+

The Hold Up 5/22: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking Baseball's Top Setup Men for the 2025 Season.

There have been a lot of comeback stories this season, a few of which I talk about below, but Abner Uribe’s story is certainly an interesting one after everything he dealt with last year. A couple changes are resulting in Uribe’s breakout this season, first of which is that he is throwing more strikes. His fastball’s zone rate is up almost 8%, but he’s also landing his slider in the strike zone now, too, as the zone rate is up to 45.6%, up from 33.7% in 2024 and just 22.9% in 2023. This has lowered his walk rate to 10.9%, which still isn’t exactly ideal, but I will gladly take this number from someone like Uribe. The ability to throw that slider for strikes now has allowed Uribe a more 50/50 usage split between his sinker and slider, and as long as he is able to keep this going, I don’t see any reason to expect much negative regression here.

Since Uribe was activated on April 1st, here’s how he stacks up against the likes of closer Trevor Megill and fellow setup man Nick Mears, both of whom are having solid seasons as well.

Name K% xFIP CSW% Stuff+
Abner Uribe 34.8% 2.48 33.7% 119
Trevor Megill 26.6% 3.86 30.2% 119
Nick Mears 21.7% 3.41 27.3% 97

 

Notes

  • Brendon Little continues to prove his hot start to 2025 is no fluke, as the lefty still holds the best swinging-strike rate in baseball at 23.5%, which has led to a 37% strikeout rate and great ratios (1.61 ERA, 1.07 WHIP). The curveball is the big reason behind this, but with a 21% zone rate and 60% strike rate, something has to give eventually. Hitters will eventually adjust and start laying off his breaker more often, but it may not be anytime soon, as he is currently on an 11 strikeout/1 walk stretch over his past 7 innings. The sinker is still a solid offering here as well, and should give him a steady floor as something similar to the left-handed version of Clay Holmes.

 

  • I’ve seen a lot of debate recently about Ryan Walker vs. Camilo Doval, but I feel like Randy Rodríguez is being unfairly left out. I know he doesn’t have the closing experience like the other two, but he has been the Giants’ best reliever this season. Just look at his player page. Rodríguez has a closer-esque pair of pitches, too, in his 97+ MPH fastball and a slider that holds a 22.3% swinging-strike rate. Now, both Doval and Walker have looked better as of late, but Rodríguez has been the most consistent of the group all season (see below), and hopefully that leads to more holds moving forward.
Name K-BB% SIERA SwStr% PLV
Randy Rodríguez 34.6% 1.53 16.1% 5.33
Camilo Doval 14.5% 3.27 13.5% 5.01
Ryan Walker 11.5% 3.73 7.6% 4.88

 

  • Brock Stewart has been lights out for the Twins despite the decreased velocity, but the stuff is still playing up, and he now has a 39% strikeout rate since returning from the IL a month ago. Even with the great numbers, I’d still like to see Stewart throw more sweepers, but we’ll also take the new and improved changeup from Stewart. Griffin Jax is still the top set-up option behind Jhoan Duran, but I can see Stewart being that secondary option with Louis Varland. Just look at these numbers since Stewart returned on April 19th.
Name K% SIERA SwStr% Stuff+
Brock Stewart 39% 2.22 15.8% 114
Louis Varland 23.1% 2.72 11.6% 112
Cole Sands 20% 3.25 9.4% 94

 

  • Bryan Baker has been the Orioles’ best reliever this season, and it’s still wild to think he almost didn’t make the team out of spring training. Despite Yennier Cano’s recent struggles, I doubt he is completely removed from high-leverage work, but it should open the door to Baker finally seeing more holds (he has just 2!). I don’t think it would be crazy to think Baker may even wind up with some saves this year, as Félix Bautista also has hit a rough patch lately, allowing runs in his past four outings. For the entire season though, it’s clear Baker has been the most consistent right-handed setup man here.
Name K-BB% SIERA SwStr% PLV
Bryan Baker 28.2% 2.15 14.2% 5.14
Yennier Cano 14.7% 3.22 11.8% 5.23
Seranthony Domínguez 10.4% 4.33 11.6% 4.66

 

  • I know everyone is excited about Luis Mey in Cincinnati, and rightfully so, he has electric stuff, but let’s also not forget about Graham Ashcraft, who is starting to show the reliever upside we had been excited for entering the season. Mey still intrigues me much more than Tony Santillan or any other Reds reliever besides Ashcraft or closer Emilio Pagán, but I do worry about his minor league numbers as Mey has NEVER at ANY LEVEL held a K-BB rate over 13%. Anyways, these numbers are since the end of April when Ashcraft started seeing some increased velocity.
Name K-BB% xFIP CSW% Stuff+
Graham Ashcraft 28% 1.88 35.8% 127
Luis Mey 20% 2.86 31.5% 108
Tony Santillan 16.2% 4.55 23.8% 100

 

  • Fernando Cruz has been getting a lot of hype in New York and rightfully so, but now he is dealing with a shoulder issue and even though it sounds minor, and I’m not too concerned, lets still shout out Mark Leiter Jr. He’s only allowed runs in three of his 22 appearances this season has been helpful across the board in holds leagues this year. But while Cruz and Luke Weaver get a ton of praise in New York, Leiter has comparable numbers,  if not better, in multiple categories this season (PLV doesn’t like splitters…). EDIT: I should have been more concerned with Cruz as he did land on the IL this afternoon.
Name K-BB% xFIP CSW% PLV
Mark Leiter Jr. 29.1% 2.25 33.1% 4.94
Fernando Cruz 29% 2.74 36.6% 4.87
Luke Weaver 21.1% 3.69 27.6% 5.27

 

  • We’ll take a break from tables to talk about Ben Casparius and what the Dodgers should, or I guess more importantly, WILL, do with him now that their pitching staff has been decimated by injuries. It looked like Casparius was going to possibly join the rotation, but now they’ve stated he will remain in the bullpen in a true relief role, so I would think that means he’s by default their top right-handed high-leverage option? Casparius has been fantastic as a reliever this year, and I’d love to see how his stuff plays up in a consistent short-inning role.

 

  • Snider got off to a rocky start to the season, allowing five runs (three earned) over his first four outings, but since then he’s settled in and is showing that last year’s breakout was indeed real. Snider now holds a 23.6% K-BB rate and 2.55 SIERA over his past 17.2 IP, and while the strikeout upside (or lack thereof) limits his overall upside, I feel comfortable with Snider similarly to how we are comfortable with the high floor of a Chris Martin. Matt Brash is also back now and looks a lot better than I had expected, given the diminished velocity, but there should be plenty of room for these two and Gabe Speier to rack up holds the rest of the way.

 

  • Ok, this will be the last table I swear, but I think it’s important that we highlight how Ronny Henriquez is the Marlins’ best reliever right now. Henriquez throws four pitches rather equally, but the foundation, his four-seam is an elite offering as it sits at 96 MPH and gets 18.1″ of IVB (97th percentile 1.8 HAVAA). The offspeed stuff is solid, the sweeper is the big whiff-getter (31.3% swinging-strike rate), and I think the Marlins may have a breakout reliever here if Henriquez can just keep his command in check. Look at how dominant he has been since the last time he allowed an earned run (April 28th).
Name K-BB% SIERA SwStr%
Ronny Henriquez 28.2% 2.21 23%
Anthony Bender 17.1% 3.05 6.6%
Calvin Faucher 13.8% 3.26 11.6%
Lake Bachar 6.5% 4.65 13.8%
Jesús Tinoco 6.1% 4.26 10.9%

 

  • Drew Pomeranz comeback season is fully on at this point, and while the velocity isn’t where it was when he last pitched back in 2021, the pitch still has great shape with 18.2″ of IVB and 93 MPH isn’t too far off from when we last saw him (93.9 MPH in 2021). So this isn’t exactly like Liam Hendriks losing 2.5 MPH since he was last relevant. So I’m optimistic this Pomeranz thing can last, but I do have to wonder what’s going on with his curveball, which has yet to receive a single whiff somehow. I guess he’s only thrown 27 total, but it really isn’t a great offering so we shall see how long the fastball can carry him.

 

 

Rank Pitcher TeamChange
1Griffin JaxT1TB-
2Jeremiah EstradaSD-
3Bryan AbreuHOU+2
4Cade SmithCLE-1
5Jason AdamSD-1
6Gabe Speier
T2
SEA+2
7Matt StrahmKC+3
8Alex VesiaLAD+9
9Abner UribeMIL+28
10Brendon LittleTOR+18
11Hunter GaddisCLE+8
12Randy RodríguezSF+15
13Camilo DovalNYY+10
14Yimi GarcíaTOR-8
15Garrett CleavingerTB+11
16Dylan Lee
T3
ATL+14
17Louis VarlandTOR-6
18Brock StewartLAD+34
19Bryan BakerTB+30
20Graham AshcraftCIN+54
21Lucas ErcegKC-14
22Justin SlatenBOS-8
23Mark Leiter Jr.+31
24Matt BrashSEA+12
25Mason MontgomeryPIT-16
26Ryan Zeferjahn
T4
LAA-14
27Luis MeyCIN+19
28Adrian MorejonSD+4
29Ben CaspariusLAD+UR
30Garrett WhitlockBOS-9
31Steven OkertHOU-16
32Tyler RogersTOR-8
33Pierce JohnsonCIN+8
34Collin SniderCHC+44
35Ronny HenriquezMIA+50
36Nick Mears
T5
KC-7
37Keegan AkinBAL-6
38Drew PomeranzLAA+29
39Tommy KahnleBOS-
40Yennier CanoBAL-20
41Edwin UcetaTB-16
42Robert GarciaTEX-24
43Bryan KingHOU+2
44Phil MatonCHC+4
45Kyle LeahySTL+2
46Jose A. FerrerSEA+4
47Kevin GinkelARI+21
48Huascar BrazobánNYM+3
49Michel OtañezTEX-6
50Jake BirdNYY+21
51Mason Fluharty
T6
TOR+48
52Brad KellerPHI+12
53Kaleb OrtLAA+12
54Ryne StanekSTL-1
55John SchreiberKC+17
56Chad Green+10
57Orion KerkeringPHI-22
58Tony SantillanCIN-14
59Kyle HarrisonMIL+32
60Aaron BummerATL+10
61Lake BacharMIA+8
62Jackson RutledgeWSH+14
63Yariel RodriguezTOR+24
64Anthony BenderMIA+30
65Manuel RodríguezTB-3
66Andrew KittredgeBAL+UR
67Erik MillerSF+UR
68Cole SandsMIN+UR
69Ryan BoruckiSF-12
70Tyler HoltonDET-28
71Tim Herrin
T7
CLE-12
72Taylor RogersMIN+20
73Bennett SousaHOU+24
74Reed GarrettNYM-36
75Yuki MatsuiSD-42
76Ian HamiltonATL-15
77Seranthony DomínguezCWS+13
78Daysbel HernándezATL-23
79JoJo RomeroSTL+16
80Greg WeissertBOS-17
81Scott BlewettSTL+UR
82Carlos VargasSEA+UR
83Sean ReynoldsSD+UR
84Ryan ThompsonARI+4
85Jonathan LoáisigaARI+UR
86Juan MorilloARI+UR
87Cole HenryWSH+9
88Jack DreyerLAD-11
89Max KranickSD+UR
90Joey CantilloCLE+UR
91Caleb FergusonCIN+UR
92Mitch SpenceKC+UR
93Justin WilsonNYY+UR
94Caleb ThielbarCHC+UR
95Tanner BanksPHI+UR
96Shaun AndersonLAA+UR
97Cionel PérezWSH+UR
98Jorge Alcala+UR
99Justin Sterner-41
100Gregory SotoPIT-11

 

SP Eligible Relievers

Subscribe to the Pitcher List Newsletter

Your daily update on everything Pitcher List

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

Account / Login