+

The Hold Up 8/14: Ranking the Top 100 Relievers for Holds Every Thursday

Ranking baseball's top setup men for the 2025 season.

The Phillies bullpen got some more help this past weekend as David Robertson was added to the active roster Sunday. I don’t have the highest expectations for the 40 year old, as his velo is down about 3 MPH and we are already in mid-August, so the clock is ticking for him to get back to his normal self and make an impact before the season ends. His presence mostly provides competition to Jordan Romano for secondary hold chances, which could be fewer and farther between once José Alvarado returns next week. The addition of Jhoan Duran has helped Orion Kerkering finally settle into a set role now and it’s showing. Over his past four games, Kerkering has six strikeouts and no walks, allowing just two hits over those four innings. Small sample size and all, those are the kind of ratio’s we were expecting from Kerkering leading up to this year.

 

Notes

  • I talked about the Yankees bullpen situation a little bit earlier this week, but figuring out the hierarchy behind David Bednar is another task. Luke Weaver has looked great lately, and is definitely benefiting from the bullpen additions at the deadline. I’m still not ready to completely give up on Devin Williams, who hasn’t allowed a baserunner over his last two outings while striking out four, but what his role will be over the next month and a half is totally up in the air. The stuff is still there, and if you take away that terrible stretch from late July through early August, he’s been a top 5-10 reliever since late April.

 

  • Griffin Jax now has a 4.76 ERA and 1.29 WHIP on the season, so I understand being frustrated and not wanting to roster this roller coaster moving forward…BUT…the stuff is still there and all the underlying metrics show he’s been severely unlucky. Jax holds 35.7% strikeout (ranks 10th), 19.2% swinging-strike (6th), and 36.5% CSW (3rd) rates on the year, and his 5.47 PLV mark is first amongst all relievers. His 1.84 xFIP and 2.09 SIERA are also first amongst relievers on the season. I still have hope he can finish the year strong and he’s setting up to be a prime sleeper target in 2026 drafts.

 

  • Gabe Speier continues to just dominant from the left side for the Mariners, but that bullpen could get an even bigger boost in Matt Brash becoming his normal self again, as the talented righty is starting to miss bats again just like he used to. In Brash’s first 16.1 innings this season, he was sitting 95-96 MPH with his fastball and held just 26% strikeout and 9.5% swinging-strike rates overall (3.24 xFIP). Over his past 15.1 innings though, Brash has been closer to 96-97 MPH and it’s led to 29% strikeout and 14.2% swinging-strike rates (and a 2.99 xFIP). Even more recently, Brash has racked up eight strikeouts over his past 4.2 innings as he continues trending in the right direction.

 

  • Yariel Rodríguez is not trending in the right direction, as the Jays reliever has allowed six earned runs over his past three innings of work, and just hasn’t been the same guy since the All-Star break. Over his past 7.2 innings, Rodríguez holds an 8.22 ERA (7.58 SIERA), 1.83 WHIP, and a -13.5% K-BB rate (5.4% strikeout rate). Even with Seranthony Domínguez also struggling in this bullpen, there are just too many other options here to justify hanging on to Rodríguez at this point. Louis Varland and Braydon Fisher are much better options at this point.

 

 

Rank Pitcher TeamChange
1Mason MillerT1SD-
2Abner UribeMIL+2
3Jeremiah EstradaSD+3
4Adrian MorejonSD+3
5Edwin UcetaTB-
6Luke WeaverNYM+8
7Devin WilliamsNYM+UR
8Griffin JaxTB-6
9Gabe SpeierSEA+2
10Jason AdamSD+3
11Garrett Whitlock
T2
BOS-2
12Reid DetmersLAA-4
13Bennett SousaHOU+7
14Dylan LeeATL+3
15Garrett CleavingerTB+1
16Louis VarlandTOR+8
17Matt BrashSEA+11
18Ryan HelsleyBAL-8
19Blake TreinenLAD-7
20Matt StrahmKC+1
21Steven OkertHOU-3
22Brendon LittleTOR-3
23Bryan BakerTB-
24Erik SabrowskiCLE+1
25Pierce JohnsonCIN+6
26Aaron Ashby
T3
MIL+1
27Gregory SotoPIT-1
28Tyler RogersTOR+2
29Seranthony DomínguezCWS-7
30Danny CoulombeBOS+2
31Braydon FisherTOR-2
32Hunter GaddisCLE+2
33Caleb ThielbarCHC+3
34Ryan WalkerSF+5
35Tony SantillanCIN-2
36Camilo DovalNYY-1
37Andrew KittredgeBAL+8
38Shawn ArmstrongCLE+6
39Lake BacharMIA+7
40Orion KerkeringPHI+18
41Brooks Raley
T4
NYM+6
42Shelby MillerCHC-5
43Graham AshcraftCIN+9
44Ben CaspariusLAD-4
45Riley O’BrienSTL+5
46Isaac MattsonPIT+3
47Grant AndersonMIL-6
48Bryan KingHOU-5
49Reed GarrettNYM-1
50Brad KellerPHI+3
51Lucas ErcegKC+5
52Hoby MilnerCHC+11
53Tanner BanksPHI+8
54Mason MontgomeryPIT-3
55Yennier CanoBAL+4
56Scott Barlow
T5
ATH-2
57Anthony BenderMIA-2
58Nick MearsKC-1
59Caleb FergusonCIN+3
60Mark Leiter Jr.-
61Tyler HoltonDET+5
62Elvis Alvarado+7
63Drew PomeranzLAA+4
64Justin WilsonNYY+4
65Anthony BandaMIN+5
66Angel ZerpaMIL+7
67David MorganSD+4
68Jordan LeasureCWS+UR
69Jared KoenigMIL+11
70David Robertson+UR
71Yariel Rodriguez
T6
TOR-29
72Jordan RomanoLAA-8
73Jack DreyerLAD+1
74Ryne StanekSTL+1
75Tyler PhillipsMIA-10
76Rafael MonteroNYY-
77Jordan HicksCWS-5
78Wandy PeraltaSD-
79Taylor RogersMIN-
80José ButtóSF+3
81Cole HenryWSH+UR
82Andrew HoffmannARI+7
83Kyle LeahySTL+UR
84Aaron BummerATL+3
85Mason FluhartyTOR+UR
86Brandon EisertCWS-5
87Steven MatzTB-3
88Brock BurkeCIN+4
89Tyler KinleyATL+2
90Matt SvansonSTL+UR
91Edgardo HenriquezLAD+UR
92Luis GarciaNYY+1
93John SchreiberKC+UR
94Kaleb OrtLAA+1
95Eduard BazardoSEA+3
96Nic EnrightTOR-8
97Andrew SaalfrankARI+UR
98Kyle BackhusPHI+UR
99Jon Gray-14
100Alexis DíazTEX+UR

 

SP Eligible Relievers

Subscribe to the Pitcher List Newsletter

Your daily update on everything Pitcher List

Rick Graham

Rick resides in the Boston area and has experience as a player and coach at the collegiate level. He has been covering relievers for Pitcher List since 2017.

Account / Login