+

The Hold Up 3/27: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking Baseball's Top Setup Men for the 2025 Season

It’s finally here, happy Opening Day y’all! This list will take a little while to stabilize as we learn about bullpen roles and pecking orders, but for now, let’s chase some of the higher upside relief options. While we wait to see how things play out across bullpens around the league, we can at least look at relievers who can help stabilize ratios and boost strikeouts in the early going.

 

Notes

 

  • Whether the closer role goes to A.J. Puk or Justin Martinez, the two are basically interchangeable in the hold and closer ranks. We should get a sense over the weekend as to who Torey Lovullo is leaning to use as his closer, but both need to be rostered everywhere for the time being.

 

  • Mason Montgomery might be a surprise this high but he appears to be locked into a high-leverage role already and he may have the highest upside of anyone on this list. Over his past 17 innings (MLB and Spring Training), Montgomery has allowed just 9 hits and 5 walks while striking out 26. The lefty has a fastball that sits in the upper 90s with over 18″ of induced vertical break (IVB) to go with a slider that held a 32.6% swinging-strike rate last year.

 

  • Tier 3 features a bunch of lefties as well as some future closers. Keegan Akin and Dylan Lee are coming off fantastic seasons and should be a bigger part of their bullpen’s late-inning plans this year. José Alvarado is coming off a down year, but he has shown his old velocity this spring, leading to a dominant 20 strikeouts and zero earned runs over nine spring innings.

 

  • If Mason Montgomery isn’t the best rookie reliever in the AL this season, it could very well be his teammate Hunter Bigge. Bigge wound up making the Opening Day roster and should work his way into a set-up role eventually. Bigge’s fastball is similar to Montgomery’s, just from the right side, and his slider is just as good.

 

  • Tier 5 features a bunch of starters turned relievers with Garrett Whitlock making his return to the bullpen where he’s thrived in the past. He should be in line for holds as well as some wins here and there as the Sox multi-inning fireman. Max Kranick has looked amazing in short stints this spring, and he might have found his role in New York. Graham Ashcraft could be the long-term closer in Cincinnati, but we will probably see him in a similar role as Whitlock for now. Louis Varland’s and Ben Casparius’ roles are TBD, but their stuff plays way up out of the bullpen.

 

 

Rank Pitcher TeamChange
1Griffin JaxT1TB+1
2Cade SmithCLE+1
3Justin MartinezARI+18
4Jeremiah EstradaSD+7
5Orion KerkeringPHI+8
6Edwin UcetaTB+UR
7Jason Adam
T2
SD-
8Luke WeaverNYM+UR
9Bryan AbreuHOU-5
10José AlvaradoPHI+63
11Blake TreinenLAD+11
12Lucas ErcegKC+UR
13Matt StrahmKC-3
14Mason MontgomeryPIT+47
15Justin Slaten
T3
BOS+12
16Adrian MorejonSD+28
17Porter HodgeCHC+UR
18Keegan AkinBAL+40
19Dylan LeeATL+13
20Ben JoyceLAA+UR
21Yimi GarcíaTOR+UR
22Robert GarciaTEX+30
23Yennier Cano
T4
BAL-8
24Chris MartinTEX+UR
25Hunter GaddisCLE-13
26Camilo DovalNYY+9
27Tyler HoltonDET-13
28Hunter BiggeTB+36
29Kirby YatesLAA+UR
30Alex VesiaLAD-7
31Cole SandsMIN+12
32Reed GarrettNYM-16
33Dennis SantanaPIT-8
34Hunter HarveyCHC+UR
35Aaron BummerCHC+36
36Fernando CruzNYY+21
37Anthony Bender
T5
MIA+50
38A.J. MinterNYM+UR
39Colin HoldermanCLE+8
40Garrett WhitlockBOS+UR
41José A. FerrerSEA+45
42Max KranickWSH+UR
43Graham AshcraftCIN+UR
44Louis VarlandTOR+49
45Jorge Alcala+UR
46Pierce JohnsonCIN-6
47Ben CaspariusLAD+UR
48Tyler RogersTOR-3
49Mark Leiter Jr.ATH+UR
50Collin SniderCHC-8
51José Leclerc
T6
SD+29
52Gregory SantosSF-14
53Seth HalvorsenCOL+UR
54Jorge López+UR
55Jesus TinocoMIA+UR
56Scott BarlowATH+UR
57Tyler FergusonCHC-11
58Tim HerrinCLE-3
59Anthony BandaMIN+UR
60Joel PayampsATL-11
61Tommy KahnleBOS-28
62Danny CoulombeBOS+UR
63Seranthony DomínguezCWS+UR
64Erik MillerSF+14
65Julian MerryweatherMIN+UR
66Taylor RogersMIN+10
67Chad Green+UR
68Ryan Fernandez
T7
STL-
69Ryne StanekSTL+6
70Joe MantiplyTOR+18
71Will VestDET-35
72Emilio PagánCIN-
73Garrett CleavingerTB-20
74Brock BurkeCIN+9
75Jacob WebbCHC+UR
76Lake BacharMIA+UR
77Abner UribeMIL+UR
78Daysbel HernándezATL+UR
79Nate PearsonHOU-38
80Ryan ZeferjahnLAA+UR
81Bryan BakerTB+UR
82JoJo RomeroSTL+UR
83Yuki MatsuiSD+UR
84Trent ThorntonCHC+UR
85Gregory SotoPIT+6
86Lucas SimsCWS+UR
87Gabe SpeierSEA+UR
88Jared KoenigMIL-22
89Paul SewaldARI+UR
90Bryan HudsonCWS+UR
91Danny YoungATL+UR
92Hoby MilnerCHC+UR
93Kevin KellyTB+UR
94Manuel RodríguezTB-63
95José ButtóSF-14
96Tayler ScottATL+UR
97Ryan ThompsonARI-32
98Alek JacobSD+UR
99Steven OkertHOU+UR
100Shelby MillerCHC+UR

 

SP Eligible Relievers

Subscribe to the Pitcher List Newsletter

Your daily update on everything Pitcher List

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

Account / Login