+

MLB Rumor Roundup: 5/9

Diving into recent talk, transactions, and trends around the league!

Welcome back to another week of Rumor Roundup, where we dive into all the recent talk, transactions, and trends from around the league, balancing both fantasy baseball implications and real-world baseball analysis through the lens of a front office.

 

Featured Story

 

Tarik Skubal is headed to the IL after he underwent surgery on his left elbow to remove a loose body. The timetable for his return remains uncertain, but the Tigers are encouraged he will be able to return to the mound this season.

Skubal, 29, has turned in a 2.70 ERA/2.14 FIP this season but has seen his K% drop nearly 5% compared to the year prior, plus his BAA (.220) — while still exceptional — is the highest it has been since 2022. His other-worldly four-seamer was getting knocked around, too. Last year, the offering boasted a .201 xBA, .293 xwOBA, and 29% whiff rate. This season? An alarming .298 xBA, .331 xwOBA, and mediocre 21% whiff rate. His velo was down a full tick as well.

It’s hard not to imagine this injury won’t effect Skubal in this year’s upcoming free agency, where entering 2026 it seemed obvious he was poised to ink the largest contract among starting pitchers in MLB history. He’s making $32 million this year alone via arbitration. I still believe he has a pretty good chance at breaking Yoshinobu Yamamoto’s $325 million deal, but there is so much baseball to be played between now and then. Let’s hope Skubal is able to quickly recover and get back to dominating on the mound… baseball is better when its stars are healthy.

 

Injury Updates

 

The following players have started rehab assignments this week:

 

The following players have been placed on the IL this week:

 

Finally, the following players have seen their IL status change this week:

 

Recent Transactions

 

The following players have been DFA’d this week:

 

Promotions/demotions:

 

Trade!

 

Breaking news… this trade was reported right as I was putting the finishing touches on this article! The Cleveland Guardians made a shocking move by acquiring two-time Gold Glove catcher Patrick Bailey in exchange for the No. 29 pick in this year’s draft and RHP Matt Wilkinson.

Bailey, 26, is the definition of a premium defender. He’s an annual Platinum Glove candidate that excels in run prevention. He currently owns 6 OAA and 3 DRS to start the year. His 6 FRV — highlighted by his elite framing ability behind the dish — put him in the 100th percentile among qualified catchers.

So why would a team be willing to move on from him? Simply put, Bailey has been horrid offensively. His career OPS (.611) is usually enough to send a guy packing in his first season, let alone fourth year at the major league level. He’s gotten significantly worse in 2026, slashing just .146/.213/.183 with a 16 wRC+ — usually when someone says “video game numbers” they mean that in a good way… but this certainly fits that jaw-dropping description.

I do believe there should be some optimism regarding Bailey’s bat. He has definitely underperformed his expected numbers, best highlighted by his .190 wOBA/.283 xwOBA discrepancy, all while his HH% and EV are still very solid.

As for the return, Wilkinson (or “Tugboat” as some call him) is a massive 6’1” / 250 lb beast that has twirled 28.1 innings this season, featuring a 25% KK-BB rate and 2.60 FIP. The 29th overall selection in this year’s draft, a comp pick, is the real headliner. This will allow the Giants to snag a first round talent in what is shaping up to be a really impressive class.

All in all? A shocking, yet intriguing move from both sides. I’m excited to see how this plays out throughout the year, and if Bailey can return to form offensively.

 

Feature image by Michael Packard (@CollectingPack on Twitter) | Photosby Keith Gillett/Icon Sportswire

Subscribe to the Pitcher List Newsletter

Your daily update on everything Pitcher List

Griffey Geiss

Geiss, known by many as “G.G.”, is a staff writer and data analyst at PitcherList. He has extensive experience in professional baseball as a Player Development & Data consultant, plus has spent several years independently creating content and covering the Boston Red Sox on a number of platforms. After arm injuries derailed his pitching career, Geiss founded @ggeiss_MLB Media and has since gained over 9k followers on Twitter.

Account / Login