+

The Hold Up 7/17: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking baseball's top setup men for the 2025 season.

We haven’t had any games this week, but we still have a big second-half/All-Star break update. Lucas Erceg hasn’t exactly looked better since returning from the IL a little over a month ago, with a 2.45 ERA (3.52 SIERA), 1.43 WHIP, and just a 9.7% K-BB rate. Pitching in Kansas City boosts his floor, but the ceiling may not be what we thought it could be. The Phillies desperately need bullpen help as Jordan Romano and Orion Kerkering continue to struggle with Romano holding a 3.97 SIERA (4.72 xFIP), 1.38 WHIP, and 18.5% K rate since the beginning of June, while Kerkering holds a 3.93 SIERA (4.78 xFIP), 1.36 WHIP, and 22% K rate. Nick Mears holds a 3.63 ERA and 1.12 WHIP over his past 22.1 IP, but it comes with just a 23.89 SIERA (4.22 xFIP) and 19% K rate (25.2% CSW). His velocity has been getting better game by game, so perhaps we’ll see an uptick in Ks coming out of the break, but for now, I kind of like Grant Anderson better.

Speaking of Anderson, he has been solid all year, but over his last 14.2 IP, he’s allowed just one earned run and holds a 2.38 SIERA and 30% K rate. Lake Bachar is back up in the 40s again, and he holds an impressive 1.46 ERA (3.00 SIERA), 0.97 WHIP and 27% K rate over his past 24.2 IP. Shaun Armstrong holds a 1.88 ERA (2.91 SIERA) and 0.56 WHIP over his past 14.1 IP with a 34.2% CSW rate and has emerged as one of the Rangers’ most important bullpen arms. Jonathan Loáisiga has struggled this season, but a 3.09 xFIP and 30.3% CSW over his past 20.2 IP (plus a 115 Stuff+) has me optimistic in a big second half for him, especially considering the Yankees’ bullpen is missing a few big pieces at the moment. The Pirates could trade their best two relievers at the deadline, leaving Isaac Mattson as the potential next closer. He holds a 1.89 ERA (3.43 SIERA) and 0.89 WHIP over his 19 IP this season, as well as a 29% K rate.

 

Notes

 

  • Reid Detmers has completely taken over the top set-up/next-in-line role for the Angels, as he has been their best reliever the past two months. Over his past 22 IP, Detmers holds a 1.23 ERA (2.47 SIERA), 1.05 WHIP, and 34.5% K rate (33% CSW) as his stuff has really been playing up out of the pen (116 Stuff+).

 

  • There’s an argument that Bennett Sousa is still too low on the list, but I do worry all the lefties in that Astros bullpen will ultimately limit each other’s overall upside. Sousa holds a 1.82 ERA (2.11 SIERA), 0.77 WHIP, and 29% K-BB (19.8% SwStr) over his past 24.2 innings of work, but it comes with just four holds (three saves and two wins, though).

 

  • Seranthony Domínguez has been dominant over the past two months and should get the Orioles a nice return this month, as the free agent-to-be is likely to be traded. Over his past 20.1 IP, Domínguez holds a 0.89 ERA (2.38 SIERA), 0.98 WHIP, and 38.8% K rate.

 

  • Braydon Fisher has had a couple of hiccups lately heading into the break, and I’m not sure what the long-term outlook is here, but the breaking ball combo he features is legit. Fisher holds a 0.67 ERA (2.25 SIERA) and 0.78 WHIP over 27 innings as a reliever, with 33.7% K and 35.2% CSW rates.

 

  • I actually considered bumping Jason Adam down even more, but he remains one of the better sources for holds despite his stuff taking a hit this season. Over his past 26.1 IP, Adam holds a 1.71 ERA, but that comes with a 4.05 SIERA (4.37 xFIP), a 1.48 WHIP, and just a 20.7% K rate.

 

  • Aaron Ashby has spent most of the year on the IL, but since being activated in May and added to the Brewers bullpen, he’s been the team’s top left-handed reliever. He’s only thrown 21.2 innings this season but holds a 1.66 ERA (2.30 SIERA), 1.06 WHIP, and 30.2% K rate to this point as his stuff plays up in a relief role (121 Stuff+).

 

  • Dennis Santana holds an impressive 1.59 ERA and 0.76 WHIP over his past 17 innings, but it comes with a 4.48 SIERA (4.65 xFIP) and just a 13.8% K rate (8% SwStr). The Pirates will be listening to offers on him and should be looking to sell high.

 

  • Elvis Alvarado is still raw, but the stuff is electric, and the opportunity for him to see high-leverage innings should be there in an Athletics bullpen that has struggled all season long. The fastball sits at 98.5 MPH with 15.3″ of iHB (probably should be classified as a sinker?), and his upper 80s slider holds a 19.3% SwStr rate so far on the season.

 

 

Rank Pitcher TeamChange
1Griffin JaxT1TB-
2Bryan AbreuHOU-
3Alex VesiaLAD+2
4Randy RodríguezSF-1
5Adrian MorejonSD+4
6Abner UribeMIL-2
7Reid DetmersLAA+15
8Dylan LeeATL+2
9Cade SmithCLE-1
10Jeremiah EstradaSD-4
11Bennett Sousa
T2
HOU+13
12Gabe SpeierSEA+2
13Seranthony DomínguezCWS+25
14Steven OkertHOU-1
15Brock StewartLAD+3
16Garrett CleavingerTB-
17Blake TreinenLAD+UR
18Braydon FisherTOR+17
19Brendon LittleTOR-2
20Bryan BakerTB-9
21Louis VarlandTOR-6
22Luke WeaverNYM-10
23Garrett WhitlockBOS+9
24Phil MatonCHC-1
25Jason AdamSD-18
26Matt Brash
T3
SEA+2
27Aaron AshbyMIL+12
28Edwin UcetaTB+3
29Ben CaspariusLAD+UR
30Tyler RogersTOR-9
31Yariel RodriguezTOR-11
32Bryan KingHOU+10
33Chris MartinTEX-8
34Danny CoulombeBOS-8
35Kirby YatesLAA-2
36Gregory SotoPIT+1
37Ryan WalkerSF-1
38Dennis SantanaPIT-19
39Pierce JohnsonCIN-5
40Erik SabrowskiCLE+6
41Grant Anderson
T4
MIL+27
42Lake BacharMIA+28
43Tanner BanksPHI-
44Jose A. FerrerSEA+5
45Shawn ArmstrongCLE+34
46Jordan HicksCWS-2
47Graham AshcraftCIN-
48Caleb ThielbarCHC-7
49Jonathan LoáisigaARI+23
50Isaac MattsonPIT+32
51Andrew KittredgeBAL+4
52Yennier CanoBAL-7
53Brooks RaleyNYM+UR
54Elvis Alvarado+UR
55Brad LordWSH+4
56Reed Garrett
T5
NYM+19
57Héctor Neris+UR
58Lucas ErcegKC-31
59Jordan RomanoLAA-19
60Orion KerkeringPHI-31
61Hunter GaddisCLE-7
62Nick MearsKC-32
63Drew PomeranzLAA+8
64Tyler HoltonDET-8
65Ryne StanekSTL-3
66Brad KellerPHI-14
67Anthony BenderMIA-4
68Tony SantillanCIN-11
69JoJo RomeroSTL-4
70Scott BarlowATH+4
71Angel Zerpa
T6
MIL+UR
72Riley O’BrienSTL+UR
73Jake BirdNYY+3
74Rafael MonteroNYY+UR
75Caleb FergusonCIN-17
76Aaron BummerATL-26
77Steven CruzKC-26
78Justin WilsonNYY-25
79Hoby MilnerCHC-19
80John SchreiberKC-19
81Taylor RogersMIN+2
82Ryan BrasierTEX+UR
83Wandy PeraltaSD+UR
84Sam BachmanLAA+UR
85Jorge Alcala+UR
86Brandon EisertCWS+4
87José FermínSTL+5
88Kevin KellyTB+UR
89Ian HamiltonATL-11
90Jack DreyerLAD-23
91Jared KoenigMIL-5
92Braxton AshcraftPIT+UR
93Kyle BackhusPHI-13
94Jacob WebbBOS+UR
95David MorganSD+UR
96Ryan Pressly-30
97Brock BurkeCIN+UR
98Huascar BrazobánNYM-14
99Calvin FaucherMIA+UR
100Connor BrogdonCLE+UR

 

SP Eligible Relievers

Subscribe to the Pitcher List Newsletter

Your daily update on everything Pitcher List

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

Account / Login