+

The Hold Up 9/4: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking baseball's top setup men for the 2025 season.

Cole Sands was not having quite the season I’d hoped for after last years breakout campaign, at least that was until the Twins traded away everyone else in their bullpen. Since Sands has moved back into a high leverage role (16 innings), he holds a 2.81 ERA (2.17 SIERA), 0.88 WHIP and 38.1% K rate. No other Twin reliever has a K-BB rate over 12.2% since the trade deadline, yet Sands is at 30.2%. He should start seeing save chances shortly and could be the favorite for saves heading into 2026 unless the team adds a veteran or two this off season (they probably will).

Speaking of slept on relievers, since being recalled back on June 25th, Matt Svanson holds a 1.29 ERA (2.93 SIERA) and 0.74 WHIP and 30.2% K rate over 35 innings. That’s a large sample size and the stuff backs up his performance with a 111 Stuff+ over that span. I don’t love him as a closer necessarily, but given the other options in the Cardinals bullpen, I’d give him the edge of JoJo Romero and others.

 

Notes

  • Only one Reds reliever has a WHIP under 1.20 and K-BB rate above 20% since the All-Star break and that is Tony Santillan. He’s also the only reliever here over that span to produce an xFIP under 4.20 (3.11) as the rest of the bullpen has struggled since the break. Right now Santillan is looking like the favorite to open up 2026 in the closer role, but he could get competition from a healthy Graham Ashcraft or off season acquisition.

 

  • Daniel Palencia continues to battle through his save chances, but the two guys in front of him continue to excel in their roles. Brad Keller has not allowed an earned run over 19.1 innings since the All-Star break, while his 0.47 WHIP and 33.8% K rate over this span are also impressive. Andrew Kittredge holds a 2.17 xFIP and 29.4% K-BB since the beginning of August and has been the teams best swing and miss reliever lately.

 

  • Theres nothing to be concerned about with Edwin Diaz in New York but the rest of that bullpen has been less than ideal since making multiple deals at the deadline to shore things up. For starters, Ryan Helsley continues to struggle and now holds an 11.45 ERA and 2.45 WHIP in 11 innings with his new team and just a 21% K rate. There are concerns he is tipping his pitches, but so far we have not seen a solution to the problem. Gregory Soto and Tyler Rogers have been fine at limiting runs, but their 1.46 and 1.29 respective WHIPS are a bit concerning.

 

  • Shawn Armstrong has taken over the closer role in Texas for the time being, but I’m not totally out on Phil Maton and Robert Garcia yet. Both have ERA’s north of five since August 1st, but they also have SIERA’s of 2.90 and 3.10 and K-BB rates over 20% still. Chris Martin is also back this week and should see plenty of hold chances but he’s likely to remain out of the closer role.

 

 

 

Rank Pitcher TeamChange
1Mason MillerT1SD-
2Devin WilliamsNYM-
3Edwin UcetaTB-
4Adrian MorejonSD-
5Jeremiah EstradaSD-
6Luke WeaverNYM-
7Gabe SpeierSEA+2
8Garrett WhitlockBOS+2
9Reid DetmersLAA+2
10Garrett CleavingerTB+2
11Griffin Jax
T2
TB-4
12Blake TreinenLAD+1
13Matt StrahmKC+2
14Bryan BakerTB+2
15Matt BrashSEA+2
16Fernando CruzNYY+2
17Aaron AshbyMIL+2
18Steven OkertHOU-4
19Tony SantillanCIN+6
20Brad KellerPHI+8
21Seranthony Domínguez
T3
CWS+2
22Dylan LeeATL-1
23Brendon LittleTOR-3
24Erik SabrowskiCLE-2
25Pierce JohnsonCIN-1
26Chris MartinTEX+UR
27Phil MatonCHC-
28Justin SlatenBOS+1
29Andrew KittredgeBAL+7
30Louis VarlandTOR-4
31Tyler RogersTOR+1
32Caleb ThielbarCHC-2
33Hunter GaddisCLE-2
34David Robertson-1
35Robert StephensonLAA-
36Isaac Mattson
T4
PIT+5
37Bryan KingHOU+6
38Brooks RaleyNYM+11
39Riley O’BrienSTL+1
40Robert GarciaTEX+10
41Ryan HelsleyBAL-4
42Gregory SotoPIT-4
43José AlvaradoPHI-4
44Orion KerkeringPHI-2
45Jared KoenigMIL+12
46Cole SandsMIN+22
47Matt SvansonSTL+18
48Mason MontgomeryPIT+7
49Lucas ErcegKC-2
50Camilo DovalNYY-2
51Ben Casparius
T5
LAD-7
52Tanner BanksPHI-6
53Michael KopechSD+UR
54Kirby YatesLAA-2
55Lake BacharMIA-2
56Angel ZerpaMIL+3
57Justin WilsonNYY+5
58Steven MatzTB+12
59Jack DreyerLAD+13
60Yennier CanoBAL+14
61Rafael MonteroNYY+12
62Scott Barlow-8
63Mark Leiter Jr.+8
64Yariel RodriguezTOR+11
65Tyler HoltonDET-5
66Dietrich EnnsBAL+10
67Tyler PhillipsMIA+14
68Eduard BazardoSEA+11
69Tommy NanceTOR+27
70Grant TaylorCWS-6
71Elvis Alvarado
T6
-8
72Edgardo HenriquezLAD-3
73José ButtóSF-6
74Cole HenryWSH+19
75Justin Sterner+17
76Tyler KinleyATL+4
77Matt FestaCLE+12
78Taylor ClarkeARI+17
79Joel PegueroSF+19
80Kyle LeahySTL+17
81John SchreiberKC-15
82Ryan ZeferjahnLAA+5
83Caleb FergusonCIN-25
84Drew PomeranzLAA-28
85Shawn DubinWSH+UR
86Nic EnrightTOR-8
87Anthony BandaMIN-10
88Dauri MoretaSD+UR
89Luis GarciaNYY-6
90Brandon EisertCWS-2
91Hoby MilnerCHC-30
92David MorganSD+2
93Jimmy HergetCOL-3
94Kyle NicolasCIN-3
95Rico GarciaBAL+UR
96Kaleb OrtLAA+UR
97Zach MaxwellCIN+2
98Craig KimbrelNYM+UR
99Ryne StanekSTL+1
100Ryan ThompsonARI+UR

 

SP Eligible Relievers

Subscribe to the Pitcher List Newsletter

Your daily update on everything Pitcher List

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

Account / Login