the plate, his contact skills and batted-ball profile wouldn’t preclude a much better batting average, leaving me to wonder whether he could fill a utility infielder role in the bigs.

 

Kyle DeBarge-MIN

 

Expected Projection: .252/11.4 HR/17.6 SB/26.9 K%/7.9 BB%

 

Score: 29.3

 

I’ve had to keep adjusting DeBarge throughout this process, as the 22-year-old had an impressive showing in the Arizona Fall League, batting .347 with four doubles, two triples, five homers, and nine steals in 21 games for Salt River. His limited sample trumps his regular season, in which he managed just a .221 average with 12 homers and 41 steals in 120 games. His hit tool is fringy, but DeBarge has shown at-least-plus speed and improved power over the last 18 months. He’s always excelled at getting the ball into the air to his pull side, but the EVs are trending up and helping him reach more pop. I will be closely monitoring him as 2027 gets underway to see if the power gains stick, which could propel him up the rankings with that always enticing power/speed blend.

 

 

Projection Based Prospect Rankings-2B

The variance between the EOS ranking and the model ranking was quite surprising, but I had a few takeaways. The model clearly values the confidence element of the formula as expected. With such a wide range of outcomes for players in general, let alone the young players at this position, there was bound to be some volatility in the rankings. That said, the studs at the top are still clustered together, except for Michael Arroyo and Max Anderson, two players with very divisive profiles in the prospect community.

I also found the ranking of Henry Godbout and Kyle DeBarge intriguing, as each has a very clear skill set with a narrower range of outcomes, and the model embraced that. Johan De Los Santos, who is still a young player but has shown consistency even in a smaller sample, was also rewarded and, honestly, would have scored even higher if he had any potential to reach more significant power. Looking ahead to my catcher projections, I’m very intrigued to see how the model values certain skills (BA and speed) at a position where you either have them or you don’t.

Martin Sekulski

Martin is a Dynasty writer for PitcherList and co-host of Destination Dynasty on the PL Network of pods. He is a lifelong member of Red Sox Nation and attributes his love of baseball to his father, Marty. In addition to PL, you can find his work on Twitter and Substack!