+

The Hold Up 8/29: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking baseball's top setup options for the 2024 season.

We have a few lefties charging up the board this week, all names we have seen in the top 50 or so on this list in the past due to their strikeout upside. I talked about Anthony Banda last week when covering the Dodgers bullpen, and how Banda appears to have moved past Alex Vesia in the pecking order. Since the All-Star break Banda holds 28.2% K-BB rate, 22.3% SwStr and 37.2% CSW rates as well as a 2.26 xFIP over 18 innings.

Dylan Lee gets forgotten about in Atlantas bullpen but he’s now the top lefty with A.J. Minter out and dating back to mid-June, Lee has been outstanding. Over his past 22 IP, Lee holds 33% K and 20.3% SwStr rates, as well as a 1.23 ERA (1.95 SIERA) and 0.82 WHIP. Lee only has 2 holds over the past 2 weeks but that’s still 2 more holds than Aaron Bummer has on the season.

Garrett Cleavinger has much better stuff (120 Stuff+ since the break) than Colin Poche (83 Stuff+) and has really out pitched him since the All-Star break, just allowing his first earned run since the break on Tuesday. Cleavinger has 3 SV+HLD’s over the past week and hopefully we see that trend continue.

Andrew Chafin has a 36.8% K and 18.1% SwStr rate going back to the All-Star break, as well as a 3.00 SIERA, although walks have been an issue (13.2% BB rate). Chafin remains the Rangers top left handed reliever, and has 2 holds over the past week.

 

Notes

 

  • There were plenty of relievers lost to the IL this past week, but we also gained some prominent set up men as well. Camilo Doval is back with the Giants and working in high leverage spots in front of Ryan Walker. Ryan Pressly is expected to return from the IL today and should slot right back in to a 7th/8th inning set up role. Dedniel Núñez returned late last week and should see some high leverage work as the Mets best reliever outside of Edwin Díaz. Justin Slaten is likely forced right back into a setup role with both of the Red Sox trade deadline additions, Lucas Sims and Luis Garcia, now on the IL. (UPDATE: Núñez is back on the IL with a forearm injury…).

 

  • Since the Rays traded Jason Adam, Manuel Rodríguez has really flourished in with 5 SV+HLDS, 2 Wins, a 23% K rate, and 2.87 SIERA over 11.2 IP. At this point, he doesn’t have quite the same upside as Edwin Uceta or Drew Rasmussen, but the stuff is there for him to take another leap in the bat missing department, and it’s certainly encouraging seeing the Rays trust him with save chances lately.

 

  • A lefty with limited strikeout upside but despite that has been flustering hitters going back to late June would be Tigers Tyler Holton, who has allowed just 1 earned run over his past 23.2 IP. Over that span he’s only managed a 21.2% K rate, but whatever, we will take the 0.38 ERA (3.33 SIERA), 0.72 WHIP and 10 SV+HLD’s.

 

  • Jorge Alcala has not been as dominant since the All-Star break, with just 17.7% K and 6.7% SwStr rates as well as a 4.85 xFIP over his past 14 IP. The stuff is still there and opportunity should be as well with Brock Stewart and Justin Topa out, but perhaps this rough patch can open up more chances for someone like Cole Sands.

 

If you would like more daily reliever updates, please check out our Reliever Ranks series.

 

SP Eligible Relievers

 

Rank Pitcher TeamChange
1Griffin JaxT1TB-
2Tanner ScottLAD+2
3A.J. PukARI+2
4Evan PhillipsLAD-1
5Bryan AbreuHOU-3
6Jason AdamSD+1
7Jeff HoffmanTOR-1
8Yennier CanoBAL+1
9Cade SmithCLE+2
10Trevor MegillMIL-2
11Joe Jiménez
T2
ATL+2
12Luke WeaverNYM+2
13Hunter GaddisCLE-1
14Aroldis ChapmanBOS+1
15Kevin GinkelARI+1
16Matt StrahmKC+1
17Jeremiah EstradaSD+1
18Orion KerkeringPHI+1
19Camilo DovalNYY+UR
20Ryan Pressly+UR
21David Robertson
T3
-
22Bryan HudsonCHW-2
23Tommy KahnleBOS+1
24Jake CousinsLAD+5
25Anthony BandaMIN+14
26Drew RasmussenTB+2
27Manuel RodríguezTB+10
28Chris MartinTEX-2
29Tyler HoltonDET+9
30James McArthurKC+4
31Jorge Alcala
T4
-8
32Alex VesiaLAD-10
33Mark Leiter Jr.ATH-6
34Justin SlatenBOS+UR
35Reed GarrettNYM-3
36Paul SewaldARI-3
37Craig KimbrelTB-2
38Dylan LeeATL+15
39Phil MatonCHC+1
40Andrew KittredgeBAL+1
41Garrett Cleavinger
T5
TB+9
42Andrew Chafin+10
43Blake TreinenLAD-
44Daniel Hudson-2
45Tyler RogersTOR-9
46Joel PayampsATL-
47Adrian MorejonSD-2
48Tyler FergusonCHC-
49JoJo RomeroSTL-5
50Nate PearsonKC+4
51Yuki MatsuiSD-
52Jared KoenigMIL+3
53Joe Kelly-4
54Kyle NicolasWSH-7
55Tony SantillanCIN+1
56Ryan Thompson
T6
ARI+7
57Kris BubicKC-
58Taylor RogersMIN-
59Fernando CruzNYY+2
60Pierce JohnsonCIN-1
61Colin PocheDET+3
62Will VestDET+6
63Tyson MillerCHW+6
64Tayler ScottATL+7
65Ryan Brasier+8
66John SchreiberKC+10
67Jorge López+19
68Robert GarciaTEX+2
69Scott BarlowKC-9
70José ButtóSF-3
71Adam Ottavino
T7
-6
72Ryne StanekSTL-6
73Kaleb OrtLAA-1
74Aaron BummerKC+4
75Cole SandsMIN+4
76José QuijadaSD-1
77Tim HerrinCLE-3
78José LeclercSD+3
79Collin SniderCHC+4
80Joe MantiplyTOR+4
81Cionel PérezNYM+9
82Emilio PagánCIN-5
83Sean HjelleSF-3
84Nick SandlinDET-2
85Gregory SotoPIT+4
86Jesus TinocoMIA+9
87Austin Voth+UR
88Génesis CabreraKC+5
89Sam MollCIN+7
90Michel OtañezTEX+7
91Grant HolmanPHI+7
92Brennan BernardinoCOL+UR
93Brenan HanifeeDET+UR
94Tanner BanksPHI+UR
95Roansy Contreras-7
96Jalen BeeksTEX+UR
97Hunter Strickland+UR
98Erik MillerSF-11
99Ryan FernandezSTL+UR
100T.J. McFarland+UR

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.