+

The Hold Up 9/11: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking baseball's top setup men for the 2025 season.

No notes this week as I’m in the middle of moving, but I’ve gone and updated the list for the week. Any questions/comments reach out to me on X/Bluesky and I’ll try to answer as soon as possible.

 

Rank Pitcher TeamChange
1Mason MillerT1SD-
2Edwin Uceta
T2
TB+1
3Adrian MorejonSD+1
4Jeremiah EstradaSD+1
5Devin WilliamsNYM-3
6Luke WeaverNYM-
7Garrett WhitlockBOS+1
8Gabe SpeierSEA-1
9Garrett CleavingerTB+1
10Griffin JaxTB+1
11Matt Strahm
T3
KC+2
12Bryan BakerTB+2
13Matt BrashSEA+2
14Alex VesiaLAD+UR
15Blake TreinenLAD-3
16Aaron AshbyMIL+1
17Fernando CruzNYY-1
18Steven OkertHOU-
19Tony SantillanCIN-
20Brendon LittleTOR+3
21Phil MatonCHC+6
22Andrew KittredgeBAL+7
23David Robertson+11
24Caleb ThielbarCHC+8
25Seranthony DomínguezCWS-4
26Dylan Lee
T4
ATL-4
27Erik SabrowskiCLE-3
28Pierce JohnsonCIN-3
29Tyler RogersTOR+2
30Bryan KingHOU+7
31Robert GarciaTEX+9
32Hunter GaddisCLE+1
33Chris MartinTEX-7
34Brooks RaleyNYM+4
35Isaac MattsonPIT+1
36Riley O’BrienSTL+3
37Orion KerkeringPHI+7
38Jared KoenigMIL+7
39Cole SandsMIN+7
40Matt SvansonSTL+7
41Robert Stephenson
T5
LAA-6
42Lucas ErcegKC+7
43Justin SlatenBOS-15
44Louis VarlandTOR-14
45Jack DreyerLAD+14
46Graham AshcraftCIN+UR
47Reed GarrettNYM+UR
48Ryan HelsleyBAL-7
49Gregory SotoPIT-7
50José AlvaradoPHI-7
51Yennier CanoBAL+9
52Kirby YatesLAA+2
53Camilo DovalNYY-3
54Justin WilsonNYY+3
55Eduard BazardoSEA+13
56Michael Kopech
T6
SD-3
57Joel PegueroSF+22
58Matt FestaCLE+19
59Justin Sterner+16
60Tyler KinleyATL+16
61Yariel RodriguezTOR+3
62Tyler PhillipsMIA+5
63Tommy NanceTOR+6
64Edgardo HenriquezLAD+8
65Grant AndersonMIL+UR
66Tyler HoltonDET-1
67Rafael MonteroNYY-6
68Angel ZerpaMIL-12
69Dietrich EnnsBAL-3
70Steven MatzTB-12
71Tanner Banks
T7
PHI-19
72Lake BacharMIA-17
73Scott Barlow-11
74Elvis Alvarado-3
75José ButtóSF-2
76Taylor ClarkeARI+2
77Kyle LeahySTL+3
78Caleb FergusonCIN+5
79Cole HenryWSH-5
80Mark Leiter Jr.-17
81Drew PomeranzLAA+3
82Shawn DubinWSH+3
83John SchreiberKC-2
84Luis GarciaNYY+5
85Anthony BandaMIN+2
86Brandon EisertCWS+4
87David MorganSD+5
88Rico GarciaBAL+7
89Porter HodgeCHC+UR
90Craig KimbrelNYM+8
91Clayton BeeterWSH+UR
92Andrew Chafin+UR
93Jimmy HergetCOL-
94Kyle NicolasCIN-
95Brock BurkeCIN+UR
96Ryan ThompsonARI+4
97Zach MaxwellCIN-
98Jake WoodfordMIL+UR
99Ryne StanekSTL-
100Braydon FisherTOR+UR

 

SP Eligible Relievers

Subscribe to the Pitcher List Newsletter

Your daily update on everything Pitcher List

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

Account / Login