+

The Hold Up 8/21: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking baseball's top setup men for the 2025 season.

José Alvarado returned to the Phillies bullpen this past week, giving them yet another bullpen reinforcement, although one that is ineligible for the postseason. His ramp up appearances at AAA weren’t exactly anything to be thrilled about, especially considering his velocity had been down in most of those outings, but in his first MLB outing since May 16th, Alvarado pitched a clean inning while striking out Cal Raleigh. The velo was still down a little over a MPH, but he can still have success as long as the command is there.

Speaking of velocity issues on the Phillies, David Robertson continues to sit about 2 MPH down from last year, but it hasn’t made much of a difference as he still holds a 35% K rate over his first five appearances. He’s decreased his fastball (cutter) usage and his upped both his knuckle curve and slider usage. Robertson and Alvarado have quickly moved past Jordan Romano and possibly Tanner Banks in the pecking order but I’m not sure if they will see a ton of holds with Matt Strahm and Orion Kerkering healthy and pitching well.

 

Notes

  • Devin Williams has now gone 4.1 innings in a row without allowing an earned run, giving up just two hits and a walk in the process while striking out eleven. This is the Williams we are (mostly) used to, and it looks like his rough patch prior to this has passed. What his role will be moving forward remains to be seen, but if he is pitching like this he should at least be in the mix for consistent holds.

 

  • Edwin Uceta has had a rocky year, but since the end of May he has been one of the best relievers in baseball. Over his past 35.1 innings of work, Uceta holds a 3.31 ERA (1.59 SIERA), 0.99 WHIP and 43% K rate (second best amongst RP’s over this span). He’s back to where he was last season, and it’s too early to talk about 2026 but this Rays bullpen has crazy potential for next season if they can get the best out of Uceta, Griffin Jax, Bryan Baker, Garrett Cleavinger and Mason Montgomery.

 

  • Ryan Helsley has had a tough time transitioning to the Mets bullpen as he now holds a 7.11 ERA and 2.05 WHIP with his new team while being tagged with three loses. This may just be an adjustment period as he adjust to a new team, role and battery mate but until we see some signs of him turning things around he isn’t exactly a must roster in holds leagues.

 

  • Tony Santillan has been pretty steady for the entire season, but he’s turned things up a notch since the start of June. Over his past 30 innings, Santillan holds a 2.40 ERA (3.32 SIERA) and 1.10 WHIP, with his strikeout rate jumping up to just under 30% (29.6%) over this span. The walks are still a bit of an issue, but he remains Terry Francona’s most trusted reliever in that Reds bullpen.

 

 

Rank Pitcher TeamChange
1Mason MillerT1SD-
2Devin WilliamsNYM+5
3Abner UribeMIL-1
4Edwin UcetaTB+1
5Adrian MorejonSD-1
6Jeremiah EstradaSD-3
7Luke WeaverNYM-1
8Griffin JaxTB-
9Jason AdamSD+1
10Gabe Speier
T2
SEA-1
11Reid DetmersLAA+1
12Garrett WhitlockBOS-1
13Bennett SousaHOU-
14Dylan LeeATL-
15Garrett CleavingerTB-
16Blake TreinenLAD+3
17Steven OkertHOU+4
18Matt StrahmKC+2
19Bryan BakerTB+4
20Erik SabrowskiCLE+4
21Matt Brash
T3
SEA-4
22Louis VarlandTOR-6
23Brendon LittleTOR-1
24Pierce JohnsonCIN+1
25Aaron AshbyMIL+1
26Tony SantillanCIN+9
27Caleb ThielbarCHC+6
28Ryan HelsleyBAL-10
29Gregory SotoPIT-2
30Seranthony DomínguezCWS-1
31Hunter GaddisCLE+1
32Tyler RogersTOR-4
33Ryan WalkerSF+1
34Andrew KittredgeBAL+3
35Shawn ArmstrongCLE+3
36José Alvarado
T4
PHI+UR
37Orion KerkeringPHI+3
38David Robertson+32
39Brad KellerPHI+11
40Ben CaspariusLAD+4
41Danny CoulombeBOS-11
42Camilo DovalNYY-6
43Riley O’BrienSTL+2
44Graham AshcraftCIN-1
45Isaac MattsonPIT+1
46Lake BacharMIA-7
47Bryan KingHOU+1
48Tanner BanksPHI+5
49Lucas ErcegKC+2
50Shelby MillerCHC-8
51Brooks Raley
T5
NYM-10
52Reed GarrettNYM-3
53Scott Barlow+3
54Mason MontgomeryPIT-
55Grant AndersonMIL-8
56Hoby MilnerCHC-4
57Yennier CanoBAL-2
58Nick MearsKC-
59Jared KoenigMIL+10
60Caleb FergusonCIN-1
61Drew PomeranzLAA+2
62Angel ZerpaMIL+4
63Mark Leiter Jr.-3
64Tyler HoltonDET-3
65Elvis Alvarado-3
66David MorganSD+1
67Justin WilsonNYY-3
68Anthony BandaMIN-3
69Jordan LeasureCWS-1
70Yariel RodriguezTOR+1
71Cole Henry
T6
WSH+10
72Matt SvansonSTL+18
73Tyler KinleyATL+16
74Jack DreyerLAD-1
75Tyler PhillipsMIA-
76Ryne StanekSTL-2
77Wandy PeraltaSD+1
78Taylor RogersMIN+1
79Aaron BummerATL+5
80John SchreiberKC+13
81Alex LangeKC+UR
82Rafael MonteroNYY-6
83Mason FluhartyTOR+2
84Brandon EisertCWS+2
85Steven MatzTB+2
86Brock BurkeCIN+2
87Edgardo HenriquezLAD+4
88José ButtóSF-8
89Cole SandsMIN+UR
90Dietrich EnnsBAL+UR
91Luis GarciaNYY+1
92Eduard BazardoSEA+3
93Nic EnrightTOR+3
94Kyle BackhusPHI+4
95Andrew SaalfrankARI+2
96Tim HillNYY+UR
97Andrew Chafin+UR
98Jimmy HergetCOL+UR
99Kyle NicolasCIN+UR
100Justin Sterner+UR

 

SP Eligible Relievers

Subscribe to the Pitcher List Newsletter

Your daily update on everything Pitcher List

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

Account / Login