+

The Hold Up 4/17: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking Baseball's Top Setup Men for the 2025 Season.

Two veterans in Ryne Stanek and Paul Sewald, who signed for just $11.5 million combined this offseaon, have already proven they still have something left in the tank and should be on your radar in holds leagues. At 33 years old, Stanek is still able to average 98 MPH on his fastball, but one thing that has changed this year is his pitch usage, throwing his slider 34.3% of the time (up 17.7%) and his splitter just 6.5% (down 14.9%). This is likely a result of Stanek facing fewer left handed hitters to begin the season, but that may also be by design as Stanek generally has more success against right handed hitters.

Sewald is still barely able to hit 90 MPH but his fastball still grades out as one of the best in baseball do to his consistent location at the top of the zone with 1.8″ HAVAA. This leads to Sewald getting tons of whiffs with his sweeper, and so fa,r the results in Cleveland have been fantastic (33.4% K-BB, 39.2% CSW, 5.49 PLV). Even with Emmanuel Clase’s early struggles, Sewald shouldn’t see too many save chances, but he can be a steady source for holds as the season moves forward.

 

Notes

 

  • Finally, we see Kirby Yates get some hold chances, picking up three in his past three outings, the first he’s had since the Tokyo series. It’s only 9.1 innings, but Yates has been dominant so far, with a 48.6% strikeout and 25% swinging-strike rates while allowing just two earned runs. As long as he can latch on to this new role, he should be a top 10-15 holds option, but the Dodgers have so many options right now (with some on their way back as well), so the holds may not be that consistent.

 

  • A.J. Minter looks like the Minter of old, giving the Mets a much-needed left-handed presence in their bullpen as Minter holds a 39.3% K-BB rate, 37.7% CSW rate, and 5.30 PLV so far. Minter has upped his cutter usage with the Mets, but the four-seam looks really good as well, and he shouldn’t have any issues against right-handed batters.

 

  • I love Louis Varland as a reliever and think it’s just a matter of time before he winds up seeing consistent hold chances. The four-seamer plays way up out of the bullpen, sitting at 98.2 MPH, and has flipped the usage between his knuckle curve and slider, throwing the curve (which creates more whiffs) more. If Griffin Jax can figure things out (he should), the Twins could have one of the more electric 7th-8th-9th inning trios in all of baseball.

 

  • Abner Uribe looks great in his return to the Brewers bullpen, showing off the upside that we were all tantalized by two years ago. His high velo sinker/slider combo is similar to Brusdar Graterol’s, but unlike Graterol, Uribe is able to generate a ton of whiffs with his slider (70.6% right now!) and currently holds a 30.3% strikeout and 38.1% CSW rates. When he’s not missing bats, he’s getting groundballs (85%!), but the command/control still remains less than ideal (albeit improved).

 

  • Julian Merryweather has become the Cubs’ secondary setup option almost by default, as Merryweather has looked OK, but not the dominant reliever we’ve seen glimpses of in the past. The fastball velocity is still down two MPH from 2023, and I’m not sure he can survive in a high-leverage role without it, but perhaps he gets it back as the season goes on?

 

 

Rank Pitcher Change
1Jeremiah EstradaT1+2
2Griffin Jax-1
3Cade Smith-1
4Jason Adam-
5Luke Weaver-
6Mason Montgomery-
7Orion Kerkering-
8Bryan Abreu+1
9Yimi García+2
10Matt Strahm+2
11Lucas Erceg
T2
-1
12Edwin Uceta-4
13Porter Hodge-
14Justin Slaten-
15Kirby Yates+10
16Tony Santillan+1
17Yennier Cano+2
18Gabe Speier+5
19Robert Garcia-3
20Adrian Morejon-5
21Alex Vesia-3
22Chris Martin-2
23A.J. Minter+22
24Louis Varland+16
25Hunter Gaddis
T3
-4
26Reed Garrett-4
27Tyler Rogers-3
28Keegan Akin-2
29Camilo Doval-1
30Cole Sands-3
31Tyler Holton-2
32Dylan Lee-2
33Jose A. Ferrer+2
34Garrett Whitlock+3
35Randy Rodríguez+17
36Graham Ashcraft+2
37Nick Mears+4
38Tyler Ferguson+5
39Abner Uribe+12
40Phil Maton
T4
+13
41Steven Okert+13
42Ryne Stanek+23
43Paul Sewald+25
44Fernando Cruz-
45Lake Bachar-3
46Tim Herrin+3
47Erik Miller+3
48Hunter Bigge-15
49Ryan Zeferjahn-2
50Julian Merryweather+11
51Will Vest+6
52Daysbel Hernández+7
53Jacob Webb+11
54Max Kranick-15
55Mark Leiter Jr.+7
56Ben Casparius
T5
-25
57Danny Coulombe+6
58Shelby Miller+13
59Bryan Baker+7
60Brendon Little+25
61Justin Sterner+18
62Bryan King+14
63Jorge Alcala-27
64Ian Hamilton-8
65Chad Green-7
66Trent Thornton+1
67Aaron Bummer-21
68Manuel Rodríguez-8
69Jordan Romano+UR
70Anthony Banda-15
71Seranthony Domínguez
T6
+13
72Yuki Matsui+10
73Huascar Brazobán+16
74Hayden Birdsong+4
75Pierce Johnson-6
76Anthony Veneziano-1
77Jack Dreyer+10
78Garrett Cleavinger+15
79Jared Koenig+UR
80Ryan Borucki-3
81Jorge López-33
82Daniel Lynch IV+6
83Cam Booser+UR
84JoJo Romero-3
85Collin Snider-2
86Danny Young+5
87Taylor Rogers+5
88Alek Jacob+6
89Hoby Milner+7
90Brock Burke
T7
+UR
91Kyle Leahy+UR
92Carlos Vargas+UR
93Daniel Palencia+UR
94Ian Gibaut+UR
95Tim Hill+UR
96Jalen Beeks+UR
97Caleb Ferguson+UR
98Ethan Roberts+UR
99Gregory Soto-13
100Jesús Tinoco+UR

 

SP Eligible Relievers

Subscribe to the Pitcher List Newsletter

Your daily update on everything Pitcher List

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

2 responses to “The Hold Up 4/17: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday”

  1. Mason says:

    Holton doesn’t havd one hold all year. He is consistently working on the 6, 7, 8th inning. Is this small sample variance / randomness? Do you think he will be a viable hold option ros? He qualified at sp which is very helpful for me a svh. It allows me deploy another reliever. Thanks

  2. Jim says:

    Kerkering is not him.
    T Rogers deserved WAY MORE love here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Account / Login