Pitcher List’s Staff Consensus Top 300 Rankings – 2019

It’s time for some rankings! 19 of our writers sent in their personal top 300 rankings, and we’ve combined them all to give to you the consensus rankings for our site. Use these rankings to help create your own draft rankings, to help gauge trade value, and to see how players are valued by a large group of industry writers.

These rankings were made with head-to-head, standard 5×5 scoring, 12-team leagues in mind. These were also done prior to some of the most recent news, such as Bryce Harper signing with the Phillies.

 

Overall Top 300

 

Ranking	Player	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Mike Trout	OF	1.0	1	1	100%
2	Mookie Betts	OF	2.0	2	2	100%
3	Jose Ramirez	2B, 3B	3.1	3	5	100%
4	J.D. Martinez	OF	5.1	4	8	100%
5	Nolan Arenado	3B	5.4	3	11	100%
6	Trea Turner	SS	8.6	4	16	100%
7	Max Scherzer	SP	8.7	6	18	100%
8	Manny Machado	3B, SS	9.8	6	27	100%
9	Christian Yelich	OF	10.6	4	18	100%
10	Francisco Lindor	SS	10.8	4	21	100%
11	Ronald Acuna	OF	12.1	5	21	100%
12	Chris Sale	SP	12.3	4	20	100%
13	Aaron Judge	OF	13.7	6	20	100%
14	Jose Altuve	2B	13.9	6	34	100%
15	Alex Bregman	3B, SS	14.1	8	22	100%
16	Bryce Harper	OF	14.3	8	20	100%
17	Jacob deGrom	SP	14.5	9	20	100%
18	Paul Goldschmidt	1B	17.6	12	22	100%
19	Freddie Freeman	1B, 3B	17.8	14	22	100%
20	Trevor Story	SS	19.8	9	29	100%
21	Giancarlo Stanton	OF	21.3	17	29	100%
22	Charlie Blackmon	OF	24.4	16	34	100%
23	Justin Verlander	SP	24.6	22	31	100%
24	Corey Kluber	SP	26.2	18	37	100%
25	Javier Baez	2B, 3B, SS	26.4	17	43	100%
26	Gerrit Cole	SP	26.8	20	33	100%
27	Andrew Benintendi	OF	27.4	18	49	100%
28	Kris Bryant	3B, OF	27.8	21	33	100%
29	Aaron Nola	SP	28.9	19	39	100%
30	Anthony Rizzo	1B, 2B	29.7	23	36	100%
31	Blake Snell	SP	30.4	24	36	100%
32	Trevor Bauer	SP	32.4	18	45	100%
33	Juan Soto	OF	34.1	21	56	100%
34	Starling Marte	OF	37.0	30	57	100%
35	Anthony Rendon	3B	37.7	27	44	100%
36	Whit Merrifield	1B, 2B, OF	37.9	27	52	100%
37	Luis Severino	SP	38.0	25	57	100%
38	Khris Davis	OF	39.1	26	55	100%
39	Noah Syndergaard	SP	40.7	28	61	100%
40	Rhys Hoskins	1B, OF	40.7	23	54	100%
41	Carlos Carrasco	SP	42.5	36	49	100%
42	Carlos Correa	SS	42.6	29	82	100%
43	Cody Bellinger	1B, OF	43.9	35	56	100%
44	Xander Bogaerts	SS	44.3	25	54	100%
45	Walker Buehler	SP, RP	46.7	35	56	100%
46	Eugenio Suarez	3B	48.9	37	78	100%
47	George Springer	OF	50.1	39	75	100%
48	Lorenzo Cain	OF	51.6	41	65	100%
49	Clayton Kershaw	SP	51.6	29	124	100%
50	Joey Votto	1B	52.9	45	75	100%
51	Patrick Corbin	SP	56.1	37	74	100%
52	Ozzie Albies	2B	58.2	40	81	100%
53	Matt Carpenter	1B, 2B, 3B	58.8	34	121	100%
54	James Paxton	SP	58.9	46	80	100%
55	Jose Abreu	1B	60.4	44	84	100%
56	Vladimir Guerrero Jr.	3B	60.9	42	81	100%
57	Stephen Strasburg	SP	61.4	47	92	100%
58	Jean Segura	SS	62.4	51	87	100%
59	Justin Upton	OF	62.7	46	90	100%
60	Mike Clevinger	SP, RP	63.2	38	84	100%
61	Nelson Cruz	OF	64.0	50	95	100%
62	Edwin Diaz	RP	64.8	45	125	100%
63	J.T. Realmuto	C, 1B	65.4	33	102	100%
64	Tommy Pham	OF	65.6	43	103	100%
65	Zack Greinke	SP	66.6	50	124	100%
66	Corey Seager	SS	67.4	51	105	100%
67	Jameson Taillon	SP	67.5	47	108	100%
68	Daniel Murphy	1B, 2B	72.4	59	89	100%
69	Gary Sanchez	C	73.1	52	111	100%
70	Adalberto Mondesi	2B, SS	73.4	36	103	100%
71	Mitch Haniger	OF	74.8	53	148	100%
72	Marcell Ozuna	OF	76.2	35	168	100%
73	Blake Treinen	RP	76.9	57	108	100%
74	Jesus Aguilar	1B	78.6	57	106	100%
75	Nicholas Castellanos	3B, OF	79.1	57	116	100%
76	Eddie Rosario	OF	79.4	55	137	100%
77	Gleyber Torres	2B, SS	79.4	48	125	100%
78	Jack Flaherty	SP	79.5	57	109	100%
79	Craig Kimbrel	RP	80.8	50	124	100%
80	Kenley Jansen	RP	85.5	51	120	100%
81	Scooter Gennett	2B, 3B, OF	86.0	66	105	100%
82	Justin Turner	3B	86.2	60	115	100%
83	Michael Conforto	OF	86.4	53	107	100%
84	Wil Myers	1B, OF	86.4	49	140	100%
85	German Marquez	SP	86.9	54	110	100%
86	Matt Chapman	3B	87.4	61	127	100%
87	Zack Wheeler	SP	87.9	42	138	100%
88	Aroldis Chapman	RP	88.6	74	111	100%
89	Yasiel Puig	OF	88.7	60	117	100%
90	A.J. Pollock	OF	89.6	58	165	100%
91	Josh Donaldson	3B	89.8	58	139	100%
92	David Price	SP, RP	90.3	59	114	100%
93	Jose Berrios	SP	90.3	68	107	100%
94	Aaron Hicks	OF	90.8	55	122	100%
95	Matt Olson	1B, OF	91.2	59	112	100%
96	Travis Shaw	3B	92.0	55	118	100%
97	Joey Gallo	1B, 3B, OF	98.6	70	128	100%
98	Michael Brantley	OF	100.2	77	166	100%
99	Roberto Osuna	RP	100.9	83	156	100%
100	Mike Foltynewicz	SP	102.1	81	147	100%
101	Max Muncy	1B, 2B, 3B, OF	102.6	88	136	100%
102	Brad Hand	RP	103.5	84	135	100%
103	Madison Bumgarner	SP	104.1	67	182	100%
104	Felipe Vazquez	RP	104.3	80	119	100%
105	Miguel Andujar	3B	104.3	76	141	100%
106	David Dahl	OF	105.6	72	123	100%
107	Andrew McCutchen	OF	106.4	64	141	100%
108	Robinson Cano	2B	106.6	69	127	100%
109	Edwin Encarnacion	1B	107.6	84	140	100%
110	Miles Mikolas	SP	108.3	44	153	100%
111	Jonathan Villar	2B, OF	110.4	80	171	100%
112	David Peralta	OF	112.4	96	126	100%
113	Masahiro Tanaka	SP	112.8	79	146	100%
114	Eloy Jimenez	OF	114.1	82	146	100%
115	Dee Gordon	2B, OF	116.4	85	173	100%
116	Luis Castillo	SP	117.5	76	199	100%
117	Sean Doolittle	RP	118.7	89	144	100%
118	Jose Peraza	2B, SS	119.3	68	149	100%
119	Rougned Odor	2B	120.8	95	172	100%
120	Ender Inciarte	OF	121.6	99	180	100%
121	Victor Robles	OF	121.8	91	161	100%
122	Brian Dozier	2B	122.8	101	183	100%
123	Yu Darvish	SP	123.2	69	192	100%
124	Mallex Smith	OF	124.2	79	178	100%
125	Raisel Iglesias	RP	125.3	100	162	100%
126	Charlie Morton	SP	126.9	94	164	100%
127	Rafael Devers	3B	128.9	114	161	100%
128	Robbie Ray	SP	130.9	107	193	100%
129	Shohei Ohtani	DH	135.8	86	171	100%
130	Mike Moustakas	3B	136.2	114	172	100%
131	Josh Hader	RP	138.3	94	282	100%
132	Kyle Hendricks	SP	138.7	123	180	100%
133	Stephen Piscotty	OF	141.0	107	166	100%
134	Nomar Mazara	OF	141.6	88	203	100%
135	Jurickson Profar	1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF	145.9	99	195	100%
136	Kirby Yates	RP	146.4	97	175	100%
137	Willson Contreras	C	146.7	108	204	100%
138	Carlos Martinez	SP	147.4	78	257	100%
139	Yasmani Grandal	C	147.4	99	180	100%
140	Wilson Ramos	C	147.9	127	218	100%
141	Nick Pivetta	SP	148.1	115	209	100%
142	Jose Leclerc	RP	150.4	119	189	100%
143	Brandon Nimmo	OF	151.3	104	211	100%
144	Tim Anderson	SS	153.6	112	271	100%
145	Wade Davis	RP	153.6	133	203	100%
146	J.A. Happ	SP	153.6	105	186	100%
147	Salvador Perez	C	154.2	120	292	100%
148	Yoan Moncada	2B	154.4	130	223	100%
149	Eduardo Rodriguez	SP	154.6	107	197	100%
150	Miguel Cabrera	1B	155.0	113	249	100%
151	Ian Desmond	1B, OF	155.1	125	209	100%
152	Ken Giles	RP	155.4	118	298	100%
153	Elvis Andrus	SS	156.4	122	291	100%
154	Chris Archer	SP	157.2	110	198	100%
155	Amed Rosario	SS	157.7	131	233	100%
156	Cesar Hernandez	2B	158.2	115	206	100%
157	Buster Posey	C, 1B	160.6	143	204	100%
158	Corey Knebel	RP	162.4	128	181	94%
159	Jonathan Schoop	2B	163.2	104	243	100%
160	Yadier Molina	C	165.1	133	190	100%
161	Kyle Freeland	SP, RP	166.6	99	245	100%
162	Harrison Bader	OF	168.5	139	222	100%
163	Eric Hosmer	1B	170.1	126	246	100%
164	Ryan Braun	1B, OF	170.6	122	248	100%
165	Cole Hamels	SP	170.9	144	282	100%
166	Rich Hill	SP	171.4	111	261	100%
167	Shane Bieber	SP	172.6	106	218	100%
168	Nathan Eovaldi	SP	173.2	119	254	100%
169	Andrew Heaney	SP	177.2	116	242	100%
170	Carlos Santana	1B, OF	177.4	130	263	100%
171	Adam Eaton	OF	178.7	121	255	100%
172	Austin Meadows	OF	182.1	123	260	100%
173	Paul DeJong	2B, SS	184.3	131	214	100%
174	Luke Voit	1B	184.5	116	248	100%
175	Ross Stripling	SP, RP	186.3	120	265	100%
176	Dallas Keuchel	SP	186.5	129	260	100%
177	Kyle Schwarber	OF	187.3	140	263	100%
178	Tyler Glasnow	SP, RP	188.7	121	266	100%
179	Billy Hamilton	OF	190.8	143	267	100%
180	Kenta Maeda	SP	191.8	123	279	100%
181	Cody Allen	RP	192.7	153	295	100%
182	Hunter Renfroe	OF	193.4	160	227	100%
183	Jose Martinez	1B, OF	193.6	131	261	100%
184	Andrelton Simmons	SS	194.0	171	265	100%
185	Tyler Skaggs	SP	194.8	139	213	94%
186	Justin Smoak	1B	196.8	162	264	100%
187	Jesse Winker	OF	197.1	128	224	94%
188	Gregory Polanco	OF	198.9	121	261	94%
189	David Robertson	RP	199.8	94	236	94%
190	Corey Dickerson	OF	201.1	156	249	100%
191	Jon Lester	SP	202.9	157	253	94%
192	Alex Wood	SP	203.4	135	291	100%
193	Marcus Semien	SS	205.6	167	279	100%
194	Hyun-Jin Ryu	SP	207.6	161	271	100%
195	Jose Quintana	SP	208.7	159	296	100%
196	Shin-Soo Choo	OF	209.5	169	277	100%
197	Miguel Sano	1B, 3B	209.9	161	291	94%
198	Yusei Kikuchi	P	209.9	134	297	94%
199	Jorge Polanco	SS	210.1	161	261	100%
200	Rick Porcello	SP	210.1	163	295	100%
201	Yulieski Gurriel	1B, 3B	210.3	147	267	100%
202	Ramon Laureano	OF	211.3	140	259	94%
203	Byron Buxton	OF	212.2	142	298	94%
204	Franmil Reyes	OF	213.9	149	225	94%
205	Kevin Gausman	SP	213.9	161	289	100%
206	Andrew Miller	RP	216.4	132	281	94%
207	DJ LeMahieu	2B	216.9	177	262	94%
208	Eduardo Escobar	2B, 3B, SS	217.7	135	247	89%
209	Ketel Marte	2B, SS	218.8	159	258	100%
210	Alex Reyes	SP	222.9	148	250	89%
211	Nick Senzel	3B	226.9	179	285	100%
212	Jed Lowrie	2B, 3B	229.3	160	261	100%
213	Josh Bell	1B	229.3	165	295	94%
214	Jake Bauers	1B, OF	230.3	150	298	100%
215	Kyle Seager	3B	231.8	178	276	94%
216	Josh James	SP	231.9	124	234	78%
217	Jake Arrieta	SP	232.7	180	295	94%
218	Odubel Herrera	OF	233.2	161	288	89%
219	Tyler White	1B	233.8	130	288	94%
220	Chris Taylor	2B, SS, OF	234.2	193	280	94%
221	Garrett Hampson	2B, SS	234.7	153	294	94%
222	Jonathan Gray	SP	235.6	161	295	89%
223	Michael Fulmer	SP	236.8	166	286	89%
224	Ian Happ	2B, 3B, OF	238.3	194	281	94%
225	Danny Jansen	C	239.9	181	293	94%
226	Joey Lucchesi	SP	242.5	186	288	94%
227	Domingo Santana	OF	245.0	159	284	89%
228	Zack Godley	SP	245.7	175	300	89%
229	Willy Adames	2B, SS	247.1	184	292	89%
230	C.J. Cron	1B	247.4	199	264	94%
231	Arodys Vizcaino	RP	247.7	193	254	89%
232	Will Smith	SP, RP	247.7	174	274	83%
233	Joe Musgrove	SP, RP	248.0	136	299	78%
234	Jake Lamb	3B	249.3	181	271	89%
235	Manuel Margot	OF	249.3	202	286	94%
236	Jackie Bradley	OF	249.8	143	288	89%
237	Jimmy Nelson	SP	250.2	138	295	78%
238	Max Kepler	OF	251.2	151	298	94%
239	Archie Bradley	RP	251.7	197	284	83%
240	Nick Markakis	OF	259.7	205	286	83%
241	Joey Wendle	2B, OF	260.1	192	271	83%
242	Alex Colome	RP	262.2	184	300	83%
243	Collin McHugh	SP, RP	264.5	172	297	78%
244	Steven Matz	SP	264.9	197	300	94%
245	Jordan Hicks	SP, RP	265.4	166	299	78%
246	Francisco Mejia	C	266.8	196	297	89%
247	Peter Alonso	1B	270.8	154	298	89%
248	Jose Alvarado	RP	271.9	155	298	72%
249	Trey Mancini	1B, OF	274.5	183	296	72%
250	Randal Grichuk	OF	274.6	204	278	78%
251	Seranthony Dominguez	SP, RP	276.1	182	286	78%
252	A.J. Minter	RP	276.1	180	292	72%
253	Lourdes Gurriel Jr.	2B, SS, OF	276.2	201	269	78%
254	Welington Castillo	C	278.0	213	299	89%
255	Jesus Luzardo	SP	278.4	163	299	78%
256	Ryan Zimmerman	1B	279.9	199	297	83%
257	Dellin Betances	RP	282.4	164	290	72%
258	Mychal Givens	RP	283.6	207	284	78%
259	Maikel Franco	3B	289.3	206	288	78%
260	Matt Kemp	OF	289.9	181	294	72%
261	Brandon Morrow	RP	290.5	179	296	67%
262	Kelvin Herrera	RP	290.6	194	299	67%
263	Kyle Tucker	OF	290.6	230	298	83%
264	Yonder Alonso	1B	290.7	215	294	72%
265	Luke Weaver	SP	291.9	210	300	72%
266	Sean Newcomb	SP	293.0	188	295	67%
267	Evan Longoria	3B	293.2	195	287	67%
268	Asdrubal Cabrera	2B, 3B, SS	293.7	185	283	67%
269	Marwin Gonzalez	1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF	294.8	222	297	78%
270	Starlin Castro	2B	296.4	208	291	78%
271	Brandon Belt	1B, OF	297.2	247	295	78%
272	Sonny Gray	SP	297.5	216	299	78%
273	Adam Jones	OF	297.8	162	300	61%
274	Mike Soroka	SP	299.8	146	285	61%
275	Brian Anderson	3B, OF	303.9	240	296	72%
276	Kyle Gibson	SP	304.1	201	292	72%
277	Kendrys Morales	1B	309.1	244	300	72%
278	Avisail Garcia	OF	309.9	198	297	67%
279	Jay Bruce	1B, OF	310.1	226	292	67%
280	Steven Souza	OF	310.1	202	293	67%
281	Pedro Strop	RP	311.9	204	295	61%
282	Didi Gregorius	SS	312.9	207	300	61%
283	Teoscar Hernandez	OF	312.9	209	299	67%
284	Trevor May	SP, RP	313.1	246	297	67%
285	Mike Zunino	C	314.2	232	293	61%
286	Francisco Cervelli	C	316.7	228	298	61%
287	Jeremy Jeffress	RP	317.0	185	291	56%
288	Reynaldo Lopez	SP	318.3	208	288	56%
289	Carlos Rodon	SP	319.7	243	299	61%
290	Dylan Bundy	SP	321.4	241	299	67%
291	Yan Gomes	C	321.8	205	299	50%
292	Marcus Stroman	SP	327.1	237	296	56%
293	Joc Pederson	OF	327.4	234	295	56%
294	Matt Boyd	SP	328.3	213	276	44%
295	Willians Astudillo	C, 3B	329.6	223	300	56%
296	Brett Gardner	OF	332.1	188	275	44%
297	Chase Anderson	SP	333.6	239	297	50%
298	Adam Ottavino	RP	334.4	228	278	44%
299	Dereck Rodriguez	SP, RP	334.4	201	296	50%
300	Derek Holland	SP	334.8	165	297	39%

 

Catcher Rankings

 

Ranking	Player	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	J.T. Realmuto	C, 1B	65.4	33	102	100%
2	Gary Sanchez	C	73.1	52	111	100%
3	Willson Contreras	C	146.7	108	204	100%
4	Yasmani Grandal	C	147.4	99	180	100%
5	Wilson Ramos	C	147.9	127	218	100%
6	Salvador Perez	C	154.2	120	292	100%
7	Buster Posey	C, 1B	160.6	143	204	100%
8	Yadier Molina	C	165.1	133	190	100%
9	Danny Jansen	C	239.9	181	293	94%
10	Francisco Mejia	C	266.8	196	297	89%
11	Welington Castillo	C	278.0	213	299	89%
12	Mike Zunino	C	314.2	232	293	61%
13	Francisco Cervelli	C	316.7	228	298	61%
14	Yan Gomes	C	321.8	205	299	50%
15	Willians Astudillo	C, 3B	329.6	223	300	56%

 

1B Rankings

 

Ranking	Player	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Paul Goldschmidt	1B	17.6	12	22	100%
2	Freddie Freeman	1B, 3B	17.8	14	22	100%
3	Anthony Rizzo	1B, 2B	29.7	23	36	100%
4	Whit Merrifield	1B, 2B, OF	37.9	27	52	100%
5	Rhys Hoskins	1B, OF	40.7	23	54	100%
6	Cody Bellinger	1B, OF	43.9	35	56	100%
7	Joey Votto	1B	52.9	45	75	100%
8	Matt Carpenter	1B, 2B, 3B	58.8	34	121	100%
9	Jose Abreu	1B	60.4	44	84	100%
10	J.T. Realmuto	C, 1B	65.4	33	102	100%
11	Daniel Murphy	1B, 2B	72.4	59	89	100%
12	Jesus Aguilar	1B	78.6	57	106	100%
13	Wil Myers	1B, OF	86.4	49	140	100%
14	Matt Olson	1B, OF	91.2	59	112	100%
15	Joey Gallo	1B, 3B, OF	98.6	70	128	100%
16	Max Muncy	1B, 2B, 3B, OF	102.6	88	136	100%
17	Edwin Encarnacion	1B	107.6	84	140	100%
18	Jurickson Profar	1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF	145.9	99	195	100%
19	Miguel Cabrera	1B	155.0	113	249	100%
20	Ian Desmond	1B, OF	155.1	125	209	100%
21	Buster Posey	C, 1B	160.6	143	204	100%
22	Eric Hosmer	1B	170.1	126	246	100%
23	Ryan Braun	1B, OF	170.6	122	248	100%
24	Carlos Santana	1B, OF	177.4	130	263	100%
25	Luke Voit	1B	184.5	116	248	100%
26	Jose Martinez	1B, OF	193.6	131	261	100%
27	Justin Smoak	1B	196.8	162	264	100%
28	Miguel Sano	1B, 3B	209.9	161	291	94%
29	Yulieski Gurriel	1B, 3B	210.3	147	267	100%
30	Josh Bell	1B	229.3	165	295	94%
31	Jake Bauers	1B, OF	230.3	150	298	100%
32	Tyler White	1B	233.8	130	288	94%
33	C.J. Cron	1B	247.4	199	264	94%
34	Peter Alonso	1B	270.8	154	298	89%
35	Trey Mancini	1B, OF	274.5	183	296	72%
36	Ryan Zimmerman	1B	279.9	199	297	83%
37	Yonder Alonso	1B	290.7	215	294	72%
38	Marwin Gonzalez	1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF	294.8	222	297	78%
39	Brandon Belt	1B, OF	297.2	247	295	78%
40	Kendrys Morales	1B	309.1	244	300	72%
41	Jay Bruce	1B, OF	310.1	226	292	67%

 

2B Rankings

 

Ranking	Player	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Jose Ramirez	2B, 3B	3.1	3	5	100%
2	Jose Altuve	2B	13.9	6	34	100%
3	Javier Baez	2B, 3B, SS	26.4	17	43	100%
4	Whit Merrifield	1B, 2B, OF	37.9	27	52	100%
5	Ozzie Albies	2B	58.2	40	81	100%
6	Matt Carpenter	1B, 2B, 3B	58.8	34	121	100%
7	Daniel Murphy	1B, 2B	72.4	59	89	100%
8	Adalberto Mondesi	2B, SS	73.4	36	103	100%
9	Gleyber Torres	2B, SS	79.4	48	125	100%
10	Scooter Gennett	2B, 3B, OF	86.0	66	105	100%
11	Max Muncy	1B, 2B, 3B, OF	102.6	88	136	100%
12	Robinson Cano	2B	106.6	69	127	100%
13	Jonathan Villar	2B, OF	110.4	80	171	100%
14	Dee Gordon	2B, OF	116.4	85	173	100%
15	Jose Peraza	2B, SS	119.3	68	149	100%
16	Rougned Odor	2B	120.8	95	172	100%
17	Brian Dozier	2B	122.8	101	183	100%
18	Jurickson Profar	1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF	145.9	99	195	100%
19	Yoan Moncada	2B	154.4	130	223	100%
20	Cesar Hernandez	2B	158.2	115	206	100%
21	Jonathan Schoop	2B	163.2	104	243	100%
22	Paul DeJong	2B, SS	184.3	131	214	100%
23	DJ LeMahieu	2B	216.9	177	262	94%
24	Eduardo Escobar	2B, 3B, SS	217.7	135	247	89%
25	Ketel Marte	2B, SS	218.8	159	258	100%
26	Jed Lowrie	2B, 3B	229.3	160	261	100%
27	Chris Taylor	2B, SS, OF	234.2	193	280	94%
28	Garrett Hampson	2B, SS	234.7	153	294	94%
29	Ian Happ	2B, 3B, OF	238.3	194	281	94%
30	Willy Adames	2B, SS	247.1	184	292	89%
31	Joey Wendle	2B, OF	260.1	192	271	83%
32	Lourdes Gurriel Jr.	2B, SS, OF	276.2	201	269	78%
33	Asdrubal Cabrera	2B, 3B, SS	293.7	185	283	67%
34	Marwin Gonzalez	1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF	294.8	222	297	78%
35	Starlin Castro	2B	296.4	208	291	78%

 

3B Rankings

 

Ranking	Player	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Jose Ramirez	2B, 3B	3.1	3	5	100%
2	Nolan Arenado	3B	5.4	3	11	100%
3	Manny Machado	3B, SS	9.8	6	27	100%
4	Alex Bregman	3B, SS	14.1	8	22	100%
5	Javier Baez	2B, 3B, SS	26.4	17	43	100%
6	Kris Bryant	3B, OF	27.8	21	33	100%
7	Anthony Rendon	3B	37.7	27	44	100%
8	Eugenio Suarez	3B	48.9	37	78	100%
9	Matt Carpenter	1B, 2B, 3B	58.8	34	121	100%
10	Vladimir Guerrero Jr.	3B	60.9	42	81	100%
11	Nicholas Castellanos	3B, OF	79.1	57	116	100%
12	Scooter Gennett	2B, 3B, OF	86.0	66	105	100%
13	Justin Turner	3B	86.2	60	115	100%
14	Matt Chapman	3B	87.4	61	127	100%
15	Josh Donaldson	3B	89.8	58	139	100%
16	Travis Shaw	3B	92.0	55	118	100%
17	Joey Gallo	1B, 3B, OF	98.6	70	128	100%
18	Max Muncy	1B, 2B, 3B, OF	102.6	88	136	100%
19	Miguel Andujar	3B	104.3	76	141	100%
20	Rafael Devers	3B	128.9	114	161	100%
21	Mike Moustakas	3B	136.2	114	172	100%
22	Jurickson Profar	1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF	145.9	99	195	100%
23	Miguel Sano	1B, 3B	209.9	161	291	94%
24	Yulieski Gurriel	1B, 3B	210.3	147	267	100%
25	Eduardo Escobar	2B, 3B, SS	217.7	135	247	89%
26	Nick Senzel	3B	226.9	179	285	100%
27	Jed Lowrie	2B, 3B	229.3	160	261	100%
28	Kyle Seager	3B	231.8	178	276	94%
29	Ian Happ	2B, 3B, OF	238.3	194	281	94%
30	Jake Lamb	3B	249.3	181	271	89%
31	Maikel Franco	3B	289.3	206	288	78%
32	Evan Longoria	3B	293.2	195	287	67%
33	Asdrubal Cabrera	2B, 3B, SS	293.7	185	283	67%
34	Marwin Gonzalez	1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF	294.8	222	297	78%
35	Brian Anderson	3B, OF	303.9	240	296	72%
36	Willians Astudillo	C, 3B	329.6	223	300	56%

 

SS Rankings

 

Ranking	Player	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Trea Turner	SS	8.6	4	16	100%
2	Manny Machado	3B, SS	9.8	6	27	100%
3	Francisco Lindor	SS	10.8	4	21	100%
4	Alex Bregman	3B, SS	14.1	8	22	100%
5	Trevor Story	SS	19.8	9	29	100%
6	Javier Baez	2B, 3B, SS	26.4	17	43	100%
7	Carlos Correa	SS	42.6	29	82	100%
8	Xander Bogaerts	SS	44.3	25	54	100%
9	Jean Segura	SS	62.4	51	87	100%
10	Corey Seager	SS	67.4	51	105	100%
11	Adalberto Mondesi	2B, SS	73.4	36	103	100%
12	Gleyber Torres	2B, SS	79.4	48	125	100%
13	Jose Peraza	2B, SS	119.3	68	149	100%
14	Jurickson Profar	1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF	145.9	99	195	100%
15	Tim Anderson	SS	153.6	112	271	100%
16	Elvis Andrus	SS	156.4	122	291	100%
17	Amed Rosario	SS	157.7	131	233	100%
18	Paul DeJong	2B, SS	184.3	131	214	100%
19	Andrelton Simmons	SS	194.0	171	265	100%
20	Marcus Semien	SS	205.6	167	279	100%
21	Jorge Polanco	SS	210.1	161	261	100%
22	Eduardo Escobar	2B, 3B, SS	217.7	135	247	89%
23	Ketel Marte	2B, SS	218.8	159	258	100%
24	Chris Taylor	2B, SS, OF	234.2	193	280	94%
25	Garrett Hampson	2B, SS	234.7	153	294	94%
26	Willy Adames	2B, SS	247.1	184	292	89%
27	Lourdes Gurriel Jr.	2B, SS, OF	276.2	201	269	78%
28	Asdrubal Cabrera	2B, 3B, SS	293.7	185	283	67%
29	Marwin Gonzalez	1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF	294.8	222	297	78%
30	Didi Gregorius	SS	312.9	207	300	61%

 

OF Rankings

 

Ranking	Player	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Mike Trout	OF	1.0	1	1	100%
2	Mookie Betts	OF	2.0	2	2	100%
3	J.D. Martinez	OF	5.1	4	8	100%
4	Christian Yelich	OF	10.6	4	18	100%
5	Ronald Acuna	OF	12.1	5	21	100%
6	Aaron Judge	OF	13.7	6	20	100%
7	Bryce Harper	OF	14.3	8	20	100%
8	Giancarlo Stanton	OF	21.3	17	29	100%
9	Charlie Blackmon	OF	24.4	16	34	100%
10	Andrew Benintendi	OF	27.4	18	49	100%
11	Kris Bryant	3B, OF	27.8	21	33	100%
12	Juan Soto	OF	34.1	21	56	100%
13	Starling Marte	OF	37.0	30	57	100%
14	Whit Merrifield	1B, 2B, OF	37.9	27	52	100%
15	Khris Davis	OF	39.1	26	55	100%
16	Rhys Hoskins	1B, OF	40.7	23	54	100%
17	Cody Bellinger	1B, OF	43.9	35	56	100%
18	George Springer	OF	50.1	39	75	100%
19	Lorenzo Cain	OF	51.6	41	65	100%
20	Justin Upton	OF	62.7	46	90	100%
21	Nelson Cruz	OF	64.0	50	95	100%
22	Tommy Pham	OF	65.6	43	103	100%
23	Mitch Haniger	OF	74.8	53	148	100%
24	Marcell Ozuna	OF	76.2	35	168	100%
25	Nicholas Castellanos	3B, OF	79.1	57	116	100%
26	Eddie Rosario	OF	79.4	55	137	100%
27	Scooter Gennett	2B, 3B, OF	86.0	66	105	100%
28	Michael Conforto	OF	86.4	53	107	100%
29	Wil Myers	1B, OF	86.4	49	140	100%
30	Yasiel Puig	OF	88.7	60	117	100%
31	A.J. Pollock	OF	89.6	58	165	100%
32	Aaron Hicks	OF	90.8	55	122	100%
33	Matt Olson	1B, OF	91.2	59	112	100%
34	Joey Gallo	1B, 3B, OF	98.6	70	128	100%
35	Michael Brantley	OF	100.2	77	166	100%
36	Max Muncy	1B, 2B, 3B, OF	102.6	88	136	100%
37	David Dahl	OF	105.6	72	123	100%
38	Andrew McCutchen	OF	106.4	64	141	100%
39	Jonathan Villar	2B, OF	110.4	80	171	100%
40	David Peralta	OF	112.4	96	126	100%
41	Eloy Jimenez	OF	114.1	82	146	100%
42	Dee Gordon	2B, OF	116.4	85	173	100%
43	Ender Inciarte	OF	121.6	99	180	100%
44	Victor Robles	OF	121.8	91	161	100%
45	Mallex Smith	OF	124.2	79	178	100%
46	Stephen Piscotty	OF	141.0	107	166	100%
47	Nomar Mazara	OF	141.6	88	203	100%
48	Jurickson Profar	1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF	145.9	99	195	100%
49	Brandon Nimmo	OF	151.3	104	211	100%
50	Ian Desmond	1B, OF	155.1	125	209	100%
51	Harrison Bader	OF	168.5	139	222	100%
52	Ryan Braun	1B, OF	170.6	122	248	100%
53	Carlos Santana	1B, OF	177.4	130	263	100%
54	Adam Eaton	OF	178.7	121	255	100%
55	Austin Meadows	OF	182.1	123	260	100%
56	Kyle Schwarber	OF	187.3	140	263	100%
57	Billy Hamilton	OF	190.8	143	267	100%
58	Hunter Renfroe	OF	193.4	160	227	100%
59	Jose Martinez	1B, OF	193.6	131	261	100%
60	Jesse Winker	OF	197.1	128	224	94%
61	Gregory Polanco	OF	198.9	121	261	94%
62	Corey Dickerson	OF	201.1	156	249	100%
63	Shin-Soo Choo	OF	209.5	169	277	100%
64	Ramon Laureano	OF	211.3	140	259	94%
65	Byron Buxton	OF	212.2	142	298	94%
66	Franmil Reyes	OF	213.9	149	225	94%
67	Jake Bauers	1B, OF	230.3	150	298	100%
68	Odubel Herrera	OF	233.2	161	288	89%
69	Chris Taylor	2B, SS, OF	234.2	193	280	94%
70	Ian Happ	2B, 3B, OF	238.3	194	281	94%
71	Domingo Santana	OF	245.0	159	284	89%
72	Manuel Margot	OF	249.3	202	286	94%
73	Jackie Bradley	OF	249.8	143	288	89%
74	Max Kepler	OF	251.2	151	298	94%
75	Nick Markakis	OF	259.7	205	286	83%
76	Joey Wendle	2B, OF	260.1	192	271	83%
77	Trey Mancini	1B, OF	274.5	183	296	72%
78	Randal Grichuk	OF	274.6	204	278	78%
79	Lourdes Gurriel Jr.	2B, SS, OF	276.2	201	269	78%
80	Matt Kemp	OF	289.9	181	294	72%
81	Kyle Tucker	OF	290.6	230	298	83%
82	Marwin Gonzalez	1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF	294.8	222	297	78%
83	Brandon Belt	1B, OF	297.2	247	295	78%
84	Adam Jones	OF	297.8	162	300	61%
85	Brian Anderson	3B, OF	303.9	240	296	72%
86	Avisail Garcia	OF	309.9	198	297	67%
87	Jay Bruce	1B, OF	310.1	226	292	67%
88	Steven Souza	OF	310.1	202	293	67%

 

SP Rankings

 

Ranking	Player	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Max Scherzer	SP	8.7	6	18	100%
2	Chris Sale	SP	12.3	4	20	100%
3	Jacob deGrom	SP	14.5	9	20	100%
4	Justin Verlander	SP	24.6	22	31	100%
5	Corey Kluber	SP	26.2	18	37	100%
6	Gerrit Cole	SP	26.8	20	33	100%
7	Aaron Nola	SP	28.9	19	39	100%
8	Blake Snell	SP	30.4	24	36	100%
9	Trevor Bauer	SP	32.4	18	45	100%
10	Luis Severino	SP	38.0	25	57	100%
11	Noah Syndergaard	SP	40.7	28	61	100%
12	Carlos Carrasco	SP	42.5	36	49	100%
13	Walker Buehler	SP, RP	46.7	35	56	100%
14	Clayton Kershaw	SP	51.6	29	124	100%
15	Patrick Corbin	SP	56.1	37	74	100%
16	James Paxton	SP	58.9	46	80	100%
17	Stephen Strasburg	SP	61.4	47	92	100%
18	Mike Clevinger	SP, RP	63.2	38	84	100%
19	Zack Greinke	SP	66.6	50	124	100%
20	Jameson Taillon	SP	67.5	47	108	100%
21	Jack Flaherty	SP	79.5	57	109	100%
22	German Marquez	SP	86.9	54	110	100%
23	Zack Wheeler	SP	87.9	42	138	100%
24	David Price	SP, RP	90.3	59	114	100%
25	Jose Berrios	SP	90.3	68	107	100%
26	Mike Foltynewicz	SP	102.1	81	147	100%
27	Madison Bumgarner	SP	104.1	67	182	100%
28	Miles Mikolas	SP	108.3	44	153	100%
29	Masahiro Tanaka	SP	112.8	79	146	100%
30	Luis Castillo	SP	117.5	76	199	100%
31	Yu Darvish	SP	123.2	69	192	100%
32	Charlie Morton	SP	126.9	94	164	100%
33	Robbie Ray	SP	130.9	107	193	100%
34	Kyle Hendricks	SP	138.7	123	180	100%
35	Carlos Martinez	SP	147.4	78	257	100%
36	Nick Pivetta	SP	148.1	115	209	100%
37	J.A. Happ	SP	153.6	105	186	100%
38	Eduardo Rodriguez	SP	154.6	107	197	100%
39	Chris Archer	SP	157.2	110	198	100%
40	Kyle Freeland	SP, RP	166.6	99	245	100%
41	Cole Hamels	SP	170.9	144	282	100%
42	Rich Hill	SP	171.4	111	261	100%
43	Shane Bieber	SP	172.6	106	218	100%
44	Nathan Eovaldi	SP	173.2	119	254	100%
45	Andrew Heaney	SP	177.2	116	242	100%
46	Ross Stripling	SP, RP	186.3	120	265	100%
47	Dallas Keuchel	SP	186.5	129	260	100%
48	Tyler Glasnow	SP, RP	188.7	121	266	100%
49	Kenta Maeda	SP	191.8	123	279	100%
50	Tyler Skaggs	SP	194.8	139	213	94%
51	Jon Lester	SP	202.9	157	253	94%
52	Alex Wood	SP	203.4	135	291	100%
53	Hyun-Jin Ryu	SP	207.6	161	271	100%
54	Jose Quintana	SP	208.7	159	296	100%
55	Rick Porcello	SP	210.1	163	295	100%
56	Kevin Gausman	SP	213.9	161	289	100%
57	Alex Reyes	SP	222.9	148	250	89%
58	Josh James	SP	231.9	124	234	78%
59	Jake Arrieta	SP	232.7	180	295	94%
60	Jonathan Gray	SP	235.6	161	295	89%
61	Michael Fulmer	SP	236.8	166	286	89%
62	Joey Lucchesi	SP	242.5	186	288	94%
63	Zack Godley	SP	245.7	175	300	89%
64	Will Smith	SP, RP	247.7	174	274	83%
65	Joe Musgrove	SP, RP	248.0	136	299	78%
66	Jimmy Nelson	SP	250.2	138	295	78%
67	Collin McHugh	SP, RP	264.5	172	297	78%
68	Steven Matz	SP	264.9	197	300	94%
69	Jordan Hicks	SP, RP	265.4	166	299	78%
70	Seranthony Dominguez	SP, RP	276.1	182	286	78%
71	Jesus Luzardo	SP	278.4	163	299	78%
72	Luke Weaver	SP	291.9	210	300	72%
73	Sean Newcomb	SP	293.0	188	295	67%
74	Sonny Gray	SP	297.5	216	299	78%
75	Mike Soroka	SP	299.8	146	285	61%
76	Kyle Gibson	SP	304.1	201	292	72%
77	Trevor May	SP, RP	313.1	246	297	67%
78	Reynaldo Lopez	SP	318.3	208	288	56%
79	Carlos Rodon	SP	319.7	243	299	61%
80	Dylan Bundy	SP	321.4	241	299	67%
81	Marcus Stroman	SP	327.1	237	296	56%
82	Matt Boyd	SP	328.3	213	276	44%
83	Chase Anderson	SP	333.6	239	297	50%
84	Dereck Rodriguez	SP, RP	334.4	201	296	50%
85	Derek Holland	SP	334.8	165	297	39%

 

RP Rankings

 

Ranking	Player	Position	Consensus	High	Low	Percent
1	Edwin Diaz	RP	64.8	45	125	100%
2	Blake Treinen	RP	76.9	57	108	100%
3	Craig Kimbrel	RP	80.8	50	124	100%
4	Kenley Jansen	RP	85.5	51	120	100%
5	Aroldis Chapman	RP	88.6	74	111	100%
6	Roberto Osuna	RP	100.9	83	156	100%
7	Brad Hand	RP	103.5	84	135	100%
8	Felipe Vazquez	RP	104.3	80	119	100%
9	Sean Doolittle	RP	118.7	89	144	100%
10	Raisel Iglesias	RP	125.3	100	162	100%
11	Josh Hader	RP	138.3	94	282	100%
12	Kirby Yates	RP	146.4	97	175	100%
13	Jose Leclerc	RP	150.4	119	189	100%
14	Wade Davis	RP	153.6	133	203	100%
15	Ken Giles	RP	155.4	118	298	100%
16	Corey Knebel	RP	162.4	128	181	94%
17	Ross Stripling	SP, RP	186.3	120	265	100%
18	Tyler Glasnow	SP, RP	188.7	121	266	100%
19	Cody Allen	RP	192.7	153	295	100%
20	David Robertson	RP	199.8	94	236	94%
21	Andrew Miller	RP	216.4	132	281	94%
22	Arodys Vizcaino	RP	247.7	193	254	89%
23	Will Smith	SP, RP	247.7	174	274	83%
24	Archie Bradley	RP	251.7	197	284	83%
25	Alex Colome	RP	262.2	184	300	83%
26	Collin McHugh	SP, RP	264.5	172	297	78%
27	Jordan Hicks	SP, RP	265.4	166	299	78%
28	Jose Alvarado	RP	271.9	155	298	72%
29	Seranthony Dominguez	SP, RP	276.1	182	286	78%
30	A.J. Minter	RP	276.1	180	292	72%
31	Dellin Betances	RP	282.4	164	290	72%
32	Mychal Givens	RP	283.6	207	284	78%
33	Brandon Morrow	RP	290.5	179	296	67%
34	Kelvin Herrera	RP	290.6	194	299	67%
35	Pedro Strop	RP	311.9	204	295	61%
36	Trevor May	SP, RP	313.1	246	297	67%
37	Jeremy Jeffress	RP	317.0	185	291	56%
38	Adam Ottavino	RP	334.4	228	278	44%

 

Notes

 

Players who weren’t ranked on a list received a ranking of 400 for the purpose of creating the consensus ranking.

The “percent” column refers to what percentage of writers had this player listed in their top 300.

These lists were created solely for the 2019 season. Be sure to take that into account if you play in any type of keeper or dynasty league.

Writers who contributed are (in alphabetical order):

Andrew Gould, Anthony Messineo, Austin Bristow II, Ben Palmer, Ben Pernick, Charlie Wright, Colin Ward, Daniel Port, Evan Rockow, Jay Dunbar, John Hale, John Wallace, Jon Metzelaar, Kyle Monson, Max Freeze, Nathan Mills, Nick Pollack, Rich Holman, and Ryan Amore.

(Graphic by Justin Paradis, @freshmeatcomm on Twitter)