+

The Hold Up 6/19: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking baseball's top setup men for the 2025 season.

It looks like the Phillies have moved on from Jordan Romano as the team’s closer, and are now focused on Matt Strahm and Orion Kerkering sharing the eighth and ninth innings moving forward. Strahm has a 6.52 ERA and 1.45 WHIP over his past 9.2 innings pitched, so that’s an interesting choice, but at least Kerkering makes sense in the role, right? Well, Kerkering has not allowed an earned run since May 6 and has allowed just one earned run since May 1, a stretch of 18 innings, which is great. But he hasn’t exactly dominated over this stretch, with just a 1.19 WHIP, 4.59 SIERA, as well as 6.8% K-BB and 8.7% SwStr rates as he has tiptoed around trouble. If we want to get a super small sample, Kerkering has looked a lot better in his past three outings, allowing zero hits and just one walk while striking out four, but two of these outings were against the Marlins, whose offense is inconsistent to say the least. I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt for now, especially given how much the manager trusts him, but we need to see longer streaks of dominance to move him up further.

 

Notes

 

  • It’s been a rough year for Edwin Uceta, as every time it looks like he may be turning the corner, he hits a roadblock. June has been much better, though, and over his past 7.2 innings, Uceta holds a 2.35 ERA (1.94 SIERA), 1.04 WHIP, and the swing and miss over this span backs it up as he holds a 40.6% K rate and a 21.5% SwStr rate. That’s the Uceta we saw last season, and hopefully, he can continue this dominance moving forward.

 

  • Since his last save, Ryan Walker holds a 2.89 ERA (2.30 SIERA), 0.86 WHIP, as well as 26.3% K-BB and 32% CSW rates over 9.1 innings. This is more like the Walker we had envisioned entering the season, and while I could see him potentially back in the closer role, I still feel like he’s best off in a setup role (as the numbers this year show).

 

  • Greg Weissert is second in baseball in holds since the start of May with 11 (plus three saves!), so why has it taken so long to push him up the list? This looks more like a lucky hot stretch for Weissert than a true breakout. Yes, he holds a 2.18 ERA and 1.06 WHIP since May started, but it comes with an inflated 4.42 SIERA, plus poor 17.3% K, 7.4% K-BB, 7.5% SwStr, and 24.4% CSW rates. Stuff+ grades out average at just 100, and PLV is also not a huge fan with a 4.93 mark. Feel free to ride the hot streak for now, but beware of potential regression in the second half.

 

  • While other relievers in the Orioles’ bullpen, such as Yennier Cano and Andrew Kittredge, have struggled lately, Gregory Soto has been a massive plus and could net the team a nice return at the deadline. Over his past 8.1 innings of work, Soto holds a 1.08 ERA (0.72 SIERA), 0.48 WHIP, and gaudy 44.8% K-BB and 39% CSW rates. He also leads MLB in holds over this stretch with seven, tied with Abner Uribe.

 

  • I still have my doubts on Tony Santillan over the remainder of the season (unless the velo and swing and miss from last year all of a sudden return), but he’s been solid in June with three holds, a save, and a win while not allowing any earned runs and just two baserunners. Over those 6.2 innings, he still has just a 3.17 xFIP and 25.7% CSW rate, but the 30.4% K rate is still an improvement. I’m just not sure it’s sustainable.

 

 

Rank Pitcher TeamChange
1Griffin JaxT1TB-
2Cade SmithCLE-
3Bryan Abreu
T2
HOU+1
4Alex VesiaLAD+4
5Bryan BakerTB+4
6Randy RodríguezSF-3
7Abner UribeMIL-
8Jeremiah EstradaSD-3
9Jason AdamSD-3
10Tyler RogersTOR+4
11Brendon Little
T3
TOR-1
12Gabe SpeierSEA-1
13Matt StrahmKC-1
14Kirby YatesLAA+1
15Hunter GaddisCLE-2
16Louis VarlandTOR-
17Garrett CleavingerTB+1
18Brock StewartLAD-1
19Dennis SantanaPIT-
20Steven OkertHOU-
21Garrett WhitlockBOS-
22Adrian MorejonSD+2
23Chris MartinTEX+2
24Reid DetmersLAA+8
25Phil MatonCHC+5
26Lucas Erceg
T4
KC-4
27Matt BrashSEA+1
28Nick MearsKC+3
29Keegan AkinBAL+5
30Yariel RodriguezTOR+9
31Orion KerkeringPHI+16
32Edwin UcetaTB+14
33Danny CoulombeBOS-6
34Ronny HenriquezMIA-11
35Fernando CruzNYY-9
36Ryan ZeferjahnLAA-3
37Bryan KingHOU+4
38Ryan WalkerSF+10
39Pierce JohnsonCIN+1
40Bennett SousaHOU+2
41Greg Weissert
T5
BOS+12
42Gregory SotoPIT+12
43Tony SantillanCIN+16
44Reed GarrettNYM-9
45Seranthony DomínguezCWS+7
46Mark Leiter Jr.-17
47Michael KopechSD+2
48Brad KellerPHI+2
49Andrew KittredgeBAL-6
50Jake BirdNYY-12
51Mason MontgomeryPIT+4
52Drew PomeranzLAA-8
53Aaron BummerATL-2
54Yennier CanoBAL-18
55Jose A. FerrerSEA-18
56Huascar Brazobán
T6
NYM+4
57Tyler HoltonDET+5
58Aaron AshbyMIL+8
59Justin WilsonNYY+10
60Anthony BenderMIA-3
61Tanner BanksPHI-5
62Ryan Pressly+20
63Mason FluhartyTOR-5
64Caleb ThielbarCHC+15
65Jonathan LoáisigaARI+18
66Sean ReynoldsSD+14
67Luis MeyCIN+UR
68Grant TaylorCWS+3
69Yuki MatsuiSD-2
70Ryan ThompsonARI-2
71Caleb Ferguson
T7
CIN-1
72Kyle LeahySTL-
73Brant HurterDET-9
74Hoby MilnerCHC-9
75Chad Green-2
76Brad LordWSH+15
77Ryne StanekSTL-16
78Cole SandsMIN-15
79Erik MillerSF-4
80JoJo RomeroSTL-3
81John SchreiberKC-7
82Jack DreyerLAD-4
83Scott BarlowATH+1
84Kaleb OrtLAA-3
85Jalen BeeksTEX+8
86Anthony BandaMIN+9
87Carlos VargasSEA+7
88Braydon FisherTOR+8
89Luke JacksonNYM+UR
90Braxton AshcraftPIT-4
91Cam BooserTB-6
92Tim HerrinCLE-16
93Ian HamiltonATL-5
94Jared KoenigMIL-5
95Shawn ArmstrongCLE+4
96Steven CruzKC+2
97Matt FestaCLE+UR
98Cole WinnTEX+UR
99Juan MorilloARI+UR
100Tyler PhillipsMIA+UR

 

SP Eligible Relievers

Subscribe to the Pitcher List Newsletter

Your daily update on everything Pitcher List

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

Account / Login