+

The Hold Up 8/22: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking baseball's top setup options for the 2024 season.

I feel like it’s worth taking a minute to try and break down the Dodgers bullpen. They just added two relievers from the IL this week and may even get Brusdar Graterol back in a week, which would put them at full strength for the first time. Michael Kopech and Evan Phillips are at the top of the pecking order here and don’t need much selling. Daniel Hudson is out of the closer role and has a 5.0% K-BB rate over his past 14 IP with a 5.06 SIERA and 24.3% CSW. The velocity has been on the decline for Hudson for a while now, and I wonder if we eventually see an IL stint for him before the playoffs.

Blake Treinen returned this week and has been okay for the most part this year but has just an 18% K-BB rate, 1.37 WHIP, and 4.00 xFIP going back to June (22.2 IP). Ryan Brasier also returned this week but with limited innings on the year and stuck in a deep bullpen, it’s hard to judge what his holds-league value just may be. Joe Kelly has struggled most of the year but he’s coming off a strong week in which he picked up two holds and a win (and the upside is always enticing).

As far as the lefties go, Anthony Banda over his past 16.1 IP holds 29.7% K-BB, and 21.5% SwStr rates to go with a 0.86 WHIP and 2.10 xFIP. Alex Vesia has had some command issues since the All-Star break, with an 11.1% K-BB and just a 6.3% SwStr rate, plus a 1.71 WHIP and 4.48 SIERA over his past 9.1 IP. There is certainly an argument to be made that Banda should overtake Vesia here, but they both have been seeing the same amount of hold chances, and I personally believe in Vesia’s stuff more so than Banda’s.

 

Notes

 

  • Trevor Megill returned from the IL earlier this week and went on to allow four runs in his first outing back. The good news is the velocity looked good, but his command was off as he was missing up a lot. I’m not too worried about him struggling down the stretch, as every one of the Brewers’ top relievers had issues last night.

 

  • Drew Rasmussen has looked great since returning from the IL this year, with a 1.00 WHIP, and 11/1 K/BB ratio over eight innings. His fastball velocity is up 1.6 mph pitching out of the bullpen and picked up his first hold yesterday.

 

  • It was a tough week for Andrew Kittredge, but it’s really been an up-and-down season for him going back to May. Over his past 31 IP Kittredge holds a 4.35 ERA, 1.42 WHIP, 4.06 SIERA, and 11.8% K-BB rate. The holds are still keeping his value afloat, but there are a lot of other relievers with higher upsides to take a chance on.

 

  • Kyle Nicolas moves up the list this week and while the stuff is better than the results, the results have been better lately with a 24% K rate, 0.94 WHIP, and 2.73 SIERA over his past 10.2 IP (plus two holds). He feels like he is a few tweaks away from breaking out. Speaking of breakouts, A’s reliever Tyler Ferguson has been fantastic since being recalled in July, with a 26.4% K-BB, 0.88 WHIP, and 2.57 SIERA over 24 IP. He and Michel Otanez have really turned into an impressive setup duo in front of closer Mason Miller.

 

If you would like more daily reliever updates, please check out our Reliever Ranks series.

 

SP Eligible Relievers

 

Rank Pitcher Change
1Griffin JaxT1+1
2Bryan Abreu+1
3Evan Phillips+2
4Tanner Scott-3
5A.J. Puk+1
6Jeff Hoffman-2
7Jason Adam+1
8Trevor Megill+UR
9Yennier Cano+3
10Yimi García-3
11Cade Smith
T2
-1
12Hunter Gaddis-1
13Joe Jiménez+2
14Luke Weaver+3
15Aroldis Chapman+4
16Kevin Ginkel+2
17Matt Strahm-4
18Jeremiah Estrada-4
19Orion Kerkering+1
20Bryan Hudson-4
21David Robertson
T3
+1
22Alex Vesia+2
23Jorge Alcala+4
24Tommy Kahnle+4
25Julian Merryweather+4
26Chris Martin+6
27Mark Leiter Jr.+6
28Drew Rasmussen+24
29Jake Cousins+11
30Andrew Nardi+1
31Nick Mears
T4
-6
32Reed Garrett-6
33Paul Sewald-3
34James McArthur+2
35Craig Kimbrel-
36Tyler Rogers+9
37Manuel Rodríguez+11
38Tyler Holton+5
39Anthony Banda+19
40Phil Maton-3
41Andrew Kittredge
T5
-18
42Daniel Hudson+UR
43Blake Treinen+UR
44JoJo Romero-10
45Adrian Morejon-3
46Joel Payamps+8
47Kyle Nicolas+22
48Tyler Ferguson+22
49Joe Kelly+11
50Garrett Cleavinger+9
51Yuki Matsui+13
52Andrew Chafin+13
53Dylan Lee+13
54Nate Pearson+14
55Jared Koenig+UR
56Tony Santillan
T6
+26
57Kris Bubic+29
58Taylor Rogers-11
59Pierce Johnson-3
60Scott Barlow-14
61Fernando Cruz-23
62José Alvarado-18
63Ryan Thompson-12
64Colin Poche-1
65Adam Ottavino-4
66Ryne Stanek-4
67José Buttó+5
68Will Vest+UR
69Tyson Miller+8
70Robert Garcia-3
71Tayler Scott
T7
-18
72Kaleb Ort+11
73Ryan Brasier+UR
74Tim Herrin+2
75José Quijada+9
76John Schreiber+UR
77Emilio Pagán-4
78Aaron Bummer+9
79Cole Sands+17
80Sean Hjelle-2
81José Leclerc-2
82Nick Sandlin-2
83Collin Snider+2
84Joe Mantiply-13
85Lucas Sims-11
86Jorge López+UR
87Erik Miller-12
88Roansy Contreras+9
89Gregory Soto-
90Cionel Pérez-2
91Tyler Kinley+UR
92Justin Wilson+UR
93Génesis Cabrera+6
94Shawn Armstrong+UR
95Jesús Tinoco+UR
96Sam Moll+2
97Michel Otanez+UR
98Grant Holman+UR
99Drew Smyly+UR
100Luis Garcia+UR

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

2 responses to “The Hold Up 8/22: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday”

  1. RP Lover says:

    I’m surprised Jeremiah Estrada is still so high – he’s been pitching in like 10-4 deficits lately with the additions SD made during the deadline.

  2. Adam Uphill says:

    It says Michael Kopech is still with CHW on here. JSYK :)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Account / Login