+

The Hold Up 9/12: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking baseball's top setup options for the 2024 season.

A.J. Puk doesn’t have a hold since August 25, but he’s been arguably the best reliever in baseball dating back to mid-June, and since June 23 he holds a 0.26 ERA and 0.50 WHIP (second best behind Raisel Iglesias). Over those 34 IP, Puk holds a 40% K-BB rate, 1.83 xFIP, and 1.31 SIERA, all best amongst relievers over that span. His 19.7% SwStr and 35.7% CSW rates still rank in the top 5. So even despite the lack of holds lately, it’s really hard to move him off the top spot with how dominant he has been out of the bullpen.

 

Notes

 

  • Tony Santillan has impressively been able to keep this run as a strikeout machine reliever going and is clearly the best arm in the Reds bullpen at the moment. Since the All-Star break, Santillan holds a 42% K rate (fourth best amongst relievers) and 1.94 xFIP (fifth best), while his 2.45 ERA and 0.82 WHIP certainly aren’t wrecking anyone’s ratios.

 

  • Aaron Bummer may only have one hold on the season, but he has still been impressive for the Braves, especially over the second half. Since the All-Star break, Bummer holds a 1.50 xFIP (best amongst relievers) and a 1.72 SIERA (fourth best) while carrying 29.3% K-BB and 34.1% CSW rates (both top 15). Now if we could just get some better BABIP luck and sprinkle in some more holds please.

 

  • Michel Otanez ranks second amongst qualified relievers in CSW (37.4%) since the All-Star break, definitely not a name you’d expect to see here. That number is backed up by a 20% SwStr rate (seventh best) and 2.31 SIERA (19th) despite holding a 3.24 ERA and 1.32 WHIP in the second half. The stuff is legit (98 mph FB and a slider with a 55% Whiff rate), and if he could just shore up his command a bit, he could be a top holds option.

 

  • Angel Chivilli ranks SECOND amongst relievers post All-Star break with a 23% SwStr rate behind only Josh Hader, and there definitely seems like there could be some sustainability to this as it comes with 29.6% ZContact – OSwing (also second behind Hader) and 35.7% CSW rates (top 10). That being said, it’s even more surprising to see him hold just a 21.6% K rate with this swing-and-miss ability. Stuff+ and PLV are also not big fans either. I’m still intrigued by the bat-missing ability so he’s worth keeping an eye on, even while pitching half his games in Colorado.

 

If you would like more daily reliever updates, please check out our Reliever Ranks series.

 

SP Eligible Relievers

 

Rank Pitcher TeamChange
1A.J. PukT1ARI-
2Griffin JaxTB+1
3Tanner ScottLAD-1
4Evan PhillipsLAD-
5Jason AdamSD+1
6Jeff HoffmanMIN-1
7Bryan AbreuHOU-
8Cade SmithCLE+2
9Joe JiménezATL-1
10Yennier CanoBAL-1
11Trevor Megill
T2
MIL-
12Hunter GaddisCLE+1
13Matt Strahm+1
14Orion KerkeringPHI+3
15Jeremiah EstradaSD+1
16Tyler HoltonDET+3
17Kevin GinkelARI-2
18Reed GarrettNYM+2
19Ryan Pressly-1
20David Robertson+1
21Clay Holmes
T3
CHC+UR
22Drew RasmussenTB+2
23Alex VesiaLAD+3
24Manuel RodríguezTB+1
25Dylan LeeATL-2
26Jake CousinsLAD+8
27Tony SantillanCIN+8
28Dennis SantanaARI+8
29Blake TreinenLAD+3
30Mark Leiter Jr.ATH-3
31Andrew Kittredge
T4
BAL-2
32Tommy KahnleBOS-1
33Jorge Alcala-5
34Justin SlatenBOS+4
35Phil MatonCHC-13
36Camilo DovalSF-6
37Chris Martin-
38Nate PearsonKC+10
39Kris BubicLAD+14
40DL HallMIL+UR
41David Bednar
T5
NYY+1
42Paul SewaldTOR-2
43James McArthurKC-4
44Craig KimbrelKC-3
45Daniel Hudson-1
46Adrian MorejonSD-
47Fernando CruzNYY+7
48Pierce JohnsonCIN+3
49Will VestDET+3
50Colin HoldermanCLE+6
51Ian Hamilton+UR
52Tyler RogersTOR+6
53Collin SniderCHC+24
54Cole SandsMIN+13
55JoJo RomeroMIL+2
56Jared Koenig
T6
MIL-6
57Andrew Chafin-14
58Garrett CleavingerTB-13
59Joel PayampsATL-12
60Yuki MatsuiSD-11
61Tyler FergusonCHC-6
62Brusdar GraterolLAD+UR
63Ryan ThompsonARI-2
64Tayler ScottATL-2
65Robert GarciaTEX-
66Aaron Bummer+9
67Michel OtañezTEX+13
68Troy TaylorSEA+UR
69José AlvaradoPHI+24
70Aaron AshbyMIL+UR
71Emilio Pagán
T7
CIN-1
72Ryan Brasier-8
73Tim HerrinCLE-5
74Ryan FernandezSTL-5
75Ryne StanekSTL-12
76Tyson MillerCHW-4
77Brock BurkeCIN+UR
78Angel ChivilliNYY+UR
79Taylor RogersMIN-20
80Kaleb OrtLAA-6
81José Leclerc+3
82Kyle NicolasWSH-22
83Anthony BenderMIA+UR
84Adam Ottavino-11
85Tanner BanksPHI-7
86José ButtóSF-5
87Hunter Strickland+7
88John SchreiberNYY-5
89Joe MantiplyTOR-7
90Sean HjelleSF-4
91Erik MillerBOS-3
92Jalen BeeksTEX+3
93Derek Law+6
94Cionel PérezNYM-9
95Keegan ThompsonCOL+3
96Erik SwansonSD+4
97Génesis CabreraKC-6
98José A. FerrerSEA-2
99Victor VodnikMIA+UR
100Seth HalvorsenLAD+UR

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.