Second Base Dynasty Prospect Comps

Typically a thin and top-heavy fantasy position, second base has an argument for a strong prospect grouping. The group listed below, along with James Triantos, Demetrio Crisantes, and Termarr Johnson is as strong as second base prospects have been. While most of these prospects aren’t true second basemen, they’ve all gravitated to second base or spent most of their time there. Below are a few of the best, and what they can potentially become.

 

Second Base Dynasty Prospect Comps

 

Kristian Campbell, BOS

 

Dynasty Floor Comp: Randy Arozarena

Kristian Campbell burst onto the scene in 2024 after being drafted 132nd overall in the 2023 MLB Draft. The hit tool is arguably the best tool here with speed not far behind. Arozarena started his career off hot, with a tremendous post-season performance. A career .254 hitter, Arozarena has dropped off a bit with the hit tool recently. Arozarena is a consistent 20-20 player, which is close to the Campbell potential.

Dynasty Ceiling Comp: Mookie Betts

Comparing prospects to a top-5 player in baseball is a tough ask, but the eyes and numbers look promising. While Mookie has been elite for the last 10 years, Campbell has the chance to follow. The power isn’t nearly as high as Mookie, but Campbell could max out at 25 per season. Campbell even plays second base, shortstop, and outfield like Betts. This is a lofty comparison and high expectations, but it’s a fun one.

True Projection:

Somewhere in the middle of these two is the most likely outcome. Unsure about the power, Campbell swings violently but still manages a plus hit tool. A .280+ average, .350+ OBP, 15-20 home runs, and 25+ stolen bases seems realistic. Campbell’s peak potential is swapped with Betts. Power is the tool for Betts, speed is the tool for Campbell. The low-end for Campbell is a top player, but there should be 20-20 potential here with ease.

 

Travis Bazzana, CLE

 

Dynasty Floor Comp: Gleyber Torres

The first overall pick of the 2024 MLB Draft has a great profile. With plus tools across the board, Bazzana has a great approach with good power and speed. Power might take a tick up for Bazzana, giving him 2023 Gleyber Torres profile. 25+ home runs, a .350 OBP, and 15 stolen bases is a top-tier second baseman. After a bit of a struggle in his pro debut, Bazzana may have a bit of a lower upside.

Dynasty Ceiling Comp: Jose Altuve

Altuve has been one of, if not the best second basemen in baseball since 2012. Altuve had a few 30+ home run seasons, with multiple 20+ home runs and 30+ stolen bases years. In the best-case scenario, Bazzana has 25+ home runs and stolen bases. Every tool points to Bazzana being the next best second baseman in the league. While Altuve has more speed, Bazzana has a chance at more consistent power.

True Projection:

While Bazzana could excel in every tool, one of the power or speed seems likely to dip. He’s currently a 20 home run/25 stolen bases profile, and Bazzana draws plenty of walks to keep the stolen base numbers up. Cleveland may limit his running and focus more on him as a pure hitter. Overall, Bazzana looks like a .360 OBP, 25 home runs, and 15 stolen bases player to start his career.

 

Christian Moore, LAA

 

Dynasty Floor Comp: Christopher Morel

Power is real for both of these players. With an aggressive approach, the walk rate isn’t going to be too high. Morel is a bit of an extreme for Moore, as he’s coming off a sub-.200 average season. 2023 Morel, where he hit .247 with 26 home runs is a safe floor for Moore. The hit tool for Moore is likely more advanced than a .247 average. Plus power and a mid-.200 average is something to look for as Moore starts his career

Dynasty Ceiling Comp: Teoscar Hernández

2021 and 2024 Teoscar Hernández is the high side of Moore. Teoscar hit .296 and .272 with 32 and 33 home runs in those seasons and the high side for Moore is closer to 2024. A near .275 average with 30+ home runs is something to sign up for with any prospect. Moore will jump to the top of second base options with that profile, but it may take a few seasons to get there.

True Projection:

Moore dominated in his pro debut, spending most of his time at Double-A. The Angels have notoriously moved their draft picks quickly with Zach Neto and Nolan Schanuel. Moore hit five home runs in 23 Double-A games, and power is the calling card. Morel and Hernández both have plus power, and Moore can reach 30+ home runs per season. The high strikeout rate and low walk rate are something to monitor. A .250 average, .320 OBP, with 26-29 home runs seems like a best-case profile.

 

Michael Arroyo, SEA

 

Dynasty Floor Comp: Jeremy Peña

One of the breakout prospects in 2024 was Michael Arroyo who is a smaller prospect at 5’9″. Arroyo has tools across the board. Peña had a phenomenal rookie season and a solid sophomore season. His third season is the projection similar to Arroyo. With a lower OBP at .308, Peña hit 15 home runs and stole 20 bases in 2024. Arroyo should be able to reach 15 home runs and 20 stolen bases with a .325 OBP as his low end. Still 20 years old for the 2025 season, Arroyo could see his floor rise after a good season.

Dynasty Ceiling Comp: CJ Abrams

Similar to Pena, Abrams has a low OBP but excels in the home run/stolen base profile. Abrams has put up back-to-back seasons of 18 home runs/47 stolen bases, and 20 home runs/31 stolen bases. Arroyo hit 23 home runs and stole 18 bases in 120 2024 games. The power may not be matched again for Arroyo, but 25-30 steals are in play for Arroyo. The counting stats may be a bit high for the smaller Arroyo, but best case he’s in the ballpark.

True Projection:

This is another example of projection being in the middle of the two comparisons. Arroyo had a huge 2024 and there is still some speculation in the power. The power is around 15 home runs total per season at the moment and stolen bases are around 25+. Given that Arroyo is smaller, the power will always be questioned, but the hit tool may be more advanced than both comparisons above.

 

Luke Keaschall, MIN

 

Dynasty Floor Comp: Ian Happ

Over eight MLB seasons, Ian Happ has averaged 25 home runs per season over 162 games. Keaschall was able to hit 15 home runs in 102 games in 2024. The speed is more prominent for Keaschall, but both players provide a bit of everything. A safe floor for Keaschall is Happ, who also started as a second baseman. Neither had a true defensive home, but both can play multiple positions. Keaschall should have a higher average and stolen base total, but the power total isn’t quite at Happ yet.

Dynasty Ceiling Comp: Michael Harris II

Harris is more dynamic than Happ and Keaschall, but the ceiling is higher. The stolen base total was lower for Harris but was at 20 both seasons prior. Keaschall could reach the .290+ average and 20 stolen base total Harris put up his first two seasons. Best case, Keaschall reaches nearly 20 home runs like Harris did as well.

True Projection:

Keaschall is probably the biggest prospect riser from the 2023 MLB Draft. Dominating his 133-game pro debut over two seasons, Keaschall does it all. With 105 walks in 133 games, Keaschall draws the patient approach similar to Ian Happ. As a dual 20 home run/20 stolen base threat, Keaschall has seen the power tick up to reach that total. He’ll miss the start of 2025 after needing Tommy John surgery, but a .285 average with 20 home runs and 20 stolen bases is realistic.

 

Photo by Icon Sportswire | Featured Image by Justin Redler (@reldernitsuj on Bsky/Twitter)