+

The Hold Up 9/19: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking baseball's top setup options for the 2024 season.

I want to lead this talking about two unheralded relievers currently on American League teams fighting for a playoff spot, with both of these guys stepping into high leverage roles due to a rash of injuries to their respective bullpens. Collin Snider has become the top set up option for the Mariners and rightfully so as he holds a 1.15 ERA (2.90 SIERA), and 23.2% K-BB rate over his past 31.1 IP dating back to early July. A sinker/slider guy in the past, Snider has now adopted a four seam/sweeper approach which has been an obvious game changer for him (Fangraphs David Laurila recently interviewed Snider about the changes he’s made).

Cole Sands on the other hand has transitioned to a full time reliever this season, and he also holds an impressive 1.17 ERA (2.52 SIERA), and 26.7% K-BB rate over his past 30.2 innings. Sands has increased his cutter usage 23% this season as it is now his most used offering and he’s also been able to tack on two MPH of velocity on his fastball. Both of theses relievers have made drastically different changes this season, but they are paying off big time for each one of them, and the two should certainly be on your radar in holds leagues for next season.

 

Notes

 

  • After a fantastic August, Evan Phillips has started of September on a sour note, with 7 hits, 9 runs (5 ER) and 4 walks allowed to just 3 strikeouts. It’s unfortunate timing for those still holding out hope he may regain his closer role as Michael Kopech has also struggles lately (5 walks over his previous three outings).

 

  • Yennier Cano has not pitched in over a week as he is dealing with forearm tightness, which is never a good sign for a pitcher but he should be available to pitch this weekend it sounds like. Cano still has just 2 IP in September, so even if he is available the next week and a half, expect the Orioles to take things easy with him.

 

  • Ian Hamilton is back in the Yankees bullpen and looking like his early season self with 8 K’s over 4.1 IP since returning, allowing just 2 his and no walks. There are a lot of other options in that bullpen for him to bypass to be relevant in holds leagues, but its nice to see the stuff return.

 

  • Jorge López is back from the IL and despite his disastrous stint with the Mets earlier this season, he was really turning things around in Chicago. Over his past 21 innings with the Cubs, López holds 35% K and 36.6% CSW rates, as well as a 2.47 xFIP and 2.40 SIERA. His velocity has definitely increased since joining the Cubs and has led to this uptick in strikeouts.

 

If you would like more daily reliever updates, please check out our Reliever Ranks series.

 

SP Eligible Relievers

 

Rank Pitcher TeamChange
1A.J. PukT1ARI-
2Tanner ScottLAD+1
3Griffin JaxTB-1
4Cade SmithCLE+4
5Jason AdamSD-
6Bryan AbreuHOU+1
7Jeff HoffmanTOR-1
8Joe JiménezATL+1
9Trevor MegillMIL+2
10Evan PhillipsLAD-6
11Hunter Gaddis
T2
CLE+1
12Matt StrahmKC+1
13Orion KerkeringPHI+1
14Jeremiah EstradaSD+1
15Tyler HoltonDET+1
16Yennier CanoBAL-6
17Reed GarrettNYM+1
18Ryan Pressly+1
19David Robertson+1
20Kevin GinkelARI-3
21Clay Holmes
T3
NYM-
22Drew RasmussenTB-
23Alex VesiaLAD-
24Manuel RodríguezTB-
25Dylan LeeATL-
26Blake TreinenLAD+3
27Jake CousinsLAD-1
28Dennis SantanaPIT-
29Andrew KittredgeBAL+2
30Mark Leiter Jr.ATH-
31Tommy Kahnle
T4
BOS+1
32Justin SlatenBOS+2
33Phil MatonCHC+2
34Chris MartinTEX+3
35Kris BubicKC+4
36Ian HamiltonATL+15
37Tony SantillanCIN-10
38Nate PearsonHOU-
39Collin SniderCHC+14
40Cole SandsMIN+14
41Adrian Morejon
T5
SD+5
42DL HallMIL-2
43Camilo DovalNYY-7
44Tyler RogersTOR+8
45Daniel Hudson-
46Pierce JohnsonCIN+2
47Will VestDET+2
48Colin HoldermanCLE+2
49JoJo RomeroSTL+6
50Tyler FergusonCHC+11
51Joel PayampsATL+8
52Michel OtañezTEX+15
53Robert GarciaTEX+12
54Troy TaylorSEA+14
55Jorge López+UR
56David Bednar
T6
NYY-15
57Garrett CleavingerTB+1
58Fernando CruzNYY-11
59Jared KoenigMIL-3
60Brusdar GraterolLAD+2
61Tyson MillerCWS+15
62Andrew Chafin-5
63Yuki MatsuiSD-3
64Ryan ThompsonARI-1
65Emilio PagánCIN+6
66Tim HerrinCLE+7
67Joe Kelly+UR
68Ryan FernandezSTL+6
69Aaron BummerCHC-3
70Aaron AshbyMIL-
71Tayler Scott
T7
ATL-7
72José AlvaradoPHI-3
73Ryan Brasier-1
74Ryne StanekSTL+1
75Brock BurkeCIN+2
76Angel ChivilliNYY+2
77Taylor RogersMIN+2
78Jacob WebbMIN+UR
79Colin PocheDET+UR
80Erik MillerSF+11
81Prelander BerroaCWS+UR
82Brenan HanifeeDET+UR
83José LeclercSD-2
84Kaleb OrtLAA-4
85Anthony BenderMIA-2
86José ButtóSF-
87John SchreiberKC+1
88Hunter Strickland-1
89Adam Ottavino-5
90Tanner BanksPHI-5
91Erik SwansonSD+5
92José A. FerrerSEA+6
93Joe MantiplyTOR-4
94Sean HjelleSF-4
95Derek LawARI-2
96Cionel PérezNYM-2
97Keegan ThompsonCOL-2
98Génesis CabreraKC-1
99Seth HalvorsenCOL+1
100Keegan AkinBAL+UR

Subscribe to the Pitcher List Newsletter

Your daily update on everything Pitcher List

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

Account / Login