+

The Hold Up 4/3: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking Baseball's Top Setup Men for the 2025 Season.

With the Pirates bullpen currently in limbo, I think we can turn to one of their veteran lefties as a potential holds option. Ryan Borucki is back pitching in leverage, and while he’s had trouble staying healthy, he has been very steady for this organization dating back to 2023. Since landing in Pittsburgh, Borucki has tossed 54.2 innings and holds a 3.29 ERA (3.21 SIERA) and 0.91 WHIP to go with a 20.1% K-BB rate. So far we are seeing more sweepers and fewer sliders from Borucki, and it’s had a great effect on his success as he’s willing to throw that sweeper more against righties.

Sticking with lefties working their way into leverage, Steven Okert is probably the Astros’ third-best reliever at the moment, and it’s not like we haven’t seen him have success before. The slider has always been a weapon for Okert, and as long as he can hide the fastball behind it, he should be just fine. He’s coming off a great spring as well, and with the Astros bullpen up in the air after Josh Hader and Bryan Abreu, Okert could be useful in holds leagues, at least to start the season.

 

Notes

 

  • José Alvarado and Mason Montgomery continue to look unhittable, and I know it’s early but if these two lefties are both averaging over 100 mph, then I think it’s fair to say they belong in Tier 1, at least for the time being. Alvarado may not be on this list much longer anyway, as it does seem like he is the favorite for saves in Philadelphia at the moment. Saves or not, both of these lefties need to be rostered in all holds formats.

 

  • It’s great seeing Yimi García back in Toronto dominating hitters again. He’s locked into the top setup role there, and should be a great source of strikeouts as well. Camilo Doval has impressed so far and I’m not worried about just the one strikeout. The velo being down a tick isn’t a major concern, especially if it means improved command (just one walk so far).

 

  • The Gabe Speier comeback season is on, as he’s been able to keep his velo gains from the spring and now very well may be the Mariners’ top setup man. I was high on Speier heading into last season, but his velo dropped to 93 mph and he was just never able to get right. Speier was excellent in 2023 when he was averaging 94.5-95 mph on his fastballs, and he appears to be back at that level, if not better. The slider is Speier’s biggest weapon, but that fastball velo is clearly a big difference-maker for him.

 

  • Tommy Kahnle picked up the Tigers’ first real save of the season, but it’s too early to anoint him the closer as this bullpen figures to mix and match in the ninth throughout the year. Either way, Kahnle is picking up where he left off, throwing his changeup 93% of the time to start the season and having a ton of success doing so. I’m not sure if it can last for a full season, but until proven otherwise, I’m comfortable rostering him.

 

  • Abner Uribe is back and has looked really good in two outings so far. We’ve always been tempted by the talent, and maybe this is the year he puts it all together. It feels like with Uribe, who is only 24 years old, his success is tied to the mental side of things so I’m hoping Uribe can still turn into that elite reliever the Brewers had hoped for, and I love the idea of buying low on Uribe in dynasty formats.

 

  • Lake Bachar is not one of the Great Lakes but he may be one of the Marlins’ great reliever options right now. How effective he will be over time remains to be seen, but I’m certainly intrigued by his fastball metrics (19″ IVB, 2705 rpm spin) despite him only sitting 94 mph. He’s also added a sweeper this year, is throwing his slider harder, and has gone from a more traditional changeup to a splitter. It’s an interesting mix, and I can’t wait to see how he looks a month from now.

 

 

Rank Pitcher TeamChange
1Griffin JaxT1TB-
2Cade SmithCLE-
3Justin MartinezARI-
4Jeremiah EstradaSD-
5José AlvaradoPHI+5
6Mason MontgomeryPIT+8
7Orion Kerkering
T2
PHI-2
8Edwin UcetaTB-2
9Jason AdamSD-2
10Luke WeaverPIT-2
11Bryan AbreuHOU-2
12Blake TreinenLAD-1
13Yimi GarcíaTOR+8
14Lucas ErcegKC-2
15Matt Strahm-2
16Porter HodgeCHC+1
17Camilo DovalSF+9
18Justin Slaten
T3
BOS-3
19Adrian MorejonSD-3
20Keegan AkinBAL-2
21Dylan LeeATL-2
22Ben JoyceLAA-2
23Robert GarciaTEX-1
24Chris Martin-
25Tony SantillanCIN+UR
26Yennier CanoBAL-3
27Alex VesiaLAD+3
28Hunter BiggeATH-
29Tyler HoltonDET-2
30Kirby Yates
T4
-1
31Hunter GaddisCLE-6
32Cole SandsMIN-1
33Hunter HarveyCHC+1
34Fernando CruzNYY+2
35Reed GarrettNYM-3
36Ben CaspariusLAD+11
37Gabe SpeierSEA+50
38Tommy KahnleBOS+23
39Pierce JohnsonCIN+7
40Garrett WhitlockBOS-
41José A. FerrerSEA-
42Jorge Alcala+3
43Louis Varland
T5
TOR+1
44Max KranickWSH-2
45Graham AshcraftCIN-2
46Aaron Bummer-11
47Tyler RogersTOR+1
48A.J. MinterMIN-10
49Tyler FergusonCHC+8
50Tim HerrinCLE+8
51Erik MillerBOS+13
52Jorge López+2
53Anthony BandaMIN+6
54Julian MerryweatherMIN+11
55Abner UribeMIL+22
56Marc ChurchTEX+UR
57Gregory Santos-5
58Lake BacharPIT+18
59Jacob Webb
T6
CHC+16
60Chad Green+7
61Will VestDET+10
62Ryan ZeferjahnCHC+18
63Daysbel Hernández+15
64Bryan BakerTB+17
65Ryan BoruckiCLE+UR
66JoJo RomeroMIL+16
67Yuki MatsuiSD+16
68Steven OkertHOU+31
69José ButtóSF+26
70Manuel RodríguezTB+24
71Mark Leiter Jr.ATH-22
72Collin SniderCHC-22
73Danny Coulombe-11
74Seranthony DomínguezSEA-11
75José Leclerc-24
76Brendon LittleTOR+UR
77Anthony VenezianoTEX+UR
78Shelby MillerCHC+22
79Scott Barlow
T7
-23
80Joel PayampsATL-20
81Taylor RogersMIN-15
82Ryne StanekSTL-13
83Joe MantiplyTOR-13
84Garrett CleavingerTB-11
85Phil MatonCHC+UR
86Jack DreyerLAD+UR
87Trent ThorntonCHC-3
88Gregory SotoPIT-3
89Jared KoenigMIL-1
90Paul SewaldTOR-1
91Bryan HudsonCHW-1
92Alek JacobSD+6
93Ryan ThompsonARI+4
94Tayler ScottATL+2
95Kevin KellyTB-2
96Randy RodríguezSF+UR
97Bryan KingHOU+UR
98Daniel Lynch IVKC+UR
99Huascar BrazobánCHW+UR
100Nate PearsonKC-21

 

SP Eligible Relievers

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.