+

The Hold Up 7/3: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking baseball's top setup men for the 2025 season.

The Red Sox got Jordan Hicks back this week, and while the results haven’t been great in his first two outings, it’s good to see him throwing 100 MPH again. Hicks signed with the Giants to be a starter, but I think he will strictly be used out of the bullpen in Boston, and (especially given his contract) may be the teams closer as soon as the end of this month. Hicks didn’t have much bullpen usage in San Francisco over the past two years, but his best season was in 2023 as a full time reliever. With Greg Weissert struggling recently, Hicks should immediately be in the running for the Sox top set up role, and with Aroldis Chapman highly likely to be traded, Hicks can be a great stash candidate in save only leagues as well.

 

Notes

 

  • Over his past 15.2 innings, Adrian Morejon holds a 0.38 WHIP, 2.01 SIERA, 23.2% K-BB, and 34.2% CSW rate as well as a 122 Stuff. He has not allowed an earned run since May 17th, which is the only earned run he has allowed over the past two months. With Robert Suarez struggling, I would not be surprised to see the trio of Morejon, Jason Adam, and Jeremiah Estrada begin to take over games from the 7th inning on, and I’d consider all three as must roster relievers in SV+HLD leagues.

 

  • Yimi García returned this week and was rudely greeted by the Yankees lineup, in particular Aaron Judge, who hit a two-run home run off him. Judge is arguably the best hitter on the planet, so I won’t judge Garcia too harshly on the outcomes, and despite the command being a bit shaky (to be expected first game back), the stuff looked normal for Garcia, so I don’t have too much concern there. I do wonder about his role as the rest of this Jays bullpen has stepped up in Garcia’s absence, but based on his usage yesterday (8th inning, up two runs), I think it’s safe to say Garcia will get his set-up role back.

 

  • It looks like Matt Strahm may be settling into the closer role in Philadelphia, which doesn’t mean Orion Kerkering won’t see any saves, but Strahm is likely the safer option of the two, as Kerkering’s 1.40 WHIP and 10.7% K-BB rates are tough to ignore. Jordan Romano had been pitching well and then got torched for four earned runs on Saturday and hasn’t pitched since. He’s been mostly good since late April, with a couple of duds mixed in with solid outings, so I’m not totally out yet and think there’s a chance he could be a fantasy option after the All-Star break.

 

  • Tommy Kahnle’s last save came on June 4th, and although Will Vest only has four saves since, I think the Tigers may be pushing away from the closer by committee approach and clearly prefer Vest in the role. Kahnle should still be a solid holds option, theres just limited upside.

 

  • Dedniel Núñez hsa looked much more like his 2024 self since the Mets called him up a couple weeks ago. He has picked up eight strikeouts over the six innings he’s pitched since returning, and has not walked anyone. Given how shaky Ryne Stanek has been all season and how poorly Reed Garrett and Huascar Brazobán have pitched lately, I wouldn’t be shocked to see Núñez take over the 8th inning sooner rather than later. (EDIT: And Dedniel just landed on the IL. The Mets will definitely be adding to the bullpen this month)

 

 

Rank Pitcher TeamChange
1Griffin JaxT1TB-
2Bryan AbreuHOU+1
3Randy RodríguezSF-1
4Cade SmithCLE-
5Abner UribeMIL-
6Alex VesiaLAD-
7Jeremiah EstradaSD+1
8Jason AdamSD+1
9Adrian MorejonSD+11
10Bryan BakerTB-3
11Luke Weaver
T2
NYM-1
12Garrett CleavingerTB+4
13Steven OkertHOU+6
14Gabe SpeierSEA-
15Brendon LittleTOR-2
16Louis VarlandTOR-1
17Brock StewartLAD-
18Dennis SantanaPIT-
19Yariel RodriguezTOR+2
20Bennett SousaHOU+7
21Tyler RogersTOR-10
22Phil MatonCHC-
23Reid DetmersLAA+1
24Yimi GarcíaTOR+UR
25Chris MartinTEX-
26Orion Kerkering
T3
PHI+UR
27Danny CoulombeBOS-1
28Matt BrashSEA+3
29Lucas ErcegKC+3
30Nick MearsKC+3
31Kirby YatesLAA+6
32Braydon FisherTOR+7
33Jordan Romano-21
34Edwin UcetaTB+2
35Garrett WhitlockBOS-5
36Pierce JohnsonCIN-1
37Ryan WalkerSF-3
38Gregory SotoPIT-10
39Aaron AshbyMIL+1
40Seranthony DomínguezCWS+4
41Tommy Kahnle
T4
BOS+UR
42Bryan KingHOU+1
43Brad KellerPHI+3
44Jordan HicksCWS+UR
45Caleb ThielbarCHC+4
46Steven CruzKC+6
47Mason MontgomeryPIT-
48Tanner BanksPHI+2
49Porter HodgeCHC+5
50Yennier CanoBAL+UR
51Justin WilsonNYY-
52Jose A. FerrerSEA+4
53Aaron BummerATL+8
54Erik SabrowskiCLE+UR
55Tony SantillanCIN+5
56Caleb Ferguson
T5
CIN+8
57Drew PomeranzLAA+1
58Hunter GaddisCLE-17
59Ryan ZeferjahnLAA-21
60Andrew KittredgeBAL+2
61Jonathan LoáisigaARI+6
62Brad LordWSH+4
63Mark Leiter Jr.-18
64Jake BirdNYY-16
65Hoby MilnerCHC-
66John SchreiberKC+3
67Anthony BenderMIA+6
68Tyler HoltonDET+6
69Ryne StanekSTL+12
70Ryan ThompsonARI-7
71Greg Weissert
T6
BOS-12
72Reed GarrettNYM-15
73Ryan Pressly+2
74Scott Barlow-4
75Chad Green+1
76Ian HamiltonATL-5
77Shawn ArmstrongCLE+2
78Kyle BackhusPHI+UR
79Cade GibsonMIA+UR
80Carlos VargasSEA+8
81Isaac MattsonPIT+13
82Taylor RogersMIN+9
83Brandon EisertCWS-1
84Erik MillerSF-1
85Jack DreyerLAD-
86JoJo RomeroSTL-2
87Juan MorilloARI+2
88Chase LeeTOR+4
89Nick SandlinLAA+UR
90Grant AndersonMIL+8
91Daysbel HernándezATL+UR
92Rafael MonteroNYY+3
93José FermínSTL+UR
94Lake BacharMIA+UR
95Kevin GinkelARI+UR
96Tim HerrinCLE+4
97Will KleinLAD+UR
98Angel ZerpaMIL+1
99Anthony BandaMIN+UR
100Tyler PhillipsMIA-10

 

SP Eligible Relievers

Subscribe to the Pitcher List Newsletter

Your daily update on everything Pitcher List

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

Account / Login