+

Closing Time 9/23: Ranking the Top 40 Closers Every Tuesday

Ranking baseball's closer situations for the 2025 season.

Will Vest has allowed six runs (five earned) over his past two outings, both resulting in losses, so I wouldn’t expect him to see the team’s next save chance, especially with Kyle Finnegan back in the bullpen. The team also got Paul Sewald back recently but he hasn’t look great either so don’t expect him to be in the mix for saves here. All hands should be on deck for the Tigers as they have two huge series coming up. The first starts today with the Guardians, who they are playing for the AL Central, and then the Red Sox, who they could be playing for the final wild card spot.

 

Notes

 

  • Carlos Estévez may wind up leading the league in saves yet this is his first time in my top 10. He’s been the leagues luckiest reliever this season and there just hasn’t been that negative regression that was due to come (I guess it will happen next year?). Amongst closers this season, Estevez ranks dead last in xFIP (4.97), SIERA (4.50), K rate (19.6%), SwStr rate (8.2%), and CSW rate (24.2%). His ERA indicators (xFIP and SIERA) as well as his CSW% rank in the bottom 10 amongst ALL qualified relievers. But he gets six games against the Angels and Athletics so it’s a pretty tame final week of the season for Estevez.

 

  • Dennis Santana has rattled off seven straight scoreless outings this month, allowing just one hit and one walk over that span as he looks dialed in right now. With the Reds and Braves left on the schedule, Santana should have a decent chance at one more save or two to end the year.

 

  • Abner Uribe may not get every save chance with Trevor Megill out as the team has been using Uribe and Jared Koenig based on match ups in the ninth. The Brewers have five games left against potential playoff teams and with Uribe not guaranteed the ninth, there’s no guarantee he gets another save opportunity.

 

  • After hyping up Jose A. Ferrer, he’s gone out and allowed five earned runs over his past three outings, although the team did ask him to work two innings (first inning went well) his last time out which I’m not sure is in his best interests. Recent struggles aside, I still like Ferrer and the Nationals have five games remaining against the Braves and White Sox, so there’s still a chance he can add one or two more saves to close out the year.

 

  • Hogan Harris looks like the favorite to close out games for the Athletics with Sean Newcomb out but they still don’t have a set closer so it’s probably best to just stay away from this situation.

 

Rank Pitcher TeamChange
1Aroldis ChapmanT1BOS-
2Edwin DíazLAD-
3Jhoan DuranPHI-
4Andrés MuñozSEA-
5David BednarNYY-
6Cade SmithNYY+2
7Bryan AbreuHOU-1
8Pete FairbanksMIA+1
9Carlos EstévezKC+5
10Robert Suarez
T2
ATL-3
11Raisel IglesiasATL-1
12Shawn ArmstrongCLE+1
13Dennis SantanaPIT+6
14Emilio PagánCIN+1
15Jeff HoffmanTOR+2
16Ryan WalkerSF+2
17Abner UribeMIL-6
18Jose A. FerrerSEA-6
19Kenley JansenDET+2
20Tanner Scott
T3
LAD-4
21Brad KellerPHI+1
22Kyle FinneganDET+UR
23Andrew KittredgeBAL-
24JoJo RomeroSTL-
25Jordan LeasureCWS-
26Keegan AkinBAL+3
27Victor VodnikCOL+3
28Ronny HenriquezMIA-1
29Calvin FaucherMIA+4
30Hogan Harris+UR
31Cole SandsMIN-3
32Grant TaylorCWS+UR
33Will VestDET-13
34Andrew SaalfrankARI-2
35Riley O’BrienSTL+3
36Alex Vesia
T4
LAD+UR
37Mason MillerSD-6
38Devin WilliamsNYM-4
39Tony SantillanCIN-2
40Seranthony DomínguezCWS-4

 

Watch List

 

Subscribe to the Pitcher List Newsletter

Your daily update on everything Pitcher List

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

Account / Login