+

The Hold Up 8/15: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking baseball's top setup options for the 2024 season.

We lost a few reliever to the IL this week but we also gained two prominent 2024 breakouts in Bryan Hudson, and Reed Garrett who both returned from the IL. Hudson returns to a Brewers bullpen that is just Trevor Megill away from being at full strength, but I’d still expect to see Hudson get plenty of holds chances (Megill as well). Garrett struck out hte side in order in his first game back, looking like his early season self and he too should slot right back into a high leverage role as the Mets bullpen tries to nail down their late inning bridge to Edwin Diaz.

 

 

Notes

 

  • Jeremiah Estrada has been a little more volatile since the Padres acquired Jason Adam and Tanner Scott, with a 7.71 ERA and 2.29 WHIP over his past 7 IP and while he’s still racking up strikeouts (17 over those 7 IP) the lack of holds and quality ratios push him down the list this week. He also has a 1.97 xFIP over this span, so there’s definitely bad luck involved but the walk rate (15.4%) needs to be better to earn more hold chances.

 

  • Aroldis Chapman has been pitching great, pretty much since the start of June where he holds a 26% K-BB rate, 1.03 WHIP and 2.63 SIERA. The big difference here is that walk rate being at 10.6%, which while still high, it’s a number Chapman can live with given the swing and miss ability. He’s certainly the teams top setup option at the moment and could be closing out games full time soon with how poorly David Bednar has pitched.

 

  • I think James McArthur is much better than his ERA, WHIP and K rate say, and perhaps we may get another great end of season run from him starting with his previous two outings where he struck out 4 batters and allowed just one baserunner. It’s a bit baffling how he has just an 18% K rate while having a 31.5% CSW and 5.32 PLV.

 

  • I’m afraid the Rays have done it again, this time creating an elite reliever in Edwin Uceta. Now it’s only been 16 games and 26.1 IP but Uceta has posted phenomenal numbers across the board, with a 29.5% K-BB, 32.1% CSW and 2.30 SIERA. He only has 3 holds on the season, but two came earlier this month, so his high leverage usage appears to be on the rise.

 

If you would like more daily reliever updates, please check out our Reliever Ranks series.

 

SP Eligible Relievers

 

Rank Pitcher TeamChange
1Tanner ScottT1LAD-
2Griffin JaxTB-
3Bryan AbreuHOU-
4Jeff HoffmanTOR-
5Evan PhillipsLAD-
6A.J. Puk
T2
ARI+2
7Yimi GarcíaTOR-1
8Jason AdamSD+1
9Michael KopechSD+9
10Cade SmithCLE+5
11Hunter Gaddis
T3
CLE+5
12Yennier CanoBAL-1
13Matt StrahmKC-
14Jeremiah EstradaSD-7
15Joe JiménezATL-5
16Bryan HudsonCWS+UR
17Luke WeaverNYM-
18Kevin GinkelARI+6
19Aroldis ChapmanBOS+15
20Orion KerkeringPHI+1
21Ryan Pressly
T4
+1
22David Robertson+1
23Andrew KittredgeBAL+3
24Alex VesiaLAD+7
25Nick MearsKC+7
26Reed GarrettNYM+UR
27Jorge Alcala-2
28Tommy KahnleBOS+1
29Julian MerryweatherMIN-2
30Paul SewaldARI+6
31Andrew NardiMIA+2
32Chris MartinTEX+5
33Mark Leiter Jr.-3
34JoJo RomeroSTL+5
35Craig KimbrelNYM+UR
36James McArthur
T5
KC+9
37Phil MatonCHC+5
38Fernando CruzNYY+5
39Porter HodgeCHC+9
40Jake CousinsLAD+9
41Edwin UcetaTB+27
42Adrian MorejonSD-1
43Tyler HoltonDET+4
44José AlvaradoPHI-4
45Tyler RogersTOR+11
46Scott Barlow-2
47Taylor RogersMIN+4
48Manuel RodríguezTB+19
49Anthony BenderMIA-14
50Jason FoleySF+UR
51Ryan Thompson
T6
ARI+UR
52Drew RasmussenTB-14
53Tayler ScottATL+1
54Joel PayampsATL+3
55Austin Adams+4
56Pierce JohnsonCIN-10
57Huascar BrazobánNYM+13
58Anthony BandaMIN+3
59Garrett CleavingerTB+4
60Joe Kelly-10
61Adam Ottavino-9
62Ryne StanekSTL-9
63Colin PocheDET-8
64Yuki MatsuiSD-6
65Andrew ChafinCIN-1
66Dylan LeeATL-1
67Robert GarciaTEX+2
68Nate PearsonHOU+4
69Kyle NicolasCIN+16
70Tyler FergusonATH+27
71Joe MantiplyTOR+UR
72José Buttó
T7
SF+3
73Emilio PagánCIN+UR
74Lucas SimsCWS-14
75Erik MillerSF-2
76Tim HerrinCLE+1
77Tyson MillerCWS-1
78Sean HjelleSF-
79José LeclercSD-17
80Nick SandlinLAA-1
81Elvis PegueroBAL+3
82Tony SantillanCIN+UR
83Kaleb OrtLAA+UR
84José QuijadaSD-1
85Collin SniderCHC+2
86Kris BubicKC+UR
87Aaron BummerATL-6
88Cionel PérezWSH+11
89Gregory SotoPIT+9
90Danny YoungATL-4
91Tanner BanksPHI-3
92Austin VothTOR-
93Brendon LittleTOR-
94Burch SmithDET+2
95Hans CrouseBAL-
96Cole SandsMIN-2
97Roansy Contreras+UR
98Sam MollCIN+UR
99Génesis CabreraPHI+UR
100Jordan HicksCWS+UR

Subscribe to the Pitcher List Newsletter

Your daily update on everything Pitcher List

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

Account / Login